Not saying that the 2017 version of Pirates’ baserunning has become a menace to both themselves and the community, but three people were picked off during the kids-run-the-bases promotion last Sunday at PNC Park.

Of course we kid the Buccos.

Their baserunning’s not that bad, really. It’s worse.

This is a team that once failed to score on consecutive doubles, which would be the most comical baserunning story I know except a guy I used to work with once told me he’d failed to score from third on a triple because, on his way to the plate, an adjacent opposing bench lined with screaming Little Leaguers convinced him the ball in play had gone foul. He returned to third, met a teammate who was just arriving with a standup triple, and was tagged out.

Advertise with us

It hasn’t regressed to exactly that with these Pirates, but they’re certainly in the ballpark.

“We are having to teach the game of baseball more than we have ever taught the game of baseball in my 20-some years in the game,” Pirates General Manager Neal Huntington was telling me recently. “There’s a disconnect between game knowledge and aptitude and instinct in today’s players that there wasn’t 20 years ago. Part of it is that high school coaches and pitching coaches call every pitch at the freshman level, let alone the varsity level. We are drilled and skilled much better than we were 25 years ago, but we’re less instinctive and we’re less baseball game knowledge(able) than we’ve ever been.”

Huntington and Clint Hurdle and everyone in baseball operations with the Pirates aren’t the only people searching to answer the question put so eloquently by New York Mets manager Casey Stengel long, long ago: “Can’t anyone here play this game?”

Bad baserunning, throwing to the wrong base, ignoring the cut-off man, getting picked off, running into outs, losing track of the outs when the actual total (it’s 0, 1, or 2) is available on any of several nearby Jumbotrons – these are industry-wide problems, which, Huntington posits, have more to do with the way amateur baseball has evolved than the way big league baseball is coached and managed.

“It goes back to the experience of the players,” said Jack Zduriencik, the long-time GM of the Seattle Mariners who now contributes to the Pirates radio broadcasts. “Players get to the big leagues a lot quicker. When we were younger, everybody played baseball all the time. All the time. Now it’s a world-wide game, players from all over, and a lot of these kids don’t play the game as much. They’re learning it in showcases, on travelling teams, and the whole philosophy is trying to get noticed rather than playing the game the right way necessarily.

Advertise with us

“Another thing is, kids that are breaking into the game now have only known the game as it is today. You’ve got kids with I-Pads – they don’t watch the game, they see the highlights on SportsCenter.”

While all of that makes perfect sense – depressingly perfect sense – the manifest problem locally is enduring the game where it’s supposed to be played best, where kids run the bases free on Sundays.

The Pirates season that will be 25 percent history by mid-week has descended rapidly toward incompetence, in no small part from some non-baseball developments that have de-stabilized the organization at the field level.

“You try to grow boys into men and men into leaders and ballplayers at the same time, because it’s significantly different today,” said Hurdle. “There’s more talk about what you do off the field than ever before, so it’s about representing your city, representing the name on the front (of the jersey) more than the name on the back. We’ve done very well for six years at keepin’ our names out of the headlines, and then we get popped twice in four months. You feel those things as the manager.”

The first pop arrived when it became evident that Jung Ho Kang could not get back into the country after a string of DUI charges in his native South Korea, the second when Starling Marte, the club’s best player a year ago and a talent so rich teammate Gerrit Cole referred to him as “truly the only five-tool player I’ve ever played with,” was caught with a sixth tool if you count Nandrolone, and the commissioner’s office surely did, banning him for 80 games on a steroids rap.

Advertise with us

Those who figured Hurdle’s offense was headed for disaster without Kang and Marte were merely dead on. Through the first 35 games, the Pirates scored three runs or fewer 22 times (the same figure last year was 11). Despite some pitching that’s actually been better than I expected, they are 2-20 in those games.

In a little more than three-and-a-half hours on April 30, Anthony Rendon hit three homers and drove in 10 runs for the Washington Nationals against the Mets, which I mention only because most of six weeks into 2017, these were the season totals for noted Pirates regulars:

Jordy Mercer: 2 homers, 10 RBI.

Gregory Polanco: 1 homer, 7 RBI.

Josh Bell: 5 homers, 9 RBI.

Advertise with us

Twice on the road trip that ends this afternoon in Phoenix, the Pirates made it to the seventh inning without managing a hit. Monday night in Los Angeles, Hurdle’s lineup struck out 17 times in nine innings, tying the franchise record.

Former Pirates shortstop Dick Groat once struck out 38 times, but it took him 155 games in 1966.

Kang’s idiocy made David Freese a starter, and Freese was the club’s best hitter until he got hurt 18 games into it (three homers, 10 RBI!), but when Marte was sentenced, Adam Frazier became a starter until he got hurt, when John Jaso became pretty much full-time with a skill set barely acceptable for part-time.

All of that triggered an historic roster convulsion few would have predicted. The Pirates have already deployed Major League Baseball’s first Lithuanian born-and-raised player (Dovydas Neverauskas), its first African player (Gift Ngoepe), but they still await the arrival of the first really good player.

Because it’s not Andrew McCutchen.

Advertise with us

McCutchen, the former National League MVP now consuming nearly 15 percent of the payroll, was hitting .210 at the weekend in what so many had hoped would be his bounce-back year. Back in center field after Marte unraveled the great shell game outfield boondoggle (helpfully announced on Super Bowl Sunday), Cutch thumped his chest in defiance of management’s considered judgment of how awful he was there last year.

“We’ve battled suspensions, injuries, stuff that is no secret; it’s out there and we’ve had a lot of ups and down,” said veteran closer Tony Watson. “We just gotta find a way. We gotta get those guys back, get others healthy. Hopeful we’ll have the whole crew together, win some games, win some series, and hopefully playing some meaningful baseball games late.”

Yes, as Watson pointed out, it’s not even Memorial Day.

Is that the good news or the bad news?

Hope rests almost entirely with the club’s pitching, but for reasons best left to the Ivy League graduates, the Pirates got to the weekend 4-2 when Tyler Glasnow pitches (despite his 6.33 ERA) but 8-13 when Cole, Jamison Taillon, and Ivan Nova start (despite their combined ERA of 2.83). Taillon had surgery this week for what doctors suspected is testicular cancer.

Advertise with us

There’s plenty of bad-to-indifferent baseball playing coast-to-coast in 2017, with 19 of the 30 teams no better than a game above .500 at the weekend.

But way too much of it is concentrated where they seldom raise the Jolly Roger.

Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com