Gene Collier: Hello everybody and welcome to the inaugural reasonably-live chat. It's a noon kickoff but you can submit questions now as the captains meet at midfield.
Gene Collier: Good afternoon. As Coach Tomlin would, I'll start with a review of our most recent performance, which shouldn't take long since this is the inaugural chat. So there. As for the health of the chat, I had a tooth sliced and drilled this morning and can best be described as day-to-day, but then, aren't we all?
I'll be taking your questions presently.
From Donora Pennsylvania: Hello Gene, I read a Post-Gazette story this morning about Ken Griffey and Stan Musial "birth place" of Donora....my hometown too. I recall you writing a story from there a few years back as well. What were your impressions of Donora?
Gene Collier: Thanks for remembering that piece I did on Donora from 2011. I posted a link to it on Twitter this morning and it was about how the retirement of Ken Griffey Jr. the town no longer had a link to major league baseball and three of its great players, the Griffeys and Stan Musial. The day I went there was the only day I've spent there, but it looked like a pretty typically battered Mon Valley town with its industry ripped away, not at all unlike the town I grew up in on the other side of the state. The people were great and I could feel the great authenticity of the place's working class traditions.
Nazzer: You worried about how this Pirates roster is shaping up? Seems like they're not spending all the money they have.
Read More
Gene Collier: Worry probably isn't the right word. I worry about the mortgage, the kids, my tooth, etc., but rarely the teams. But it's a good question Nazzer, because the Pirates seem to be all about major subtractions and minimalist additions. If it seems like they're not spending all the money that have, it's because they're not spending all the money they have. They need a major renegotiation of terms with Root Sports, for whom they provide oodles of programming and ratings for a return on the low side of local TV money, relatively speaking
The Card Says Moops: Gene, just finished reading your latest Trite Trophy column (again). In my opinion you are a First Ballot Hall of Famer...anyway, given that Pitt basketball has changed their style of play to fit better in the ACC, do you think it will help them get further in the NCAA tournament?
Gene Collier: Thanks for reading the 32nd annual cliché-fest and being one of the literally dozen(s) of people who look forward to it annually. If Pitt is going to play the way it did against Georgia Tech, the might or might advance further in the tournament, but they'll be a heckuva lot more fun to watch. To me, that's more important, but,of course, I'm screwed up.
Josh Loves Nard: Hi Gene, given what we saw this season do you think Pat Narduzzi is finally gonna be the right guy to bring Pitt football back to supremacy?
Gene Collier: I'd give Pat Narduzzi a solid 'B' for his first season, but I don't think it was a great indication that with a month to prepare for Navy, his team still allowed 44 points. He's made his rep as a defensive coach, but after that game seemed terribly put off by the fact that Navy had done some things he didn't expect. What, is that not allowed?
Sidbreamwasneverfast: 100 duck size horses or 1 horse sized duck.... Which would you rather battle?
Gene Collier: Are those the only choices?
JamesinNYC: Thanks for taking over the All Sports Chat. Do you know if other cities get do chats? As a PGH kid and fan I have to admit I feel pretty lucky.
Gene Collier: You're quite welcome but via full disclosure, I haven't take over Jerry Micco's All-Sports Chat. Nobody chats like the boss. As far as I know, these things go on everywhere and in some cities, columnists even chat while covering games. I would not be able to do that as I was born without the ability to multi-task. There are, as you suggest, plenty of things to love about our city. Not sure where the PG's live chats turn up on the various rankings however.
Chaz: Watching the pens this season I can't believe how bad this team passes the puck. It is never brought up on the telecasts but watching you see them giving up puck possession by not connecting with simple short passes that can lead to chances. Kunitz is the worst and even Crosby and Malkin misfire on easy passes. Defensively Matta misses wide open guys constantly. This is never mentioned in any hockey talk. Do you see this and how can this be rectified?
Gene Collier: Yes I've seen this and I understand you're frustration. The puck management issues have improved greatly under Mike Sullivan but frankly, the thing that surprises me more than the inability to complete simply passes is the club's awful shooting, as reflected in its percentage. I began to notice last season that Crosby, in particular, blows a lot of scoring chances, and with shots that aren't even close. I suppose that kind of thing can be corrected, but if I knew how to correct it, I don't think I'd be doing this chat.
JamesinNYC: You blitz you get burned, but if you don't your corners get burned so you might as well send it every time, except running play situations right?
Gene Collier: Are you talking about bringing the house? Because if you bring the house, you'd better get home. If you get home and generate a splash play, you'd better take that to the house. I hope this is clear.
Alex: What are your predictions for Saturday's Steelers game?
Gene Collier: Wet. Raw. Cold. Violent. Many, many commercials and clichés. Oh, and Bengals 30, Steelers 23.
Thanks for your great questions and we'll do it again next week at this time unless I hit the powerball or figure out how to belch beer through the nose at will, in which case I'm never leaving the house again.
Follow Gene Collier on Twitter @genecollier and join him next Thursday, Jan. 14 at noon for the second installment of his weekly all-sports chat.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.