The closing ceremonies at the Olympics never deliver much fulfillment to sports fans who much prefer the innate drama of competition to the hit-and-miss packaging of pageantry, but this disconnect might have a potential solution.
What should happen amid these massive productions, starting with Sunday night’s telecast from the 2018 Winter Olympics in South Korea, is a full ceremonial stripping of medals from the various dopers across the vast panoply of sports and countries we’ve been celebrating for most of the previous three weeks.
Alexander Krushelnitskiy, for example, shouldn’t be allowed to just slink back to Russia after delegitimizing the global curling competition. He could be put on a medal stand wearing a special tear-away lanyard designed by the International Olympic Committee, and, after the public address announcer identifies the appropriate banned substance — “MELDONIUM!” — have the bronze he ostensibly “won” last week yanked off his neck. Now that’s compelling TV.
Problem is, had they done this at the Sochi Olympics in 2014, the show might have eclipsed the five-hour mark. They’d have raked four golds, eight silvers and a bronze off the Russians alone, which wasn’t even possible at the time because their massive, labyrinthine, spy-novel doping scandal hadn’t yet been whistle-blown to life for the World Anti-Doping Agency and later laid out in astonishing detail for the New York Times by Grigory Rodchenkov, the former Russian anti-doping official now hiding out in the Federal Witness Protection Program.
Rodchenkov’s story happens to be the dramatic foundation of an Oscar-nominated documentary feature called “Icarus,” in which the world can plainly see that if “Icarus” snags an Oscar next Sunday, it won’t be the first thing Rodchenkov ever helped win.
And yet any enlightened understanding on the scope of Olympic doping, much less the depth of specifically Russian motivation, can’t be conveyed even by “Icarus.”
“The Olympics have been doped since the 1950’s,” said Dr. Robert Edelman, the historian of Soviet and Cold War sport who teaches Russian history and the history of sport at the University of California San Diego. “We know pretty well that both the United States and the Soviet Union, when these things were not technically illegal, were exchanging methods, their weightlifters and our weightlifters.
“So I don’t, at any point in time as a historian of sports in general, not just Russian, consider the Olympics to be some kind of oasis of purity. They’ve been massively corrupted from the very beginning.”
In the early 21st century, some cultural holdouts still find massive corruption a bit of a turnoff, which can lead to a certain discomfort among the viewership, even at the viewership’s most sophisticated levels.
“The event that kind of brought the ambiguity of it all back to me was as I watched the U.S.-Russia game, which the Russians looked really good at [winning 4-0],” Edelman said. “I sort of felt compelled by that in ways that I was compelled by similar contests going back to the ’60s, even to 1960, when we beat them at Squaw Valley. That kind of felt like the old days a bit. But other than that, Russia’s doing the best they can under the circumstances; these are obviously not their best athletes. They haven’t won a gold yet have they?”
Not until Friday, when 15-year-old Alina Zagitova took one in women’s figure skating, and at the weekend only 14 total medals had been awarded to the (Ostensibly Clean) Olympic Athletes of Russia, seven fewer than the number won by the U.S. and 23 fewer than the spectacular Norwegians.
But it’s all through the looking glass, because nobody knows, at least until the essentially hopeless testing bodies finish their work, what it is we’ve actually been watching, or not watching as the case may be.
“Did you watch baseball in the ’90s?” Edelman asked, calcifying the conflict for me.
Indeed I did, but I had no idea of the extent of the steroid usage in baseball at the time.
“Well,” he said somewhat charitably, “you’re going to have to explain that one, not me.”
Yeah, still at a loss.
But even by the parameters of baseball at its worst, the Olympics are at a whole other level of conspiracy and skullduggery.
“The awareness of it only became considerable in the ’70s,” Edelman said. “It’s always been fairly pathetic, behind the curve of the dopers. It’s just not possible to believe only one or two people were doping at these Olympics [actually four by the deadline for this column, two of them Russians], that just can’t be. It’s simply not plausible. Either the local lab is not trying hard or the dirty athletes have found new drugs or masking agents. No one should declare victory. The Russian curler must be an idiot.”
Until the curling scandal — there’s a phrase I could never have foreseen typing — the International Olympic Committee was considering re-instating Russia to the Olympic movement and allowing the (Ostensibly Clean) Olympic Athletes of Russia to march under the nation’s flag at the closing ceremonies, and, the IOC being notably spineless, it still might.
It’s important to point out that even though Krushelnitskiy’s medal was the 44th to be stripped from a Russian in the Olympics, and that 44 is more than four times that of any other country, this level of cheating remains a global pursuit.
“Not just the United States, but the rest of the world does this too,” Edelman said. “One of things we’ve learned in our Cold War Project is that the distinction between supposedly independent, non-governmental Western capitalist sport and state-controlled Communist sport is overdrawn. There are all kinds of ways that power centers in capitalist governments have been able to create pressures and rewards that have led people to dope.”
Lance Armstrong, Marion Jones, Alex Rodriguez and hundreds more Western athletes are the fruits of those diverse systems, yet state-of-the-art doping conspiracies stubbornly appear to bear Russian fingerprints. A reasonable question remains whether the Russians are just really good at doping, or, given the rate at which they’ve been busted, are they just really bad at it.
“That’s a great question but not the central question,” said Thomas M. Hunt, who wrote “Drug Games: The International Olympic Committee and the Politics of Doping,” and is now in the Department of Kinesiology and Health Education at the University of Texas at Austin. “The central question — why is Russia doing it? — a lot of people will say Russia is doing this to beat the United States and the West, but I don’t think that’s it at all, although I’m sure they’d be happy to do it. But any authoritative regime has to boost nationalism at home in order to stay in power. Sports is a really nice way for Russia to boost nationalism at a time when their economy was having trouble. That’s the real ‘why’ in why they were going to this much effort just to win some medals. We’re misunderstanding by thinking it’s directed at us or other countries. It’s really the Russians demonstrating to themselves that they’re powerful.
“Sports or the Olympics should not be seen in isolation, but in the broader pattern of how countries behave. I think the Russians are, at best, testing or, at worst, pushing at Western norms that have been constructed. The Russians historically are paranoid. It’s the most invaded country of all time. Western norms put in place through treaties and other international agreements, many of which came from the Cold War, Russia is always pushing and testing and this fits within the pattern of paranoia against the rest of the world.”
After the Russians helped the West defeat fascism in World War II, the international community welcomed them across a spectrum of platforms, including the Olympics. They declined in 1948, reportedly because Stalin wanted some guarantee of victories the Russian sports authorities couldn’t deliver, but entered the games officially in 1952. By the time Russians hosted the Sochi Games four years ago, they were — to quote Rodchenkov in the “Icarus” film — “Top-level cheaters. We were fully equipped, knowledgeable, experienced and perfectly prepared for Sochi like never before. It was working like a Swiss watch.”
Rodchenkov further told the filmmakers, the WADA and the New York Times that he was not only responsible for developing the three-steroid cocktail that helped the Russians to 33 medals including 13 golds (including four of the 13 to be stripped), but he operated out of a dimly lit storage area next to the official urine room, into which he passed clean urine samples through a hole to replace those taken in drug testing.
Two of Rodchenkov’s colleagues in Russia later turned up dead under suspicious circumstances. One was writing a book.
As Rodchenkov told “Icarus” director Bryan Fogel in the film, “It’s not safe to write book in Russia.”
Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com or on Twitter @genecollier.
Correction, posted April 5, 2018: An earlier version of this story incorrectly spelled Alexander Krushelnitskiy’s surname.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.