When it comes to the WPIAL playoffs, there is no perfect world.

In the past, the league would conduct its pairings meeting the first part of the week and Class AAAA teams wouldn't play preliminary- or first-round games until the following Monday or Tuesday. That wasn't the case this season.

The pairings meeting was Feb. 5 and Class AAAA teams played first-round games last Friday and Saturday. Quarterfinal contests for the winners won't be played until tomorrow.

So, was it better for teams to play three or four days after the pairings meeting or better to have a long layoff before their first postseason contest?

Advertise with us

"In talking to guys, I think it was better the way it was before," Central Catholic coach Chuck Crummie said. "You had that long break but once you started playing you kept playing.

"This year they changed it up. I think most guys were surprised that we played right away, but now you sit and wait a week before playing again. Once you get into the playoffs, you want to keep going."

Central Catholic's final regular-season game was Feb. 1 against Fox Chapel. Its first playoff contest was last Friday against Latrobe. The Vikings play Canon-McMillan at 8 p.m. tomorrow at Chartiers Valley High School.

WPIAL executive director Tim O'Malley said there was no conscious effort made to have Class AAAA teams compete earlier in the playoffs.

"It was just the way it worked out," he said. "Site availability played a part in it."

Advertise with us

One of the problems Class AAAA teams encountered this week is finding other schools to scrimmage. A team is allowed to scrimmage other teams that are still in the playoffs.

"It's hard because the Class AAA and AA teams were playing during the week, so they don't want to scrimmage," he said. "You don't want to scrimmage [Quad-A] teams on your side of the bracket. So, for us, that leaves teams on the other side like Moon, Franklin Regional, Norwin and North Allegheny and you're a little leery about doing that."

That leaves the nine Class A teams still in the playoffs. Seven of them had a week between games, but Crummie said most Class A teams don't want to scrimmage Class AAAA schools.

"They don't want to hurt their players' confidence," he said.

"In the old days, you could give the players a day or two off and then get in a scrimmage or two before playing that first [playoff] game. Now, you have the extra days in the middle."

Advertise with us

Big difference

There seems to be a healthy groundswell that too many teams qualify for the WPIAL basketball playoffs. Looking at what happened in the first round Class A girls' playoff games this past weekend might just give some ammunition to those who want to reduce the playoff field.

The most glaring distance between two teams was a matchup between No. 1 seed North Catholic, which entered the playoffs with a 20-4 record, and Cornell, which came in with a 7-11 overall mark and didn't have a winning record in Section 1-A.

Well, North Catholic rocketed to a 61-6 victory and the truth is, it could have been much worse if it wasn't for two factors -- the mercy rule and Trojanettes coach Molly Rottmann substituting liberally.

While there wasn't that big of a difference in the margin of victory in all the Class A girls' first-round games, blowouts were the norm.

Advertise with us

Consider this: In the eight games, the average margin of victory was exactly 30 points, with the winners averaging 63.9 points and the losers just 33.9. And most of those games were finished early, with the winning teams putting the losers away with runs right out of the gate. The average lead at halftime was 19.5 points and of the eight games, four of the losing teams had 11 or fewer points at halftime.

Also, of the eight losing teams in that girls' Class A bracket, just two -- Rochester and Clairton -- scored more than 39 points.

While on the subject

>

Want more examples on how the WPIAL tournament has too many teams? Check this out.

Advertise with us

The top four teams in each section qualify for the playoffs, right? Well, in the boys' and girls' Class AAAA and A portions of the tournament only three fourth-place teams -- Monaca boys, Peters Township and Avonworth girls -- advanced to the quarterfinals tomorrow night and just three third-place teams -- Upper St. Clair boys, Oakland Catholic and Vincentian girls -- moved on.

OK, so the idea is to keep interest in the section races into the second half of the regular season. Having four teams from each section qualify for the playoffs does that, but isn't it obvious that the top two teams in each section have a better shot of getting to the quarterfinals?

On the other side

In all fairness, the idea of sending the top four teams in each section to the playoffs does have its merits.

The West Allegheny boys were fourth in their section last season and won the WPIAL Class AAA title. And all four of the girls' teams in Section 4 made it to the Class A semifinals.