When Shane Lowry’s par putt dropped into the cup on the Oakmont Country Club’s 18th green, ending the 116th U.S. Open golf championship around twilight Sunday, the pot-bellied Irishman removed his cap and rubbed his forehead in disbelief. The gallery, which had watched the cruel course bite back at the tournament-leading Lowry all afternoon, offered a round of applause that sounded like sympathy.

Lowry had imagined a different ending. The U.S. Open had been his to lose, as he held a four-stroke lead entering Sunday’s championship round, but by the end he stopped looking at the scoreboard altogether. Dustin Johnson, playing in the pairing directly ahead of Lowry, sidestepped two bogeys and a controversial rules violation to win the Open by three strokes.

“It was there for the taking,” Lowry said after his final-round 76, “and I didn’t take it.”

He became the first player to drop a four-stroke lead on championship Sunday at the U.S. Open since Payne Stewart lost to Lee Janzen in 1998. Lowry tied for second place, at 1 under.

Advertise with us

COMPLETE COVERAGE AT POST-GAZETTE.COM/USOPEN2016

His misery was evident from the outset. With playing partner Andrew Landry melting, eventually carding an 8-over 78, the contenders were whittled. At No. 2, Johnson birdied and Lowry bogeyed, halving his lead.

The chase was on.

When Lowry crossed over the Pennsylvania Turnpike, which separated roughly one-half of the Oakmont course from the other, he smiled and chatted with caddy Dermot Byrne. He didn’t know that 500 yards ahead, at the ninth green, Johnson had just birdied to tie at 4 under.

Lowry also didn’t know that U.S. Golf Association officials were reviewing whether to assess a stroke penalty to Johnson for inadvertently making his ball move at hole No. 5. Johnson was informed of the investigation while teeing off at No. 12, and Lowry, who self-assessed a one-stroke penalty for a similar infraction earlier in the tournament, was told moments later. The rest of the round, Johnson’s score was merely an estimation. (In the end, he was penalized a stroke.)

Advertise with us

The USGA’s deliberation, set to be settled after the round’s conclusion, created a dramatic scene on the back nine. Lowry and Landry, moving quickly as the final group, watched from one shot behind as Johnson and Lee Westwood finished on the greens in the distance.

Lowry, who got his only birdie of the round at No. 12, stood in the center of the fairway at No. 14 when Johnson’s bogey made them all square at 4 under. Or was Lowry ahead? Nobody knew.

A pack of County Offaly men followed Lowry’s pairing, wearing green shirts and hoisting an Ireland flag in the air. The man staying silent, wearing a black T-shirt and a bucket hat, was his father, Brendan, the former Gaelic footballer. He chewed his nails incessantly. How were his nerves?

Gerry Dulac recaps the final of the U.S. Open

“Not good,” the father said, forcing a smile. “Not good.”

They got no better. With a major championship at his fingertips, Lowry spoiled his strong drive on No. 14 with an off-line approach shot and went on to bogey three consecutive holes.

Advertise with us

“Things just kind of spiraled out of control from there,” he said. “It was one of those where I’d give anything to have that wide shot on 14 back again.”

There are no second chances at Oakmont. That Lowry turned in a 279 was impressive on its own, given that he missed the cut at the European Tour’s BMW PGA Championship at Wentworth Club in late May. The lowlight of his second-round 78 there was a five-putt on No. 15. In a column for the Irish Times, Lowry wrote, “No, I haven’t dumped the putter in a rubbish skip anywhere.”

While the rainstorms Thursday muddied the weekend schedule, Lowry seemed unperturbed, saying, “I find the guys that are moaning about it are the guys that are going to be going home early.” He played one round over two days, then 34 holes Saturday and 20 more Sunday.

Lowry slept on a two-shot lead Saturday night, with four holes remaining in his third round. He joked, “If you would have given me four pars, I would have stayed in bed,” but rather he rattled off two birdies to turn in a third-round 65, tied for the best round of the tournament. His 7 under par equaled the 54-hole scoring record for U.S. Opens at Oakmont set by Ernie Els in 1994.

Between rounds, Lowry retreated to his family’s rental home nearby and watched a hurling match between Tipperary and Limerick. While watching golf coverage, he had heard folks confuse him with “Dave Lowry,” a hockey player, and “Steve Lowery,” a former PGA Tour golfer. He shrugged.

Advertise with us

“Hopefully by this evening, they’ll know me,” he said.

They probably will remember Shane Lowry, but not as U.S. Open champion.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: snesbitt@post-gazette.com and Twitter @stephenjnesbitt.