It hap­pened with ho­tels, air­line travel and even restau­rants. Now it is hap­pen­ing with golf courses. Con­sum­ers are dis­cov­er­ing that book­ing tee times, es­pe­cially at courses close to home, is get­ting eas­ier, cheaper and more con­ve­nient on­line, some­times find­ing deals that are down­right ri­dic­u­lous.

Third-party tee time sell­ers such as GolfNow.com and TeeOff.com, which tip­toed onto the scene al­most a de­cade ago, have be­come such a dom­i­nat­ing pres­ence in the world of pub­lic golf — GolfNow booked nearly 15 mil­lion rounds in 2014 — they have changed the way a large per­cent­age of core golfers book rounds and how much they are will­ing to pay.

Not only can they book tee times at night, when golf shops are closed, but they also search for courses of­fer­ing the best prices, some­times as low as $9 to $15. It was a win-win for all in­volved.

Bud­get-con­scious golfers would be in­clined to play more be­cause of lower costs and per­haps even fre­quent dif­fer­ent courses. And course own­ers liked the mar­ket­ing and aware­ness they re­ceived from the sites and the idea play­ers might snatch off-peak tee times that oth­er­wise would go un­used.

Advertise with us

The third-party sell­ers were hailed as rev­o­lu­tion­aries and wel­comed as warmly as a kick-in birdie.

“They do have a tre­men­dous fol­low­ing and a tre­men­dous da­ta­base of golfers that looks for deals or bar­gains,” said Olde Stone­wall head pro­fes­sional Sean Swi­dzin­ski. “Even if some­one doesn’t book through them, they have a lot of out-of-town peo­ple who no­ticed your place be­cause you’re on there.”

Mike Reimer, a North Hills in­sur­ance sales­man, be­gan us­ing GolfNow for that very rea­son when he pur­chased Pheas­ant Ridge Golf Course in Gib­so­nia three years ago.

“As a brand new owner/​op­er­a­tor I just de­cided that be­ing on their mar­ket place and hav­ing our name in front of thou­sands of golfers in Western Penn­syl­va­nia can’t be a bad thing,” Reimer said. “That’s the rea­son I got on board — to book tee times at the golf course. They did a great job. They do a great job.”

Olde Stone­wall, gen­er­ally re­garded as the best daily-fee fa­cil­ity in Western Penn­syl­va­nia with its $150 greens fee, used GolfNow for sev­eral years, giv­ing the on­line ser­vice sev­eral tee times it could dis­count and keep 100 per­cent of the fees. But, while golfers seek­ing to play the Mi­chael Hurdzan-de­signed lay­out could now do so at a much more af­ford­able rate, Olde Stone­wall quickly found it­self in the tick­lish po­si­tion of ex­plain­ing the re­duced rate, even for just a cou­ple tee times, to its reg­u­lar cus­tom­ers.

Advertise with us

That’s when Swi­dzin­ski de­cided to stop us­ing GolfNow. But he is not alone.

Course own­ers have be­come in­creas­ingly con­cerned about third-party sell­ers, fear­ful they are los­ing con­trol of their tee sheet and wor­ried about price in­teg­rity with loyal cus­tom­ers who are pay­ing the “rack rate” for their tee times. Ac­cord­ing to a re­cent study by the Na­tional Golf Foun­da­tion, those fac­tors are caus­ing con­ster­na­tion among course own­ers and op­er­a­tors who are try­ing to strike a bal­ance be­tween in­creas­ing rounds played and an­ger­ing reg­u­lar cus­tom­ers who pay a full rate.

What’s more, be­cause golfers find such low rates with third-party sell­ers, the golf courses that are of­fer­ing those low rates are ba­si­cally com­pet­ing with them­selves and los­ing po­ten­tial rev­e­nue, as much as $40,000 an­nu­ally in some in­stances.

“If you had golf op­er­a­tors that would do ab­so­lutely noth­ing to help build their brand and could have some­one else do it, that’s a pos­i­tive,” said Tom Rob­shaw, whose Oak­mont-based com­pany, Club Prophet Systems, de­signs golf man­age­ment soft­ware for 1,600 courses in 16 coun­tries. Among the items the soft­ware pro­vides is tee time and on­line res­er­va­tions, al­low­ing courses to use their ser­vice with­out hav­ing to use a third-party seller.

