Five short weeks ago you could scarcely have conjured or delivered a more preposterous notion than that Sean Spence would be starting at inside linebacker for the Pittsburgh Steelers, in the postseason, in lieu of Ryan Shazier.

Five short weeks ago Shazier, as sensational as he was star-crossed, was the most electrifying linebacker in Mike Tomlin’s stable, and Spence was the most electrifying linebacker on the couch he was occupying somewhere in Florida.

The intricate narrative of how’s and why’s that comingled to put Spence on the field when the Steelers re-enter the Stairway to Seven next Sunday is both hopeful and tragic, both inspirational and heart-breaking; it’s the way-too-compelling story of two Florida kids who played high school football not 25 miles from each other and whose tortured pro football odysseys simply cannot be extricated.

It starts with Tomlin, whose affinity for Spence can’t adequately be explained, but the head coach gave it a heckuva try after practice one day this past week.

Advertise with us

“Sometimes young men just twinge you in a certain way.” Tomlin said at the club’s indoor facility on South Water Street. “I watched him as a very young guy on University of Miami tape. And I was down there at their pro day, and this was before he was even draft eligible. And I was talkin’ to one of their strength coaches and I said, ‘Hey, point that little linebacker out to me; I want to see what he looks like.’ And that was the first time I saw and met Sean Spence. He had a backpack on and he was just one of those guys that the way he played the game at a very young age struck me.”

Two years later, with the retirement of James Farrior, the Steelers waded into a draft crammed with linebacking talent and called Spence’s name in the third round. He was the 10th linebacker taken. He was small — standing only 5-foot-11 — but Tomlin knew he moved like the wind. Four months after that, Spence was completing his rookie preseason against Carolina at Heinz Field when his embryonic career took a u-turn that in one horrible moment approximated the configuration of his left leg.

On a blitz toward Panthers quarterback Jimmy Clausen, Spence flashed into the Carolina backfield wearing Farrior’s old No. 51. He was contacted by running back Tauren Poole. Spence bounced off Poole’s block to his right, resuming the attack, but Poole wasn’t finished. He caught up to Spence a few strides later and pushed him farther away from Clausen. When Spence tried to slow and redirect, his left leg bowed backward.

Ligaments ripped: Multiple.

Knee caps shattered: One.

Advertise with us

Damaged nerves: One, the peroneal nerve, which controls feeling in the lower leg and foot.

Chances he’d ever play again: “It would be miraculous,” was the assessment of then linebackers coach and now defensive coordinator Keith Butler.

In a rare schism, Tomlin publicly disagreed with Butler while acknowledging that neither were doctors, but Spence was lost for all of 2012 and 2013 and the Steelers lost as much as they won, stacking shaky 8-8’s, the closest Tomlin’s ever come to a losing season. With Spence’s football future anything but stable, the Steelers returned to the draft room in 2014 and selected, with their first pick, Ryan Shazier.

“It’s crazy how life works,” Spence said in the locker room the other day. “With Ryan’s injury, I mean I hate the circumstance that I’m back here, know what I mean? I wouldn’t wish that on anybody. But I’m happy to be here. This place is like home to me. When I left, I always was tryin’ to get back. There’s no place like Pittsburgh.”

Ryan Shazier, left, and Sean Spence during 2015 Steelers training camp. (John Heller / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Crazy is one way to portray all this. Too crazy really, because this isn’t the first time Spence has started in Shazier’s stead. In the year Shazier was drafted, he moved swiftly into Dick LeBeau’s starting lineup. It was only when he damaged some ligaments in late September that Spence got his first start following two years of excruciating rehab.

Advertise with us

Spence had his best season for the 2014 Steelers, who won 11 times, but started only four games the following autumn and left via free agency that winter. He played with Tennessee in 2016 and in the spring of last year, Indianapolis signed him to a one-year deal worth $3 million, a curious figure in that they appeared to have no use for him. He was getting third team reps in training camp last summer and the Colts, about to launch a wretched Andrew Luck-less coach-firing 4-12 season, released Spence Oct. 3.

Banished to the couch in Florida, Spence saw his football life pass before his eyes.

“At times that did flash through my head, that I was out of the game for good,” Spence said. “Sittin’ home for two months, never being in that situation, not being on a team you have no choice but to think that. Those kinds of situations make you kind of lose your confidence because you start second-guessing yourself: Am I not good anymore? Have I lost it? In those situations you just have to kind of work yourself through it. Keep believing in yourself and knowing that your ability is still good and you have the ability to do anything you want given the right opportunity.”

In terms of self-doubt, I wondered how those two months stacked up for anguish with the two years Spence poured into getting himself back on the field.

“It was right up there,” he said. “Of course with my injury I couldn’t play. But the last two months out of football, I felt like I still could play. I didn’t think my preseason was bad or that I had bad tape out there. But it was one of those situations where it’s hard to wrap your mind around not being good enough or not being able to be on a 53-man roster. That was really tough. Work out all week and expect a call at the beginning of the next week, and then repeating that process. Then watching the games on Sundays, not being able to be out there.”

Advertise with us

Then watching the Monday night game Dec. 4, watching Shazier making a routine tackle and rolling over on his back, unable to move his legs, his only public appearances since in a wheelchair. Spence went to the floor, praying for Shazier. Two nights later was with the Steelers, four nights after that he started.

“Jumping right in the fire against Baltimore on a Sunday night; it was crazy,” he said. “I enjoy that. I missed that feeling so much. Even though the game didn’t go as I wanted to (the defense hemorrhaged 38 points), we got the win. Allowed me to see what I need to work on and what I needed to improve on to help this defense and help this team.”

Sean Spence eyes the Ravens offense Dec. 10 at Heinz Field. (Peter Diana / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Spence simply can’t help that he can’t help this team like Shazier, who after missing the final four games and most of the one before that, still tied for the team lead in unassisted tackles with 68. Only Sean Davis, with 90, had more total tackles than Shazier (89) in 2017.

In the four games Spence has started for Shazier, the Steelers have allowed 23.75 points per game, six more than they were yielding the night Shazier went to a Cincinnati hospital.

So there’s that.

Advertise with us

“He’s gettin’ better every week, but quite frankly, we expect him to,” Tomlin said. “Part of our commitment to him is from shared experience and the knowledge that whatever we’re lookin’ at is gonna get better as he rounds into shape, as he knocks the rust off, all of those things have proven to be true and continue to be.

“Let’s be honest, anybody that we pursued would have been gettin’ off the couch. It’s the intangible. We know the man. We’ve seen him overcome a lot. We realize that he has the type of will and commitment that will allow him to overcome getting’ off the couch.”

Spence had a team-leading eight tackles at Houston on Christmas Day, then led the inside backers with six tackles against Cleveland last Sunday. No one’s taken more snaps at the position in the Steelers last three games. Thus Spence, for all his trials, will go into the playoffs as confident as anyone, saying it’s just a matter of getting his feet under him.

His prayer is that in every sense of the phrase, Shazier does the same. We all do. Their story, strained and wondrous and haunting, can’t end here.

Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com