Not long after the game, Shaler pitcher Jake Potock and his teammates were shooed off the field to their bus because of approaching bad weather. Moments after the Titans boarded the bus, the skies opened, thunder clapped and lightning struck.

Potock provided the calm before the storm.

He silenced a usually strong Plum offense like no WPIAL pitcher has in the past two years. You barely heard a peep from the Mustangs as Potock pitched a gem and led Shaler to a 1-0 victory in a WPIAL Class AAAA quarterfinal at Fox Chapel. Shaler scored an unearned run in the fourth inning.

Potock, a broad-shouldered, 6-foot-5, 230-pound senior right-hander, pitched a three-hitter and struck out nine. He was the first WPIAL pitcher to shut out Plum since 2013, and his performance put Shaler (17-4) into the semifinals for the first time since 2003. Second-seeded Plum finished 19-3 with two of the losses against Shaler. The other was April 1. This one was no fool’s joke.

Advertise with us

“Plum’s a really good offensive team,” said Potock. “No way did I think one run would do it.”

For Potock, the win provided a little bit of revenge. Two years ago, Shaler lost to Plum, 2-1, in a first-round game at the same Fox Chapel field. Potock was the losing pitcher.

Potock, a West Virginia University recruit now 5-3, wasn’t sure he would get the call against Plum this time. He was the winning pitcher in a first-round game last Wednesday.

“I didn’t know I was pitching until [Sunday],” said Potock. “I thought we might go with Gavin Cannon because he beat Plum the last time this season.”

But Shaler coach Brian Junker went with Potock. Good choice.

Advertise with us

“He was lights out, really every single inning,” said Junker.

Potock threw first-pitch strikes to 18 batters. But one of the biggest keys for Potock was his changeup.

“My changeup hadn’t been as good near the end of the season, and I had really been working on it,” said Potock.

Potock retired the side in order five times. Plum threatened in the second inning when Ethan Winesburgh led off with a double. The Mustangs had runners on second and third with one out before Potock got a strikeout and a flyout to right field to end the inning.

Plum had only one baserunner the rest of the game.

Advertise with us

“I think when you consider everything, this was his best game without a doubt,” said Junker. “His curveball goes this way, his changeup that way and his fastball has some movement. His fastball was on, his curve was on and his change was on. So he made it easy to call pitches.”

Shaler had five hits off two Plum pitchers, and the Titans scored the only run in the fourth. Anthony Venezia singled and moved to third on a throwing error. David Pietropola’s one-out single drove him home.

The previous time Shaler made it to the semifinals 12 years ago, the Titans made it to the WPIAL title game before losing to North Allegheny.

For more on high school sports, go to “Varsity Blog” at www.post-gazette.com/varsityblog. Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1975 and Twitter @mwhiteburgh.