As those who have monitored the mostly deserted intersection of baseball and cinema over the years have come to understand, there are certain inescapable moments in any major league season that can be introduced only by one of Harry Doyle’s hysterical bleatings from the 1989 movie classic “Major League.”
As the fictional play-by-play man of the Indians barked into his talk show mic in the inimitable voice of the even-less imitable Bob Uecker, “In case you haven’t noticed, and judging by the attendance you haven’t ...”
So don’t look now (and many of you bear no such intention), but at the mostly deserted intersection of General Robinson Street and Mazeroski Way, the Pirates are somehow stringing together a baseball season of nearly verifiable promise. If you don’t know or just no longer care about what you’re missing, I can only tell you that, well, I’m not sure what you’re missing either.
Not yet.
But it’s something.
There’s a Pittsburgh offense that made it to the weekend among the best in both leagues, a rookie at third base who’s among the best new players in the game, a left fielder stolen from the Tampa Bay Rays who has the vibe of an emerging star, a refurbished Francisco Cervelli (different stance, heavier bat) driving in runs at an unthinkable pace. The Pirates catcher had 24 RBIs after 43 games. He’s never driven in more than 43 in an entire season. Many if not most observers expect a bit of a correction coming on that, but overall, the question of whether the first-place flirtatious 2018 Pirates are for real is legitimate.
Read More
“We’ve been playin’ great since we left spring training,” said starting pitcher Trevor Williams. “We came out hot. I thought we were gonna surprise some people because we have some young talent, but we’re not rookies anymore. There are guys in the clubhouse that have a year of experience, a year-plus of experience, so they know what it takes to be a successful big leaguer, know what it takes to win at the big league level.
“This clubhouse hates to lose.”
Williams just turned 26. Jameson Taillon is 26, Chad Kuhl is 25, Nick Kingham is 26. Kingham’s presence might be temporary as the Pirates await the imminent arrival of injured started Joe Musgrove, who is, um, 25. The only starter with a dossier of substance, 31-year-old Ivan Nova, brought a 10.22 May earned run average to the weekend and recently needed 51 pitches to get through the bottom of the first against a last-place team.
The average age of a Pirates starter, 26.7, is thus substantially greener than any of the National League Central contenders (St. Louis 28.2, Milwaukee 29.2, Chicago 30), and that’s the reason the question of sustainable legitimacy might not last much longer. Can a rotation this inexperienced click for four-five-six months? It’s been seven weeks.
“Quite truthfully, I think we’re going to have to answer the are-we-for-real question all year,” said Taillon, opting for optimism. “We have to keep provin’ ourselves because we are young. We’re not necessarily proven big league starters yet. But if you sit around, work with us, talk with us, watch us throw our bullpens, watch us interact during the games, we might be young in age, but we’re getting better, we’re pushin’ each other, we’re extremely mature for our age. I think it’s sustainable and I don’t think it’s crazy to believe we can only get better.”
Pittsburgh sports news in my inbox? Yes, please.
Get the PG Sports Feed newsletter each weekday here.
Not crazy, necessarily, but not at all likely in a linear sense. Young pitchers go off track suddenly, get back on and fall off again, all without necessarily understanding why. Generally, if you’re going to contend for a spot in baseball’s postseason, you can do it with a starting pitcher or maybe two who is still learning the craft, but not with three or four.
“You’re right, typically, it’s not how you build a playoff team, but Colorado did it a year ago [before losing in the wild card round],” Pirates GM Neal Huntington pointed out this week. “Ours is a mature group with some common traits. They’re intelligent. They’re driven. They’re confident. The short answer is that we believe in them.
“We’re gonna have some tough stretches along the way. There will be a couple of starts, stretches, and we’ve had those already, where it just hasn’t been there. The challenge is, young starters have a harder time keeping the good stretches long and the bad stretches short.”
That’s why Kuhl and Taillon are having seasons that might better be expressed by a seismograph than by advanced metrics. Taillon, who pitched a complete game one-hit shutout in his second start of the season, had an 0.89 ERA after three starts, then a 4.83 ERA after six, but it’s begun to stabilize again. Kuhl, who couldn’t get through the fifth inning against the Padres Thursday night, also happens to be the club’s stopper. Kuhl has posted wins that followed Pirate losses a club-high three times, including one that stopped a five-game losing streak, the longest of the young season.
“Major league experience, Taillon’s got what — not a lot, Kuhl, not a lot, Williams, not a lot,” manager Clint Hurdle pondered. “That doesn’t play as much as their ability to continue to own the opportunities. They’ve gotten better with the opportunities. They’re learning what it means to be a starting pitcher. There’s games when they deal and they all have the capability to go out and beat ‘em. They’ve also had push-back games. Chad just had one here [against the Giants last weekend]. The barrel showed up a lot early. They’re trying to push him out but he was able to put the foot down and go six innings. That’s a big accomplishment for a young pitcher.
“Then [Thursday] it was Chad who threw some challenges at Chad once some guys got on, quite frankly. When the bottom of the [Padres] lineup dinged him, that got him wound up a little bit and he was trying to go harder, faster. [But] the developmental aspects with all of them, I’m really encouraged.”
You don’t have to scour the game’s history all that diligently to find reasons for such encouragement. Once upon a time, there was a team with the precise average rotation age of these Pirates, 26.7, that not only won the pennant but swept the World Series. Of course, that was in the days of the four-man rotation, and it really helped that three of them were named Sandy Koufax, Don Drysdale, and Johnny Podres, because then you go to the Series and win 5-2, 4-1, 1-0, and 2-1 while the Mickey Mantle-Roger Maris-led New York Yankees hit .171.
That’s probably not what’s going on in Hurdle’s clubhouse, and the truth is that these Pirates will likely need to add a starting pitcher if they wish to play past September, but for the moment, they’re unexpectedly comfortable.
“We’ve never cared much about expectations outside this room,” said Kuhl. “The expectations inside this room were that we were gonna be in a good spot with our rotation and our bullpen, that they’d be a real strength, and the offense has come along and done an awesome job, so we’re right where we want to be.”
Many of their fans are right where they want to be as well – at home. Attendance is off 33 percent from last year, when it was off 15 percent from the year before. It’s interesting, at the very least, that this is the kind of Pirates team that might force a reconciliation.
I mean in case you haven’t noticed, and judging from the attendance ...
Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.