It has been 25 years since Susan Tanto, one of the owners of Meadowink Golf Course in Murrysville, set about trying to change the landscape for public-course players in Pennsylvania.
At a hotel near the Somerset exchange on the Pennsylvania Turnpike, Tanto and two others met with then-United States Golf Association president Bill Campbell, a native of West Virginia, to discuss the possibility of having public-course golfers play in events that were limited solely to players from private clubs.
It seemed like a logical request. Pennsylvania had one of the nation’s largest numbers of public courses — 381 at the time — far outnumbering the total of private clubs (229).
But the two leading golf organizations in the state — the Western Pennsylvania Golf Association and the Golf Association of Philadelphia — did not allow public-course players in their events because they didn’t have handicaps that were officially established by their organizations or the USGA.
So Tanto — accompanied by Ray Funk, one of the owners of Murrysville Golf Course, and Chick Wagner, a USGA field representative who was a member at Oakmont Country Club — met with Campbell in October 1990 to recommend change.
Thus was born the Keystone Public Golf Association, an organization of public courses around the state that began with 50 courses and grew to 5,000 individual members in three years.
Several years later, the West Penn Golf Association changed its bylaws in 1994 to allow public-course players to join the organization, pay dues and play in its events. Tanto’s mission was successful.
“The USGA was very protective,” Tanto recalled the other day from Lancaster Country Club, where she attended the U.S. Women’s Open. “We struggled for a couple years before they were willing to allow us to do so.”
Today, as the KPGA officially nears its 25th anniversary, the WPGA is split with an equal number of private and public clubs — 65 each. However, the number of individual members is approximately 22,000 private, 5,000 public, according to West Penn executive director Jeff Rivard.
Tanto is no longer affiliated with the organization. The KPGA — which changed its name to the Keystone Premier Golf Association — has changed executive directors from Julie Puhl to Tom Poljak, who runs a golf magazine in Western Pennsylvania. But their mission remains the same as it did for Tanto 25 years ago — to promote public-course golf in the state.
“It allowed the public course player to get handicaps to participate in USGA events,” Tanto said. “We promoted it as being able to go and play in these events and have a representative handicap. It was difficult. Public courses were interested in making money. They weren’t interested in whether handicaps were legitimate or not. We had a big job convincing them they had to do this more seriously.”
To do so, public courses had to have their layouts “rated” — an assessment of a course’s difficulty — to official USGA standard.
A rating measures the exact distance of a hole and takes into consideration such things as trees, hazards, sand bunkers and elevation when determining the difficulty. For example, a par-4 through trees with a water hazard in front of the green would be considered very difficult and given a rating of, say, 4.5. A short, easy par-4 with no hazards might receive a rating of 3.6.
When all 18 holes are totaled, a course rating can come in anywhere from 69 (or lower) to 73 (or higher), depending on the number of obstacles and the total distance of the layout. The official formula used by the USGA is to divide the total yardage by 220 and add 40.9 (don’t ask me why it’s 40.9, but it is). So, effectively, a course that measures, say, 6,700 yards would have a course rating of 71.3. That is the simple explanation.
Handicaps are then determined based on the course rating and also the slope rating, which measures the difficulty of the course for a scratch player and a bogey player. That allows a player to have what is known as a “traveling handicap,” which can vary if he or she goes to a course with a different rating.
For example, a player with a 2-handicap at, say, Meadowink (Tanto’s former course) could conceivably be a 6- or 7-handicap at Oakmont Country Club, one of the most difficult courses in the country.
But that’s what the KPGA wanted to do, and, thanks to Tanto and her partners, they succeeded.
“It’s the entire basis for a handicap system,” Tanto said.
And one of the reason the KPGA changed the fortunes and opportunities for public-course players in the past 25 years.
Adding nine
Pete Dye, who has designed some of the most famous courses in the world, is back at Nemacolin Woodlands resort, ready to add new holes to the course he sculpted in the mid-1990s — Mystic Rock.
Dye promised the nine new holes, which will be par-36 and measure only 3,136 yards, will be just as challenging, if not more, than Mystic Rock, which played host for four years to the PGA Tour’s 84 Lumber Classic (2003-2006).
“It’s an easy nine holes to build from what it was before,” Dye said Thursday in a groundbreaking ceremony at the resort. “But it’s entirely different. I said to Joe, you sure you want it here? And he said yeah, I want it here. So that’s where it so goes.”
The reference was to Joe Hardy, the resort founder who has turned operation of the opulent 2,000-acre resort in Farmington over to his daughter, Maggie Hardy-Magerko.
Hardy and Dye have maintained a relationship over time, even though it has been 20 years since Mystic Rock opened. He didn’t consider another architect for the new project.
“He’s a real master at looking at land and letting the land conform to the course,” Hardy said. “A lot of other designers, they have two or three ideas on a golf course and take one of those and say, ‘Oh, you ought to use this one.’ He takes the views, takes the elevations and really comes out with a gorgeous picture of that hole.
He doesn’t grind it to make what he wants; he goes along with it.”
Curiously, and probably not coincidentally, the new course will be built on 84 acres — the Hardy family owns 84 Lumber — and is scheduled to be completed in July 2017. The new holes will also be numbered 19 through 27, a departure from most courses that have three nine-hole layouts.
Each nine will be identified by a single letter — R, O and C — which is short for “rock,” as in Mystic Rock. The course is so named because of the amount of rock and shale Dye had to unearth when building it.
“It wasn’t that bad, not like everybody thinks it was,” Dye said. “It was just three or four holes. That’s OK.”
As part of the project, Nemacolin Woodlands plans to develop 600 homesites around the course property and build villas near its Falling Rock hotel that start at $1.8 million. The resort recently completed a $30 million renovation at their other swank hotel, Chateau Lafayette.
“It means to a lot to me when we build at Nemacolin,” said Hardy-Magerko, owner of the resort and 84 Lumber. “It shows that we believe and we’re here for a long time.”
Just like Pete Dye.
Gerry Dulac: gdulac@post-gazette.com and Twitter @gerrydulac. Listen to “The Golf Show with Gerry Dulac” every Thursday, 6-7:30 p.m., on 970 ESPN.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.