“But I can’t see many pos­i­tives from a busi­ness-owner’s per­spec­tive where the very solu­tion you’ve cho­sen [to build your brand] you’re now com­pet­ing against. You have enough com­pe­ti­tion out there that you don’t need a vir­tual one.”

Advertise with us

The travel in­dus­try — ho­tels and air­lines — had sim­i­lar is­sues when third-party in­ven­tory sell­ers such as Ex­pe­dia and Trav­e­loc­ity came on the scene. Even­tu­ally, the two sides came to a col­lab­o­ra­tive agree­ment: Peak travel times would be re­served for cus­tom­ers who are not price-con­scious. Less at­trac­tive times that were slow to sale would be re­duced for dis­count seek­ers.

That has yet to hap­pen in the golf in­dus­try.

Un­like the travel in­dus­try, golfers seek­ing tee times have not flocked to third-party sell­ers as much as peo­ple think. In a re­cent study, the NGF said only 15 per­cent of all golfers use ser­vices such as GolfNow to book tee times. Part of that is be­cause of the num­ber of older or re­tired peo­ple who play golf. That is not the same de­mo­graphic that is likely to book travel us­ing their tab­lets or smart phones.

How­ever, the study also found that 81 per­cent of core golfers — those who play eight or more times a year — have used a third-party re­seller so they can view mul­ti­ple courses at the same time, 76 per­cent be­cause they were search­ing for lower prices. That, of course, is the in­tent of the third-party seller.

The ben­e­fit for course op­er­a­tors, ac­cord­ing to the sur­vey, was 41 per­cent of core golfers said the ser­vices gave them ac­cess to courses they would oth­er­wise not have played. And 48 per­cent used third-party re­sellers when away from home.

Advertise with us

So is it re­ally driv­ing busi­ness to the golf course at the ex­pense of lost rev­e­nue, com­pro­mised price in­teg­rity and the in­abil­ity to sell those traded tee times at the rack rate? Is the aware­ness re­ally worth it?

“Price in­teg­rity is ev­ery­thing,” Swi­dzin­ski said. “I’m up front with ev­ery­one, whether it’s an event or a mem­ber or some­one off the street. We don’t ne­go­ti­ate prices. Main­tain­ing value and know­ing there are no deals to dis­count is the only way to have in­teg­rity.”

Part of the con­cern among course own­ers is how low is too low to pay for a tee time?

Ac­cord­ing to a story in Golf­week mag­a­zine, a man in San Diego who booked 466 tee times with GolfNow in 2015 (not all for him) paid only $3.76 for an 18-hole round at nearby Car­mel Moun­tain Ranch Coun­try Club.

Lo­cally, it’s not much dif­fer­ent. On April 1, when the tem­per­a­ture was 65 de­grees, golfers could go on GolfNow.com and get a tee time at Pitts­burgh Na­tional Golf Club in Gib­so­nia, one of the bet­ter pub­lic courses in Western Penn­syl­va­nia, for $17 (cart in­cluded) be­gin­ning at 2:42 p.m. That price dropped to $14 for 18 holes (cart in­cluded) at 3:46 p.m. The week­day rate for a golfer who walked up and paid his greens fee in the pro shop is $38, no mat­ter what time of day.

Advertise with us

On that same date, golfers could book on GolfNow.com and get 18 holes with cart for un­der $20 at Grand View ($15) and Sun­crest ($17), start­ing af­ter 2:30 p.m. Pheas­ant Ridge, which charges $39 week­days, $49 week­ends, has been on GolfNow for as low as $15. Birds­foot owner Travis Lind­say, who charges $59 ev­ery day to play his up­scale 18-hole lay­out in Free­port, cringed when he saw GolfNow of­fer one of his bar­tered tee times for $15.

If more courses in Western Penn­syl­va­nia have rates as low as $15 on GolfNow, the fear is those dis­counts will lower the over­all rate courses in the re­gion can charge. In Char­les­ton, S.C., sev­eral course own­ers banded to­gether and agreed to drop GolfNow for that rea­son.

