If you are among the many hockey fans who found themselves underwhelmed by March of the Penguins, you’re doubtless finding the sequel, April of the Penguins, nothing short of loathsome.
Bereft of plot, narrative, subtext; it’s a full-on horror show, a death dive into the darkest fathoms of the Southern nee Antarctic Ocean, the place where the most unworthy Penguins go to rot.
All right, not quite.
At least not quite yet.
“The fact of the matter is, we’re sitting here with 96 points, on the bubble of getting into the playoffs in a year when we’ve had such key injuries to our top two defensemen and three of our top four, then [another] injury to [Kris] Letang at the most critical time,” Penguins general manager Jim Rutherford was saying Wednesday. “When we had most of them together, we made the California trip and got 5 points out of 6, then we came back and lost [Patric] Hornqvist and [Evgeni] Malkin [to injuries], so we lost the next four. Then we got them back and won the next two, and then we lost Letang.”
The Penguins are 1-3-1 since the previous time Letang got banged and have won only thrice in their past 13. With two games left in a season that’s burning like it wants to be the lead story on Channel 2, they’re about as likely to miss the postseason as not, which is one of the 1,001 scenarios that get NHL coaches fired.
You should note that among those 1,001 scenarios, at least 500 of them include no verifiable fault by the coach in question.
In the manic climate that surrounds a hockey club that hasn’t won a game since it put playoff tickets on sale a week ago, the notion that Mike Johnston is coaching for his job this weekend walks chat rooms and social media like truth.
“No, no, no,” Rutherford said . “Mike hasn’t been able to play with a full team. That’s kind of the history of the Penguins. This isn’t the first year it’s happened. Based on where I sit with Mike, he has two more years on his contract. The conversations around here are very positive regarding what he’s done and how he’s handled different situations.”
No one can even pretend to read the mind of Mario Lemieux on this question, and I suppose it wouldn’t be totally unrealistic to think that it is Rutherford who is generally managing for his job this weekend, but I doubt that seriously.
If the Penguins were to fire Johnston, for example, they could find themselves in the fairly ridiculous situation of paying three coaches at once. If Dan Bylsma remains in exile, he, Johnston, and Johnston’s replacement will all be cashing checks from the offices on Fifth Avenue.
The new coach being, obviously, Mike Babcock, another truth tirelessly zombie-lurching the shoulders of the information superhighway.
Just as Babcock could not coach half of Wilkes-Barre’s roster to a Stanley Cup, it is foolish to believe Johnston should be up to the task in only his first season as an NHL coach, a season that started with Malkin, Letang, Sidney Crosby and Pascal Dupuis missing from all or part of training camp, a season whose unofficial theme music was, “Hey, Hey We’re The Mumpies.”
If there’s a recent development that the whole hockey operation should question itself over it’s the acquisition of Ben Lovejoy for a defense that now literally cannot get out of its own way.
Rutherford pulled the trigger on that transaction, obviously, but it wasn’t via unexpected phone call in the middle of the night.
“I would expect that that would be criticized,” Rutherford said. “If we had [Christian] Ehrhoff and Letang playing, we could plug Lovejoy and [Ian] Cole where I expected they’d fit. One thing about Lovejoy that I said at the time: This is a trade that over time will not be in our favor. We traded a young player [Simon Despres] for him, but our hockey organization is basically a group of nine people, and [it was clear] the trade was made more for experience, a trade that would give us a better chance in the playoffs.”
With the exception of Letang and, to a slightly lesser extent, Paul Martin, none of the defensemen are programmed to play upward of 25 minutes, which they’re all doing because there have been only five of them in most games recently.
Thus Lovejoy is completely overextended, as are Cole, Scuderi, Derrick Pouliot, and, wait, is that Taylor Chorney?
No wonder the Ottawa Senators fired a staggering 44 shots at Marc-Andre Fleury Tuesday night, including 21 of the game’s final 24.
For all that, the Penguins likely need only a couple of points in these final two games to wind up in the postseason. One commentator said after the game Tuesday night that if that happens, “Nobody wants to face Pittsburgh.”
OK, but for the moment, do you know who really doesn’t want to face Pittsburgh?
Pittsburgh.
Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com and Twitter @genecollier.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.