Spanky LaValliere, lounging on the back porch in Bradenton smoking a stogie, reported the Florida temperature as approximately 117 degrees, though it was probably hotter. He didn’t much care to be jolted backward 30 years for a Sunday perspective piece, but the former Pirates catcher could never suppress his own conviviality.

“Oh boy, it’s 30 freaking years? You had to go there didn’t you?” he said about the trade that brought him, Andy Van Slyke and Mike Dunne to Pittsburgh for Tony Pena to man the paddles while Jim Leyland tried to defibrillate a franchise back from the dead. “Thirty freaking years, and here I thought I was just turning 40.”

Yeah it’s been all of three decades, but the way Spanky illuminated it, you’d have thought it was three minutes ago.

“They told us we’d been traded, but not where, and I was sitting on the bench with Andy,” LaValliere said. “We were friends but not really close. We were saying, ‘Where do you think we’re going and where do you wanna go?’ and there were two places we did not want to go. Montreal was one, and Pittsburgh was the other.

Advertise with us

“When (Cardinals general manager) Dal Maxville called us into his office and said Pittsburgh, I’ll tell you, I was a 26-year-old man, and I was ready to cry.”

And that was the best trade in Pirates history.

Spanky LaValliere joined the Pirates 30 years ago. (Robert Sullivan / Agence France-Presse/Getty Images)

As baseball’s trade deadline looms still again, perhaps it’s useful to provide some historical context on the utility of Pirates trades in general, or at least that’s our premise.

So as the medical techs like to say when they’re about to draw blood, “This might pinch a little.”

Pittsburgh general managers of every species going back to Branch Rickey himself made good trades and even great trades, but more often they made bad trades, terrible trades, comically inept trades, and irredeemably ill-advised trades that foiled the franchise and depressed the populace for years to come.

Advertise with us

The most recent this-might-pinch-a-little-but-actually-it’ll-feel-more-like-someone-is-trying-to-plant-a-beach-umbrella-in-your-arm trade was the Neil Walker deal.

It’s always stupid to even attempt to evaluate trades in the minutes after they are consummated, so who better than I to say this about the Walker trade late on the night it happened, Dec. 9, 2015?

“Though it’s very early in another dreary offseason, it says here the Pirates will be taking a step backward because of this — in wins, in attendance, and in TV ratings.”

Amazingly, even though it was I who said it, attendance is down 21 percent since that trade, based on projected attendance in 2017 of 1,962,395, and TV ratings, as reported in Sports Business Journal, are off 27 percent this year after being off 21 percent last year from 2015. As for wins, the Pirates projected to about 79 wins at the weekend after 78 last year, or 157. In the last two seasons in which they had Neil Walker, they won 186. Wins are off 16 percent.

The Pirates got Jon Niese from the New York Mets for Walker, then traded Niese back to Queens after two-thirds of a season to get Antonio Bastardo, whom they’d allowed to become a free agent the year before, and whom they released again two weeks ago.

Advertise with us

Go ahead, read it again.

Niese and Bastardo are out of baseball. Walker hit 23 homers last year, and while injuries have limited his 2017 production, he’s still only 31 and is earning $17 million this summer.

Not here of course.

Neil Walker warms up before batting practice at PNC Park — as a member of the Mets. (Matt Freed / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

For the balance of this discussion, therefore, we’re not going to get hung up on money, unlike the Pirates. When we posit that the Walker deal is probably only the third worst trade in Pirates history, we’re just talkin’ baseball. This is about who got what for whom and what happened to them, so never mind that the Pirates wound up paying Matt Morris about $10 million for 16 starts after they dealt Rajai Davis for him at the deadline in 2007. Morris was released in April of the next season and never pitched again. Davis is still active with the Oakland A’s and was last noted tying Game 7 of the 2016 World Series with an eighth-inning homer that took the Indians into extra inning, where they lost despite another Davis RBI.

Still, I wouldn’t even slot the Davis-for-Morris gambit among the worst five Pirates trades ever, a list that still has as its gargoyle capstone the shipment of Aramis Ramirez to the Cubs near the 2003 deadline for Jose Hernandez, Matt Bruback, and a player to be named later.

