Curtis Strange is one of only four players in history to win back-to-back U.S. Open titles, accomplishing the rare feat in 1988 and 1989 at The Country Club in Brookline, Mass., and Oak Hill Country Club in Rochester, N.Y. Strange’s win at Oak Hill at age 34 was his 17th career victory on the PGA Tour. As the No. 1 player in the world, surely more would follow.

None ever did.

Strange never won another tournament, not on the PGA Tour, not even on the Champions Tour. But he came close to claiming his third U.S. Open title in 1994 at Oakmont Country Club, so close that he still remembers the holes that got away. He also remembers a conversation he had with a friend at breakfast on the morning of the final round who warned him where impending trouble lurked.

Strange had shot three consecutive rounds of 70 at Oakmont and was at 3-under 210, four shots behind leader Ernie Els, heading into the final round. Els had shot a 5-under 66 on Saturday to take a two-shot lead on New Zealand’s Frank Nobilo after 54 holes.

Advertise with us

Sunday morning, Strange and his wife, Sarah, were having breakfast with Frank Fuhrer and his wife, Heidi. Strange had befriended Fuhrer during the days of the two-day Family House Invitational that Fuhrer staged and was staying at his Fox Chapel home during the U.S. Open.

While they were eating, Fuhrer gave Strange some unsolicited advice how to navigate two of the toughest and most diabolic greens at Oakmont — the par-5 ninth and the par-four 10th — even though Strange didn’t seem to have an appetite for his opinion.

“I told him, you can still win this thing,” said Fuhrer, a longtime Oakmont member. “I said the key is going to be Nos. 9 and 10. I want to tell you how to play them. Well, Curtis looked at me and said, ‘Whoa, wait a minute, you’re going to tell me how to play golf?’ I said, ‘You don’t have to listen but I’m going to tell you anyway.’ ”

Fuhrer told Strange two things: At No. 9, the pin is going to be front right, tucked behind a greenside bunker. Don’t hit your second shot on the green, behind the pin, because it’s a sure three-putt. Hit it in the bunker for an easy up-and-down birdie.

At 10, be sure not to leave your second shot short because the area in front of the green will be watered and the ball will stop. Hit your ball on the green and, even if it runs to the back, you have an uphill putt and can still make par.

Advertise with us

So what happened?

Strange knocked his second shot on the green at No. 9, leaving himself behind the pin. From there, he three-putted — as Fuhrer warned — and made 5.

At 10, he tried to do what Fuhrer told him not to do, but his second shot landed on the firm, sloping green and bounded through the back like a marble rolling in a bathtub. It took Strange three to get down from there and he made a bogey 5.

All these years later, Strange still remembers the conversation, still remembers the way Fuhrer barked at him at the breakfast table. He will get to relive some of those moments when he comes to the 2016 U.S. Open at Oakmont as a course reporter for Fox’s television coverage.

“We’re sitting there having breakfast and he said, ‘That pin on 9 is going to be front right and you got to put it in the front bunker.’ I’m, like, ‘Yeah, right, Frank,’ ” Strange said. “I had a 6-iron from the left rough and I put in on the green in two and damn if I don’t putt it off green and missed a 12-footer coming back.”

Advertise with us

As it turns out, Strange shot another 70, his fourth in a row, and missed gaining the Monday 18-hole playoff with Els, Colin Montgomerie and Loren Roberts by one shot.

“So I go to sign my scorecard and who’s the first person I run into? Frank,” Strange said. “He said, ‘I said to put it in the front bunker.’ And I said, ‘Frank you were right.’ ”

Strange, though, doesn’t think those holes cost him a chance to get into the playoff. After a birdie at the par-4 11th, he made bogeys at Nos. 13, 15 and 16 to fall several shots off the lead. A birdie at the final hole, the magnificent par-4 18th, made it look closer than it actually was.

“I didn’t finish very well on Sunday,” Strange recalled. “You can’t give away shots at the end of a U.S. Open, especially coming from behind. Ernie, all along, looked in complete control, but he didn’t finish well, either. I felt like I had a chance. I didn’t finish. You don’t think about it at the time. I played well, but you hate to come close and lose.”

Strange remains the last player to win back-to-back U.S. Open titles. Had he listened to Fuhrer, Strange might have become only the seventh player to win the tournament three times.

Advertise with us

“I knew what was going on, I knew this would be my third Open [if I won] and I wouldn’t get many more chances,” Strange said. “I was 39. I said I would go all out. I remember saying to Bill Millsaps [a golf writer for the Richmond, Va., Times-Dispatch] before the round, ‘I need a run. All I need is one little spurt.’ I was like three, four, five shots behind, and if I get that spurt maybe the game would begin to come.

“Sure enough. I birdied three of the first five holes and there was my spurt. That’s what I needed. All of a sudden, I had to slow down my adrenaline rush and I remember birdieing 11 and 14, but I made those other mistakes. I played well to come within one of getting into the playoff. You do that, you’ve done lot of things right.”

Just not enough things.

Gerry Dulac: gdulac@post-gazette.com and Twitter @gerrydulac.