One of these days, that’s when you’ll do that thing you’ve been putting off for years, one of these days, like reading “War and Peace,” painting the back porch, getting the piano tuned and teaching the dog to play ragtime.
So no, we all know none of that is ever going to get done even if it could be done, unless of course you are Rex Johnston, because these days — Saturday, Sunday, Monday — are those days.
Saturday he flew in from California, Sunday he was going to the Steelers game, and Monday he planned to throw out the first pitch before the Pirates entertain the Brewers, a worthy itinerary for anyone with a sporting bent, but especially for a guy who hasn’t been back in Pittsburgh since 1964, when he left the three rivers as the only man then or since to play for both the Steelers and the Pirates.
“I loved them both,” he said on the phone from the left coast this week. “There was no favoritism on my part; I just felt like I was doing what I was meant to do at the time, and trying to do it well.”
Rex David Johnston will turn 80 in November, so his days as a pro athlete in Pittsburgh more than a half century ago must feel like the blink of an eye. In measurable fact, they lasted only slightly longer.
Baseball’s folklorists habitually label micro-careers like Johnston’s as “a cup of coffee in the big leagues,” but I’m not sure you would call what Rex had as even a sip. He’d barely put the cream and sugar in. It was 10 games in 1964, mostly as the outfielder who went in to play left field in the ninth inning after Willie Stargell tired of driving in all those runs.
Read More
Rex was more of a factor for the 1960 Steelers, for whom he ran back punts and kickoffs and finished ninth in the NFL with a kickoff return average of 21.8 yards, not exactly eye-popping and yet still roughly 5½ times the current average of anyone on Mike Tomlin’s roster.
Despite his very professional contribution to those 5-6-1 Steelers of Buddy Parker, the franchise to this day has no photo of Rex Johnston in his black-and-gold No. 28.
“By the time I joined the Steelers that year, they’d already left training camp,” Johnston said. “I stayed to play the last game of the Northern League season. All the pictures had already been taken at camp.”
Maybe you noticed this is where Johnston’s timeline with Pittsburgh gets a little complicated. A two-sport star at Southern Cal in the late ’50s, Rex got $40,000 to sign with the Pirates out of college, leaving the Golden State before he could attend his graduation. After he waded through two less-than-spectacular seasons of minor league baseball, someone with the Steelers remembered that he might actually have been a better football player and invited him to try out.
Johnston has never forgotten what former Pirates executive Branch Rickey told him when he asked the great Rickey if he should accept the Steelers’ invitation:
“Rex, I look at your stats every day. If you've got something else to do, you'd better do it."
So for once in about four decades worth of sketchy talent evaluation, it looked like the Steelers were right, but Rex Johnston had become a running back on a team with no need of running backs; they had John Henry Johnson and Tom Tracy. They didn’t sign Rex for 1961, and he returned to the Pirates farm system.
“We played together in the Arizona instructional league in 1961 and 1962,” said Pirates great Steve Blass, who was lining up a dinner date with Rex for this weekend. “He and I and Tommy Sisk shared an efficiency out there, then we were in Columbus in ’63 and we had an apartment there together. I don’t remember much about him playing, but I remember Rex was such a good-looking guy. He looked like Li’l Abner. Once before a minor league game in Columbus a bunch of girls from a Catholic School came out to the game in their pretty gray uniforms and not a damned one paid any attention to me; they were all flocking around Rex.”
Blass didn’t know at the time he was living with a guy who’d run back kicks in the NFL.
“I was 18; I didn’t know much of anything,” Blass said. “Rex wasn’t one to trumpet himself. A pretty modest guy. Just one of those guys you meet and you feel good about. I’m excited to see him because I’ve thought about him a lot. Just a good guy.”
Blass and Johnston were rookies on the ’64 Pirates, Blass the promising pitcher, Johnston the switch-hitting outfielder who’d been part of the USC team that won the 1958 College World Series behind future MLB stars Don Buford and Ron Fairly. But just as the Steelers didn’t need running backs when Johnston wore a helmet, the Pirates weren’t exactly starved for outfield talent in 1964. They had Stargell, Clemente, Bill Virdon in center, and Manny Mota in case you needed a late-inning rope. Somehow, that didn’t stop them from giving Johnston uniform No. 4, which had once belonged to the most prolific homerun hitter of their pre-Stargell history, one Ralph Kiner.
(When the Pirates finally got around to retiring Kiner’s number in 1987, the slugger-turned-broadcaster told me, “You know, when I played, the best players got the low numbers. Not anymore. Now they’ll give it to Dale Berra!”)
So it wasn’t yet the middle of May before Johnston returned to the minors, and after playing 94 games with Phoenix of the Pacific Coast League in 1966, he was about to turn 29 and it was pretty clearly becoming time for something else.
“My dad was having some bad health and we needed someone to help him run his business,” Rex said. “We had to make a decision. As to why I’ve never come back to Pittsburgh, I guess it was just that I had a business to run.”
For most of his life then, Rex ran an industrial painting concern that operated in four Western states. His wife Sandy reported that at 79, he’s still going to the office, which is where I phoned him the other day.
She also wanted to note that Rex is making his long-awaited one-of-these-days trip with his three sons, Ty, Rex. Jr., and Brett, and that on Nov. 12, USC will honor Rex with its lifetime achievement award at its baseball alumni dinner.
All of this is just so you know that Bennie Benack isn’t the only answer to the old trivia trick that went, “Who is the only guy to play for the Steelers and the Pirates?” Benack was the jazz trumpeter who was a fixture at both teams’ games in the ‘60s and ‘70s.
“Yeah, I know that one, but I always said, ‘No, there was another guy, Rex Johnston,” Blass said. “You can win a lot of bar bets with that one.”
Around here, that’s plenty enough to make Rex a legend.
Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.