Deer Lakes could not have imagined itself to be in a better position than it was in the PIAA Class AA softball championship game.

Not only did the Lancers have a one-run lead in the bottom of the fourth inning against District 2 champion Holy Redeemer, they had a first-team all-state pitcher on the rubber in Seton Hill recruit Tiffany Edwards, a defense that had played almost flawlessly throughout the season and, to top it off, an offense that had proven it can score nearly at will.

Then the bottom fell out.

Deer Lakes (24-2) uncharacteristically made several mistakes, with a wild pitch, an error, a passed ball and a couple of mental mistakes that allowed the Royals to post a five-run rally that chased Edwards and helped Holy Redeemer to a 10-5 victory at Penn State University’s Beard Field.

Advertise with us

“I think it was a combination of things and they were an excellent team and they had some pretty good talent,” Deer Lakes coach Craig Taliani said. “We had a poor showing in the fourth inning and had five errors on the board and there’s no team in the world that’s going to win a state championship with five errors. They put pressure on us to make plays and, that inning, we really didn’t execute as well as we could have.”

Over the past four years, Deer Lakes has come on to be the premier team in WPIAL Class AA. The Lancers are 81-8 in that span, won WPIAL titles in 2012 and 2015 and lost in the title game to Riverside in 2013 and to Beaver last season, but have struggled mightily in the state tournament.

Despite four consecutive appearances in the PIAA Class AA playoffs, this was the first time the Lancers made it past the second round and they needed a come-from-behind extra-inning victory against Cambridge Springs in the semifinals to make it into the championship game for the first time in school history.

Even though they lost by five runs in the state championship game, the Lancers were 20-1 in their final 21 games and outscored their opponents by an aggregate score of 234-41. Their offensive prowess is one of the reasons why they had six players earn all-state honors, three on both the first and second teams, and had a starting lineup that featured nine starters with averages of at least .370 and five that hit better than .400.

“I think there would be a lot of teams that would trade places with us in a heartbeat,” Taliani said. “I think we’ve accomplished a nice run here. If we could win a state championship every year that would be great, but realistically, that doesn’t happen.”

Advertise with us

Next season, though, could be that year.

Though Deer Lakes will lose both Edwards and shortstop Katie Gozzard to graduation, it will bring back seven starters including outfielder Maria Taliani who hit three home runs in the WPIAL Class AA championship game. Sophomore pitcher Shae Robson also got some experience pitching in relief in the state title game and could be a candidate for the starting job in 2016.

“The girls know what it takes to get to the state finals and they know what it takes to win it,” Taliani said. “They’re going to do everything they can to get back there.”