For the second consecutive year, the Western Pennsylvania Open needed extra golf before a champion could be named. It took five sudden-death holes this year, as Jimmy Gillam sunk a birdie putt on Oakmont’s No. 5 to claim the championship.

Holding a two-stroke lead coming into the day at 1-over for the tournament, the professional from Altoona rallied from a 5-over 40 on the front to force a playoff with Connor Schmidt and eventually grind out the win.

“That’s the nature of the beast,” Gillam said of his turnaround. “That’s golf. You’ve got to stick it out no matter what because you never know what could happen. That’s the beauty of the sport.”

Gillam struggled early, bogeying each of his first three holes. He missed a couple of short putts — including what turned into a three-putt on No. 2 — and found himself in danger off the tee multiple times. But he said he was happy with the way he “gutted it out.”

Advertise with us

“I just hung in there,” Gillam said. “I said at the loop when we made the turn that if we shot 3-under on the back nine, I thought we’d have a good chance of winning or be in a playoff. … All in all, I was four back at the turn after shooting 40 and if you would have told me you’d be in a playoff after this back nine, I would’ve [taken] it. So all in all, I can’t complain.”

But many of the players found problems on the front, as only two players managed to play bogey-free golf prior to making the turn. Schmidt, a junior at Drexel, was one of them. Entering the day tied for third at 4-over, he shot a 2-under 33 to position himself at the top of the leaderboard by the time he made the turn to the back.

Day 3 of the 2018 West Penn Open

“I played really solid from the start,” Schmidt said. “I knew I just needed to shoot under par. I thought I had a really good chance at like 68. That was my target number. I had it going on the front nine, only missed one green.”

But Schmidt — who at one point led by three strokes after making birdie on No. 14 — bogeyed three of the final four holes, opening the door for Gillam to make his move. He drove it into the fescue on No. 15, three-putted on No. 16, and bogeyed No. 18. Schmidt did have a chance for birdie on 17, but he missed the putt and settled for par.

“I knew on the last four [holes] I just had to get it in, but it’s not easy out here,” Schmidt said. “The last four are tough. … Just wasn’t really making anything on the back nine.”

Advertise with us

Gillam, meanwhile, surged on the back nine. He birdied Nos. 12 and 13 once again, giving him five on those two holes over the three rounds. Then, with Schmidt in the clubhouse, he managed another birdie on No. 17 to momentarily take the lead. Facing a 6-foot putt for par and the win on No. 18, however, Gillam missed.

“It was a tough putt,” Gillam said. “Left to right [break], very speedy, and I just didn’t give it enough pace and missed it low.”

The playoff holes brought Gillam back to the first tee, but he said he had already forgotten his earlier poor play on those holes.

“You have to have amnesia out here over every shot because disaster lurks on every shot that you come across on this course,” Gillam said. “I didn’t even think about that to be honest.”

After missing a putt to win on the second playoff hole, Gillam found himself in the famous “Church Pews” bunker on the third. But he managed to get out and save par, keeping his chances alive.

Advertise with us

“[I was thinking] ‘I have to make this.’ That was it,” Gillam said of his long par putt at No. 3. “Pretty simple thought, and I’m glad I did. That really took the sting out of missing the short putt on 18.”

The sting would be absolved completely just two holes later, when Schmidt missed a long par putt and Gillam made birdie to close it out.

Others who had been in the hunt entering the final day struggled. Minnesota sophomore Evan Long, who entered the day in second at 3-over, finished with a 7-over 77 to drop to a tie for 10th. Carnegie Mellon sophomore Jason Li teed off Wednesday tied for third and left tied for 19th, shooting a 9-over 79. Brett Young — son of former Penguins forward Warren Young and a Bethel Park native — started and finished the day tied for third after shooting a 72, but only after scoring birdies on two of his last three holes to rebound from his 4-over start to the back nine.

Yet, while the day might have started ugly for Gillam, it ended just as he wanted. The win isn’t his first as a pro — he has five wins in mini-tour events — but he said it “definitely tops the list” given the venue.

“This is just a special place,” Gillam said of Oakmont. “You can feel it whenever you step foot on the grounds. … It was a great week.”

Ben Padanilam: bpadanilam@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BenPadanilam