The first day of his senior year, Luke Chutko went to North Hills’ fall sports pep rally.

He ended up representing the soccer team in a field goal competition, prompting football coaches to ask him if he’d be interested in kicking for the football team.

Chutko was already a starter on the Indians’ varsity soccer, baseball and basketball teams, all of which made the playoffs his junior and senior seasons, but sure, why not add a fourth playoff-bound sport?

“It’s not so much that he’s playing three or four sports, or a member of three or four teams, but that the teams that he’s on are all having success,” basketball coach Buzz Gabos said. “And he always plays a part in that. You don’t see that in high school sports anymore.”

Advertise with us

In Chutko’s sophomore year, North Hills’ soccer and basketball teams went to the playoffs and baseball narrowly missed the postseason. Combine that with his upperclassmen years, and Chutko has been a member of nine varsity playoff teams in his high school career.

It’s a rare feat, partially because athletes tend to specialize in one sport as they get closer to college and potential scholarships. Despite signing to play baseball at Allegheny College next year, Chutko hasn’t dropped his other sports for baseball.

He has been playing soccer since age 4, baseball since age 6 and basketball since around age 8. Chutko gets it all the time: “Why not pick one?” After tasting success his sophomore seasons and growing up playing with several of his high school teammates, though, Chutko couldn’t picture himself hanging up either set of cleats. Or his sneakers.

“I just realized it was so hard to give one up,” he said. “How do you just drop one?”

In 10th grade, Chutko lost a soccer playoff one night and was in the gym the next day.

Advertise with us

“I kind of said to myself ‘This is how it’s going to be for three more years.’”

While being a multi-sport athlete stretched his schedule thin, he never faced pressure from his coaches to drop other sports and focus on theirs.

In fact, challenging himself to refine different skill sets may have helped Chutko to succeed on different playing fields, baseball coach Randy Miller said.

“There’s something in each of those sports that help you develop, whether it’s hand-eye coordination, whether it’s flexibility, all the different facets that you need in an athlete,” Miller said.

After last season, Miller had a conversation with Chutko about what he would need out of him senior year. Chutko had already played catcher for two seasons, and was college-bound at that position, but the team needed him at first base and as a reliever on the mound, too.

Advertise with us

“A lot of kids may have said ‘I’m going to college. Put me at catcher,’” Miller said. “That might be a problem. Not Luke. Luke just looked at me and goes ‘Coach, wherever you need me, wherever I can help the team.’”

Through the Indians’ 20-2 defeat of Obama Academy on April 28, Chutko has yet to allow an earned run.

Being a successful multi-sport athlete helped him learn to manage his time, of course. According to his dad, Mark Chutko, it also helped him become a leader and take on more responsibility.

“He wasn’t leaning on someone else, people were more leaning on him,” his dad said. “And I think that’s a reflection just on the leader that he was.”

As baseball season winds down, Chutko’s three- or four-sport days at North Hills draw to a close and he steps closer to playing baseball at Allegheny. He doesn’t know how he feels about that yet.

Advertise with us

But he sees how his time as a North Hills athlete shaped his perspective.

“It has made me the man I am today,” Chutko said. “I’m a lot more grateful for a lot of things than I was before, because not a lot of kids get the opportunity that I’ve gotten. I realize how lucky I am to play three, four sports at the highest level in high school.”