Look, it’s not like the Steelers had never allowed six touchdowns before.

Take October, for example.

They played five times in October and allowed six touchdowns, total. Then Sunday, they allowed six touchdowns in 60 minutes, a season-wrecking defensive performance that left a few of its components virtually inconsolable.

Safety Mike Mitchell sat at his locker unable to even remove his uniform. He was comforted by general manager Kevin Colbert, both seemingly at the edge of tears. Mitchell later sought solace on the floor next to Cameron Heyward. That wasn’t working either. Cornerback Artie Burns also stayed in full battle gear, covering his face in a white towel that was just too symbolic.

Advertise with us

It wasn’t just that the Steelers’ ever-preening defenders had just steered Mike Tomlin’s team onto the first exit ramp available to them in the playoffs, it was the way they’d thrown a whole season into a 21-0 ditch from which not even Ben Roethlisberger could extricate them.

The Jaguars, who’ll keep that appointment the Steelers had made for themselves in New England next Sunday, scored three times as many touchdowns in the game’s first 20 minutes as they had in an entire wild-card game in which they’d fought off the never-dangerous Buffalo Bills, 10-3.

“We were so focused on the run, reading our keys, that we wound up having miscommunications,” said linebacker Bud Dupree. “I know one time I let someone go out in the flat. That was a big gain to the tight end. I put that on myself.”

Which one, the 21-yard Blake Bortles-to-Ben Koyack flip that went to the Steelers 40, or the 19-yard Bortles-to-James O’Shaughnessy toss to the 8 that ignited the first of Jacksonville’s six touchdown drives? Or how about the 45-yard post pattern to Keelan Cole that helped push the deficit to 35-21? Or how about the 40-yard run with a swing pass by T.J. Yeldon that helped extend it to 42-28?

On that first possession and again on the fourth Jaguars drive, the one that made it 21-0, the Steelers looked almost too confused to find their own sideline.

Advertise with us

“I wouldn’t call it confusion,” Tomlin said a few minutes after the worst postseason loss of his career. “It was poor execution to be quite honest with you. We didn’t execute well enough.”

There was a small mountain of evidence on that, even if the coaching staff couldn’t possibly sidestep all culpability for Jaguars 45, Steelers 42. The defense got no sacks, no takeaways, and could not prevent a Jacksonville touchdown even once on five Jaguars penetrations of the red zone. The Jaguars went 8 for 14 on third down.

“Miscommunication was pretty much the bulk of it,” said linebacker Sean Spence, hammering at a theme. “We weren’t able to get off the field in critical moments and it cost us.”

Miscommunication Man of the Year has to be Mitchell, whom some Jaguars alleged was outside their locker room pregame, taunting them. Now that would be miscommunication. Telling Monday Morning Quarterback’s Greg Bishop two weeks ago “We’re going to play [the Patriots] again. We can play them in hell, we can play them in Haiti, we can play them in New England. We’re going to beat them,” now that’s miscommunication.

You’d be inconsolable too if you’d written that many checks with your mouth and came up bankrupt.

Advertise with us

“That’s what happens when you talk [stuff],” said Jacksonville safety and former Penn Hills High defender Barry Church. “I mean you have players on their team talking about the Patriots. Acting like they were about to just obliterate us. I mean it doesn’t make sense. They just fed us the fuel that we needed to dominate.”

Yeah maybe, and maybe it was inevitable too.

It’ll take a few weeks before this Steelers season comes into better focus in the cracked rear view, but we’ll soon appreciate, it appears, how deflated the defense became after the spine injury to Ryan Shazier that first week in December. There was and there is so much concern for Shazier’s future that it was almost distasteful to publicly ponder its meaning for the Steelers defense, but Shazier’s absence has itself illuminated what an inspiring contributor he was this season.

With Shazier in the lineup, the Steelers allowed two 100-yard rushers through 12 games. They’ve allowed three in the five games since. With Shazier in the lineup, they allowed 17.75 points per game. Without him, they’ve allowed 28 points per game.

Yet unlike when the Penguins announced in the spring that standout defenseman Kris Letang would miss the remainder of the season and the playoffs and most everyone reacted almost instantaneously with there-goes-the-Cup gloom, there was no such pessimism regarding Keith Butler’s defense. The standard is the standard, goes the mantra, and that’s true. Until it’s not.

Advertise with us

So now no one has to sit around worrying for 12 months about what Tom Brady is going to do against a suspect zone. Not even Mike Mitchell. Somehow, “What can we do to beat these pesky Jaguars?” doesn’t seem so compelling.

Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com.