To quote that guy who bought the case of real expensive beer only to discover the caps on the bottles were not twist-offs, “There is nothing like an opener.”
So as you wade into another baseball season today and perhaps enjoy a cold one, be appreciative of all kinds of openers, but particularly baseball’s, which comes with its own distinctive flavor, traditions, and touchstones.
My favorite such touchstone is the opening day lineup, which rarely looks terribly remarkable by itself, but held up against last year’s opening day lineup, the one from the year before that, and from 10 years ago, 20 years ago, 50 years ago — in those comparisons you don’t merely taste the history of the game, but the narrative and dramatic arcs of a franchise.
As for the Pirates, the best place to start on Clint Hurdle’s lineup card for opening day is exactly where that enduring and iconic baseball question still persists: “Who’s on first?”
Whoever it is, that particular human will be the eighth different opening day Bucco first baseman in the past eight years.
Oh yeah, the streak lives.
Read More
How many of the past seven can you name? I’d estimate two-to-four, as the recent history of Pirates first-base hi-jinks is a powerful memory blocker. I can name them all, since I just looked them up for this column, but otherwise, I’d be right there with you in that two-to-four range.
They are Pedro Alvarez (2015), Travis Ishikawa (2014), Gaby Sanchez (2013), Garrett Jones (2012), Lyle Overbay (2011), Jeff Clement (2010) and Adam LaRoche (2009).
The antithesis of first base on this club is center field, where Andrew McCutchen can make his seventh consecutive opening day start today, the longest such stretch among active Pirates, albeit not terribly historic.
Roberto Clemente made 15 in a row in right from 1958 through 1972, Willie Stargell made 17 opening day lineups in a row from 1968-80 in either left field or at first base, and Honus Wagner appeared in eight in a row and 14 of 15 from 1900-14.
Still, when it comes to narrative arc, that’s where McCutchen’s persistence glows. His first appearance in an opening day lineup was for one of the worst teams in Pirates history (2010) and just five years later, he led one of the best (98 wins in 2015).
One look at the lineup from April 5, 2010, brings a clarity of resonance to one thought: This might be the worst opening day lineup in club history.
Manager John Russell, to begin his strategic day against the Los Angeles Dodgers, sat down and wrote this one. Akinori Iwamura (2B), McCutchen (CF), Jones (RF), Ryan Doumit (C), Lastings Milledge (LF), Clement (1B), Andy LaRoche (3B), Zach Duke (P), Ronny Cedeno (SS).
So with Milledge in left, a shortstop he didn’t trust to hit eighth, and a third baseman whose 64 RBIs the previous year led the club, Russell’s team lashed three homers among seven extra base hits and flogged the Dodgers that day, 11-5.
Man was a genius.
They exited first place 72 hours later and went on to lose 105 times.
It’s especially easy to conclude that 2010 brought the worst opening day lineup ever if you don’t look at 2009 first: Nyjer Morgan (LF), Freddie Sanchez (2B), Nate McLouth (CF), Doumit (C), Adam LaRoche (1B), Andy LaRoche (3B), Brandon Moss (RF), Jack Wilson (SS), Paul Maholm (P). It might not look as bad, but again, Andy’s 64 RBIs led the club.
Jim Leyland’s first team, the one that lost 17 times to the Mets alone on the way to 64-98, looked halfway competent, relatively speaking, on opening day 1986: R.J. Reynolds (CF), Joe Orsulak (RF), Johnny Ray (2B), Sid Bream (1B), Steve Kemp (LF), Tony Pena (C), Jim Morrison (3B), Sammy Khalifa (SS), Rick Reuschel (P).
As for the best opening day lineup in Pirates history, I’ll take the one Bill Virdon wrote April 15, 1972: Rennie Stennett (2B), Al Oliver (CF), Clemente (RF), Stargell (LF), Richie Hebner (3B), Manny Sanguillen (C), Bob Robertson (1B), Jackie Hernandez (SS), Dock Ellis (P).
That team won 96 times, but you might point out that the lineup Chuck Tanner wrote April 6, 1979 — Frank Taveras (SS), Omar Moreno (CF), Dave Parker (RF), Stargell (1B), Bill Robinson (LF), Stennett (2B), Ed Ott (C), Phil Garner (3B), Bert Blyleven (P) — formed the basis of a team that won 98 times and then seven more times for the franchise’s last world championship.
Sure, but we could talk about this all day.
You’ve got a game to watch.
And blessedly, you’ve got an opener.
Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com and Twitter @genecollier.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.