UNIVERSITY PARK, Pa. — South Side Beaver’s McKenna Smith delivered a pitch, Minersville standout Adrienne Kroznuskie swung and popped out to second base.
But umpires called an illegal pitch on Smith, and Kroznuskie got to hit again. The very next offering from Smith landed over the left-field fence.
Kroznuskie took advantage of her second chance, and her solo home run put a charge into Minersville in the third inning. The Miners then surged with three more runs in the frame and defeated South Side Beaver, 4-1, in the PIAA Class 2A softball championship Thursday at Penn State’s Beard Field.
The win gave Minersville (24-2) its 10th PIAA title, but knocking off the No. 2 team from the WPIAL didn’t come without controversy. That illegal pitch was one of 10 called on Smith, South Side Beaver’s star senior. South Side Beaver had more illegal pitches than Minersville had hits (six). The illegal pitches were called by the first base umpire.
“It comes down to Minersville just had four extra players on their team, and one in particular who had a lot of pull,” said South Side Beaver coach Amy Pieto, in reference to the umpires. “You’re talking about four extra players who stand around the field and contribute in some way or another. Without them, we play a back-yard game and who knows what happens?”
Smith also had illegal pitches called against her in the PIAA semifinals against Chartiers-Houston. Against Minersville, only once did Pieto come out of the dugout and question the calls.
Read More
“It’s not going to do any good. They’re not going to change their calls,” Pieto said. “We’ve had only three games the entire season where she had illegal pitches called. Two against Chartiers-Houston and this one.”
Pieto said the first few illegal pitches were called because Smith was putting her hands together in her glove before she stepped on the rubber. But most of the illegal pitches were for “crow hopping,” which is illegal when pitching softball. In other words, Smith was allegedly leaping into her pitches.
“We had them scouted and our scouts had it on video where she was crow hopping,” Minersville coach Dave Homa said. “Our defense was excellent, but let’s face it. The key to the game was we got a [illegal pitch] call on a popup — and then we got a bomb. That electrified everyone on our side, and for one inning we rolled with it.”
Smith tried to be diplomatic.
“I do not believe I was crow hopping, but obviously the umpire sees something,” Smith said. “I respect what he saw.”
Pieto wasn’t as diplomatic.
“Of course the calls affected [Smith]. It affected the whole game,” Pieto said. “Without the illegal pitch call, they may not have hit a home run. Then their entire fan base starts chanting, ‘crow hop.’ That’s truly poor sportsmanship. We play softball, not technicalities. It would be great if other people played softball, too.”
After Kroznuskie’s homer, Maggie Wigoda hit a sacrifice fly, and Kaylee King a two-run single.
South Side Beaver (20-4), making its first PIAA championship appearance, took a 1-0 lead in the top of the third when Smith drew a bases-loaded walk. South Side Beaver finished with eight hits and was not overpowered by Minersville pitcher Maura Bentz, who struck out five.
Despite the loss, it was a tremendous season for South Side Beaver, making the PIAA title game for the first time. The Rams, who also lost in the WPIAL final, had only 12 players this season. But two left the team recently and the Rams dressed only 10 for the PIAA final.
“Just to be here was amazing,” Pieto said. “It was amazing for the kids, the school, just everybody.”
Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.