Over lunch, Roy McHugh mentioned how it’s hard to remember 50 years ago, and even though he was speaking to a guy who can’t always remember 50 minutes ago, we got through the meal with an achieved illumination.
There are plenty of events worth recalling from 50 years ago, as 1965 brought the Voting Rights Act, the death of Churchill, the birth of Chris Rock, the first ever blast of the Keith Richards’ guitar lick that became “Satisfaction,” and the invention of the Pillsbury Doughboy just to name a few.
But few are the remaining eyewitnesses to one of the most controversial moments in sports history, indeed of America’s cultural history, by which I mean the second heavyweight title fight between the newly-renamed Muhammad Ali and Sonny Liston, a sordid and farcical and fearful and yet somehow seminal affair that hits its 50th anniversary a week from Monday.
“There was a lot of security,” said the one eyewitness with whom I’m lucky to lunch with regularly, “a huge police presence. Some people were afraid to sit at ringside.”
And that’s when I asked Roy McHugh, whom I doubt has ever seen 140 pounds from the heavier side, why he wasn’t afraid on the night of May 25, 1965.
And that’s when Roy laughed, which is about all the explanation you need.
“I wasn’t even covering it,” said the incomparable former Pittsburgh Press columnist. “I asked the managing editor if he wanted me to cover it and he said no, that it was going to be a fiasco, so I just took a few days off and went up there.”
You might be wondering by now as to the age of Roy McHugh, which allows me to identify another milestone as it draws near. On June 12, Roy will turn 100. One of these days, I think, he’s going to start looking tired, but the only thing he finds tiring at 99 is being asked “all the time!” how he’s feeling.
So now he’s got a stock answer.
“I can’t see; I can’t hear; I walk like a drunk, but I have no terminal illnesses.”
On the contrary, at 99 and nine-tenths, Roy will walk you to his favorite haunts and hold the door open for you. He will take his salad dressing on the side.
“Roy, c’mon,” I tell him. “You’re 99. Dump that dressing right on the thing. You’ve won.”
But he was saying, about Ali-Liston II, the fight he watched in the second row (from the row in front of him, Sports Illustrated’s Neil Leifer took the iconic photo of Ali standing over a fallen Liston, taunting and growling), “Nobody wanted the fight; that’s how it wound up in Lewiston, Maine. I don’t remember how I got up there. Flew to Portland or Boston, I guess, and drove the rest of the way. Stayed at a big white-framed hotel that must have gone back to the 19th century. Had a porch all the way around, back to when people sat on front porches. No air conditioning. It was sort of a non-descript factory town. Nothing stood out about it. Someone desribed it as depressed. It wouldn’t be high on the most livable cities list.”
Fifteen months earlier, Ali (then Cassius Clay) had taken Liston’s title in Miami in a kind of foreshadowing fiasco, with Liston quitting on his stool before the seventh round. The ramp-up to the rematch played out against the backdrop of Clay announcing he joined the “Black Muslims,” the assassination of Malcolm X, Liston’s latest arrest (he was a seasoned ex-con), a reshuffling and possible marginalizing of Liston’s infamous mob management, and a palpable sense that one or both fighters might meet the same fate as Malcolm X before the bell for Round 1.
The FBI reportedly had 12 men with Ali around the clock. Liston said he received a death threat from the Nation of Islam. Roy McHugh was ringside on his day off.
“I thought all the circumstances made it more interesting,” Roy said. “I wanted to get in on that scene.”
So, almost miraculously, in a half-filled converted hockey rink 100 miles from anywhere, the fight started. For a little more than 90 seconds, normality reigned. Ali circled. Liston pawed.
But then Ali launched what flashed into history as The Phantom Punch (the title of the 2008 Liston biopic starring Ving Rhames).
“It was not a phantom punch,” Roy said. “It was a good punch and I had a good view of it. I’d describe is a chop, a right-hand chop. Got Liston on the side of the face, high on the cheekbone. It hurt him. Ali could punch.”
Liston fell to his right and then onto his back. He got to one knee, then rolled onto his back again. Referee Jersey Joe Walcott, trying to force Ali to a neutral corner, lost track of the count, which the knockdown timekeeper had at 5. When Walcott finally got re-situated, he started the count at 1.
The timekeeper tried frantically to communicate this discrepancy to Walcott. Walcott stopped counting and approached the ring apron, by which time Liston had gotten to his feet, and the fighters re-engaged.
Walcott ran back to the fighters and, since Liston had not beaten the official count, declared the fight over.
Ali by a knockout.
“The crowd started yelling, ‘Fake! Fake! Fake!’ then, ‘Fix! Fix! Fix!’ ” Roy said. “When Liston was down, some said, Ali was yelling, ‘Get up and fight! People won’t believe this! Nobody will believe this.’ A lot of people thought Liston hadn’t even been hit.
“But I saw the punch. It was a short punch. A short, hard punch.”
Liston would be dead in five years; Ali would be a central cultural figure in America and the world for at least the next 50.
And Roy McHugh would take his dressing on the side.
Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.