And it’s among the rea­sons Reimer de­cided to end his re­la­tion­ship with GolfNow this year.

“When you start see­ing Pheas­ant Ridge for $14 to $18, it hurts our brand, it hurts our im­age,” Reimer said. “If we were go­ing to a des­ti­na­tion and we didn’t know the golf courses and we saw a course for $18 with cart, we wouldn’t play the golf course.”

If you don’t care when or where you play, and you wait long enough, golfers can find deals that make Black Fri­day block­bust­ers look pricey. But that cre­ates a sce­nario where those off-peak times, and prices, now be­come in de­mand for the con­sumer who will wait for the bar­gain.

Advertise with us

Good for the price-con­scious golfer, bad for the course owner.

“When you go low enough, if you’re put­ting your greens fee out there one-third of its nor­mal value, the per­cep­tion is, one, there’s a prob­lem, or, two, you’re strug­gling to at­tract busi­ness,” Swi­dzin­ski said. “But, three, the big­gest thing is, if you have a low rate out there, even­tu­ally that be­comes your rate. I’d rather look to raise our rate than lower our rate.”

Olde Stone­wall, though, is a dif­fer­ent an­i­mal from other courses in Western Penn­syl­va­nia. Be­cause of the de­mand to play there, the course has never low­ered its rate since the fee went up to $150 in 2008. And rounds keep es­ca­lat­ing, not de­clin­ing. Last year, Olde Stone­wall did more than 16,000 rounds, its best sea­son, Swi­dzin­ski said.

But, with the in­dus­try caught in a down­ward spi­ral that has seen courses close and rounds played dwin­dle, own­ers and op­er­a­tors have to find ways to at­tract play­ers — new and old — to their fa­cil­i­ties. Ser­vices such as TeeOff.com, which is spon­sored by the PGA Tour and has booked more than 500,000 tee times at 3,000 courses na­tion­wide, give them a way to do that.

“My feel­ing is that the in­dus­try is mov­ing, very co­op­er­a­tively, in the right di­rec­tion,” Peter Hill, CEO of Billy Casper Golf, said in a re­cent Wall Street Jour­nal ar­ti­cle. “The third-party re­sellers are ad­just­ing to re­al­ity. No­body wants to drive prices so low they are un­sus­tain­able. That’s like eat­ing your young.”

Advertise with us

For sev­eral years, Lind­say said he gave up two tee times a day to GolfNow.com — that’s eight play­ers at $59 each — in ex­change for free na­tional mar­ket­ing, use of the com­pany’s soft­ware and the pos­si­bil­ity that new cus­tom­ers, look­ing for a deal, would visit his course.

But the ques­tion re­mains: Did the ser­vice ac­tu­ally drive new cus­tom­ers to his course — Birds­foot did more rounds last year (33,842) than at any point since the Ault & Clark-de­signed lay­out opened in 2002 — or just convince cur­rent ones to wait for a block­buster deal that was some­times half the go­ing rate?

For ex­am­ple, last year, dur­ing a rainy month of March, Birds­foot did only 84 rounds de­spite hav­ing pric­ing for two four­somes each day dras­ti­cally low­ered by GolfNow.com.

This year, with­out us­ing the on­line ser­vice, Birds­foot did 1,463 rounds in March be­cause the weather was much bet­ter and sig­nifi­cantly warmer. So what dic­tates the in­crease — lower pric­ing or fa­vor­able weather? That’s why Lind­say is con­sid­er­ing not re­new­ing his two-year com­mit­ment this year.

“The big­gest is­sue is you need to pro­tect your tee times and the third-party seller is not al­low­ing that,” Lind­say said. “They’re es­sen­tially say­ing they’re go­ing to set the rate and they can charge any amount. Soon as they do that, you’ve got a prob­lem. Any­time you’re deal­ing with a third party and you’re los­ing con­trol of your pric­ing, then you need to start re­ally look­ing closely at what you’re do­ing be­cause they’re hold­ing the cards.”