So here we are again, six nights later, readying for another dose of prescribed violence we label AFC North football, with all the thrills, pratfalls, and potential heartache it entails.
Maybe the coin toss Sunday night between captains of the Steelers and Baltimore Ravens should include the old boxing admonition I always found so close to comic:
“Gentlemen, protect yourselves at all times.”
If they were interested in protecting themselves, what would they be doing here?
Six nights after 25-year-old Ryan Shazier executed an open field tackle in Cincinnati that put him in an ambulance, the sport at its highest level spent the week in compulsory self-evaluation, again on one broad question: It is too violent, not violent enough, or is it just some twisted Goldilocks algorithm approximating just right?
Don’t think it’s that last one.
The game was ridiculously violent last weekend — the Steelers-Bengals smackoff was probably as ugly a game as I’ve covered in going on 40 years in NFL press boxes; the league’s frantic administration of justice was uglier still.
Self-evaluation, alas, led only to further questions: Is it even possible to protect modern NFL players? Are NFL players even all that interested in being protected? The only thing clearly evident is that the game as we know it now is in a full, extended, and turbulent transition from a culture of old-school head banging toward a relatively enlightened landscape where medical research and new techniques will potentially diminish the carnage.
“It’s a good transition, but it needs to be cleared up,” said 22-year-old Steelers cornerback Artie Burns. “You can’t be cautious of the outcome of tackles out there. You can be cautious about your form on a tackle, but you don’t want to go into it thinking, ‘Man I don’t want to get a concussion on this play.’ If you worry about yourself being hurt, you’re gonna end up hurting yourself.”
The maddening equation of this game is that if you’re not worried about it, you can still hurt yourself, and sometimes very, very badly. Shazier was making an open field tackle early in the Bengals game, with Cincinnati wideout Josh Malone galloping free on a crossing route inside the Steelers’ 20. He was not thinking about form, but about getting Malone on the ground, instinctive pre-transition football. He lowered the crown of his helmet and rammed it into Malone’s right hip pad. There was nowhere for the force of that blow to go but back down his spine, where the damage remains indeterminate.
“We try to always tackle with the correct technique,” said veteran outside linebacker Arthur Moats, who’ll become an inside linebacker in the absence of Shazier. “Everybody on the defense knows, if I want to take you out, I can hit you in your head or I can hit you in your knee. But a lot of times if you’re aiming at a guy’s chest and he ducks at the last minute, that’s where a lot of these issues occur.
“This is something that’s going to be fluid and we’re not at a complete, this-is-the-best option yet. We’re still trying to fix it. In any transition process where you’re talking about dramatic changes, that process is sometimes smooth and sometimes it’s rough. We’re going through a rough phase. The league and the players have said we’d like it be a safer sport.”
It’s true they’ve said it. It’s not necessarily true that they mean it.
A mountain range of evidence has accumulated on potentially devastating tackling techniques, and the league and the players have spent another mountain of time and money promoting safe tackling in youth sports.
“We’re gatekeepers, very impactful on the young people we deal with,” Mike Tomlin told a high school concussions seminar last spring at Heinz Field. “Player safety and head injuries are our generation’s opportunity to not only safeguard the game but be active participants in the evolution of the game.
“It’s our words and actions, because young people are watching it.”
It’s the actions that don’t seem to have changed much. Players are still launching themselves, lowering their heads, and many aren’t shy about celebrating the resultant violence. The helmet-to-helmet hit Bengals’ safety George Iloka delivered to Anthony Brown last week was just plain reprehensible, yet his one-game suspension was waived on appeal.
It’s enough to make anyone suspect neither the players nor league are serious. I know Roger Goodell went on the Queen Latifah Show and even demonstrated elements of the NFL-funded program called Heads Up Football, running at zero miles per hour into a soft bag held by former NFL linebacker LaVar Arrington.
Seriously?
“We average, most guys on the field, we average 17 miles an hour, running,” said Burns. “Most humans, when they work out, aren’t anywhere near that. That’s real fast. There isn’t time for thinking. At that speed, you might have one second to make a decision. Not enough time.
“In certain situations, you can say, ‘Yes, that’s a bad hit. You should never have led with your head.’ But sometimes you can’t get away from that.”
The NFL will consider during the coming offseason a protocol for ejecting players for targeting, much as in the college game, which is the complicated and dubious process of determining who could have aborted a dangerous hit and simply chose the opposite. If passed, it will add a layer of replay and 10 layers of controversy.
Hard as it seems for modern players to believe, there is still such a thing as unnecessary roughness, and in fact, the directive to officials that is the addendum to Rule 12, Section 2, Article 8 reads, “If in doubt about a roughness call or potentially dangerous tactics, the covering official(s) should always call unnecessary roughness.”
Always.
“That’s why the flags are coming out, because guys are getting hit too hard; that’s what I believe,” said Burns. “Sometimes you’ll see it could be a clean hit, the guy don’t use his head, he hit him in the chest, but he just hit him too hard.”
You can almost hear the laughter ringing out the windows of the old school on that one. This is, after, essentially a matter of how far from that school building you want to get.
“I don’t think it’s more dangerous; it’s always been the same man, in terms of tackling and trying to have proper technique and keep yourself healthy,” said defensive coordinator Keith Butler when I asked this week. “I played with a guy down in Memphis when I was in college, and he ran down on a kickoff, ducked his head and hit somebody and broke his neck. He was paralyzed from the neck down the rest of his life. You don’t wish that on anybody, and that’s certainly not the case with Ryan as I understand it.
“To me, if I had to do it over again, I would still play. At these stakes, I would still play. I think if you asked every guy in that locker room, knowing the stakes and the possibilities at hand, they would still play this game, because the game is so much fun and it beats the heck out of workin’ for a livin’, it does.”
I’m sure they’ll enjoy Steelers-Ravens, a matchup that’s historically brought its own share of atrocities that would force you to agree with Steelers safety Mike Mitchell, who pointed out this week that “this is a man’s game.”
Even if you sometimes wish it didn’t look so much like a crazy man’s game.
Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.