The following is one in a series of reports looking at the WPIAL’s realignment for the 2016-17 school year. This week’s focus: softball.
October is a rare month for any significant high school softball news to take place, so when the PIAA board of directors met one day last fall to discuss football realignment, few expected softball to even enter the conversation.
That’s precisely when the sport was thrown an unprecedented changeup.
Goodbye, four classifications. Hello, six.
Softball, like football, baseball and boys and girls basketball, saw its classification format expand by two. The decision was made partly in hopes of leveling the playing field by further grouping schools with similar enrollments. The expanded classes will begin this upcoming school year.
The change has earned mixed reviews from WPIAL softball coaches, some of whom sounded off about the pros and cons of the move and how they see the decision playing out.
Read More
“It is what it is. There’s nothing we can do about it,” said Gary Rozanski, coach of WPIAL Class AA champion Ellwood City, which will compete in Class 3A. “I understand why they did it. I think with our sport, it’s not as bad as other sports. But I think everything is going to be more competitive top to bottom.”
Under the four-classification format, the classes included 30, 32, 35 and 30 teams. In the new format, the classes include 19, 22, 20, 18, 26 and 21 teams. West Shamokin moved to District 6. There are three sections in five of the six classes. Class 2A has four sections. Like in previous years, the top four teams in each section will qualify for the playoffs.
Hempfield, last season’s WPIAL and PIAA Class AAAA champion, moved to Class 6A and will be joined by six other teams that reached the WPIAL Class AAAA quarterfinals. The other quarterfinalist, Penn-Trafford, is in Class 5A. The teams in 6A combined to win each of the past 12 WPIAL Class AAAA championships.
“I’m not a big fan due to the fact that it cuts back the number of teams in the classification,” Hempfield coach Bob Kalp said. “A lot of people look at it like those teams [that dropped a class] weren’t quality teams. But that wasn’t the case. Connellsville and Penn-Trafford were in our section and they were every bit as good as we were. The prize of winning the WPIAL is a big prize, but it won’t be as hard because the field will be reduced.”
West Allegheny was a WPIAL Class AAA finalist in 2016 and one of 12 former Class AAA teams heading to Class 5A.
“I just think that with any change, there will be some good and some bad come out of it,” West Allegheny coach Mindi McFate said. “It’s nice to have more teams qualify for the playoffs. At the same time, it kind of devalues being a playoff team. For us going to 5A, it’s mainly staying the same. From a competition standpoint, it’s going to remain competitive in the class. It might help some schools who were kind of on the fence.”
Lengthier bus rides are a concern for some teams. The most extreme example might be Steel Valley, which finds itself in a section with Beaver County schools Beaver Falls, Ellwood City, Freedom and Riverside.
“The travel is going to be tough,” Steel Valley coach Matt Janov said. “It stinks there are four teams within 20 minutes of each other — Steel Valley, South Park, South Allegheny and East Allegheny — now in three different sections. The traveling is going to be tough going all the way to Ellwood City and Beaver Falls. It’s not ideal, but we’re going to go and do the best we can against who they put us up against.”
On the other hand, some teams are reunited with familiar foes. WPIAL Class A champion West Greene is in 1A and in the same section as Carmichaels, which was in Class AA last season. Fellow Greene County schools Jefferson-Morgan and Mapletown are also in that section.
“We weren’t in favor of 6A, but now that it’s here, there’s no reason not to embrace it,” West Greene coach Bill Simms said.
The overwhelming sentiment is that while things will be more balanced enrollment-wise and more teams will make the playoffs, the teams competing for WPIAL titles year in and year out will remain largely the same.
“I don’t think [reclassification] was a good thing,” said Dutch Harvey, who coached Yough to WPIAL and PIAA Class AAA titles this past season. “I think it was done for other sports and it carried over to softball. The better programs are still going to be the better programs even with the other classifications. The bottom line is that if you have pitching you’ll be able to compete no matter where you’re at.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.