Matt Clement spent nine years as a major league pitcher, made the All-Star Game once and amassed 87 career wins.

Clement knows baseball, and he also knows Connor Ollio, who, just like Clement was 25 years earlier, is a talented senior on the Butler High School baseball team.

“He’s a unique talent,” said Clement, a volunteer assistant at Butler. “I’ll tell you how much of a unique talent. I still don’t know what he projects as at the next levels. And when I say levels, I mean college and professional.”

Will Ollio eventually play in the big leagues? It’s possible. Does his versatility as a standout pitcher and hitter make him the second coming of Brendan McKay? McKay’s high school numbers and accolades may never be matched locally. But there’s no denying Ollio is one of the WPIAL’s top players, one who is headed to a big-time college program and could be chosen in the MLB amateur draft in June.

Advertise with us

“I’ve always been working to get drafted. Playing professionally has been a dream of mine since I was 3 years old,” Ollio said. “Any opportunity to make that come true, I try my hardest. This season, I’m focused on getting better.”

Ollio is a well-spoken 17-year-old who lives in Connoquenessing Township. He has been a star coming up through the youth ranks and a key cog on the high school team since his freshman season. A 6-foot-2, 205-pound pitcher-shortstop, Ollio signed with the University of North Carolina in November.

“I feel like Connor has had a lot of pressure on him for a long time. He was so young and a big part of the high school team,” said Butler first-year coach Cody Herald, an assistant the previous two seasons.

Ollio has also shined nationally and internationally. He spends two months each summer playing for the Central Florida Gators. The team competes in tournaments throughout the country. The summer before his sophomore season, he helped Team USA win a gold medal at the COPABE Pan Am Championships in Mexico. He boasted a 1.20 ERA in two starts and hit a team-best .636.

“The things that he’s been able to do at such a young age. To be a 15-year-old and win the gold medal as a pitcher and also being one of the top hitters. That’s a unique talent,” Clement said.

Advertise with us

As a junior, Ollio went 3-3 with a 0.97 ERA. In 36 innings, he gave up 14 hits, 5 earned runs, 17 walks and struck out 51. Opponents hit just .120 against him. Offensively, he batted .362 with a .500 on-base percentage. In 74 plate appearances, he drew 14 walks and struck out only six times. Ollio earned all-section honors as a pitcher in one of the WPIAL’s top sections (Class 6A Section 1).

Ollio made what he called “an incredibly tough” decision in November. He had played basketball since fourth grade and was a member of Butler’s varsity team his first three years. But he chose not to play his senior season in order to concentrate on weight training and baseball-related activities. Ollio said he waited until the last minute to inform Clement, the school’s basketball coach who has served as a mentor to Ollio. Ollio said he has packed on 20 pounds of muscle since last season.

Ollio isn’t overpowering on the mound or at the plate. A right-hander, he consistently throws his fastball 89 mph and topped off last season at 93. He relies on hitting his spots and fooling hitters with his off-speed pitches. At the plate, he’s a contact hitter who puts the ball in gaps. He has shown increased power recently, though.

“That could be an interesting dynamic if he adds a lot of power,” Clement said.

In addition to being Butler’s ace, he’ll play shortstop when he’s not on the mound. Even he doesn’t know where he will end up playing in college. It could be as a pitcher and infielder.

Advertise with us

“When [North Carolina] recruited me, they said they’d give me the opportunity to do both, play a position in the field and be a pitcher,” Ollio said.

One thing that has eluded Ollio in high school has been a playoff win. Butler went 14-7 and lost in the first round of the WPIAL playoffs last season. But with 12 seniors, including at least seven who will play in college, this could be the year Butler breaks through with a big season.

“He has a drive,” Herald said. “He’s coming every day and getting better. A lot of kids you hear about who commit to a big college, when they’re seniors they want to sit back and relax. Connor is a go-getter. He knows he has skills and he wants to get better.”