Advertise with us

“I was the player to be named later, but I wasn’t supposed to be the player to be named later,” said Bobby Hill this week from California, where he’s head coach of the Mission College Saints in a community college league. “The Pirates were looking at a pitcher, and I was playin’ pretty darned well for the Cubs. I know they talk about this being the worst (Pirates) trade ever, but if you look at the other guys involved, I was the only one who had success with Pittsburgh.”

The Pirates dealt Ramirez essentially because they had no intention of paying more than the first four or five million of the near $150 million he’d eventually earn in an 18-year career, but remember, this isn’t about the money. Hernandez was a below average infielder when he arrived and a below average infielder when the Pirates released him barely two months later. Hill wasn’t released until the end of 2005, and it was something of a shock.

“I was DFA’d out of nowhere,” Hill said. “I remember being in the office with Dave Littlefield and Lloyd McClendon and getting the news. Lloyd told me later he had no idea that would happen, that I was his guy off the bench. I was ready to break the pinch hit record.”

When he was released, Hill had 16 pinch hits for the 2005 Pirates, needing four to break Jose Pagan’s single-season club record that had stood for 36 years. Hill never played another big league game.

Bobby Hill and his son, also named Bobby, took in a Pirates-Giants game last week in San Francisco. (Pittsburgh Pirates)

Fans a few generations older might insist the Ramirez trade could not have been worse than the sudden deportation of Ralph Kiner to Chicago 50 years earlier. Kiner led the league in homers in all seven of his summers in Pittsburgh through 1952, but while the Pirates got little from the six players they acquired in a 10-player dead, Kiner played only three more seasons for the Cubs and Indians and never again hit 30 homers. Rickey was essentially right in pointing out that the Pirates lost spectacularly even with a superstar like Kiner in the outfield, and could do the same without him, which they did spectacularly for another five years.

Advertise with us

Plenty of terrible Pirates trades have folded into repressed memory, but I must scare up Benito Santiago’s short stay on the North Shore in 2005.

Littlefield traded a fine young pitching prospect named Leo Nunez to Kansas City for Santiago, a 40-year-old catcher who didn’t look a day over 80. When Santiago tripled in his first Pirates at bat, I half expected a press box announcement along the lines of “Attention Media: That was Benito Santiago’s last major league triple.”

Because it was, and Santiago was released a month later and never played again. Nunez would go on to pitch for eight seasons in the big leagues, in one three-year stretch saving 92 games for the Marlins, but eventually got suspended because he wasn’t Leo Nunez. He was Juan Carlos Oviedo.

Oviedo had hidden his identity and his age from baseball from the beginning of his career, insodoing and far more importantly, literally became the player to be named later.

The list of additional players the Pirates wish they hadn’t traded or weren’t forced to trade would resemble a good-sized town’s phone book, as if that were still a thing: Jason Schmidt, Chris Young, Bert Blyleven, Manny Sanguillen, Adam LaRoche, Willie Randolph, Dock Ellis (to the Yankees for pitcher and former medical student Doc Medich, prompting legendary PG baseball writer Charley Feeney to snort: “Ellis was not only a better pitcher than Medich, he was a better doctor!”), Freddy Sanchez, Jay Buhner, Bob Elliott, Preacher Roe, et al.

Advertise with us

The additional list of players they are thrilled to have acquired via trades resembles a smaller town’s phone book, if that’s still a thing since the time I used in one paragraph ago: Brian Giles, Jason Bay, Bobby Bonilla, Mike Gonzales, Doug Drabek, Felipe Rivero, Harvey Haddix, Don Hoak, Smokey Burgess (the last three coming in one deal that sent Frank Thomas to Cincinnati in 1959 and laid the asphalt to the 1960 World Series).

But the trade that brought Van Slyke and LaValliere is still their best, fueling three division titles beginning in 1990, and LaValliere made Pirates fans forget the popular Pena, their All-Star catcher and the best player on the team at the time of the trade.

“My first throw as a Pirate, I’ll never forget, replacing Tony Pena, was trying to get Vince Coleman,” LaValliere said. “Vince was practically dusting himself off at second before I released it, he had such a great jump. His jump was so good, in my throwing motion I tried to stop my arm because there was no point, but the ball came out like a Charlie Brown throw, landed on the back of the mound, and rolled to second.

“And the crowd, ‘BOOOOO!’”

Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com