Peter Edward Rose, whose maddeningly level swing churned out more hits than anyone who ever played Major League Baseball, never saw an opposing fielder he thought was positioned properly.
That’s why he is also the game’s all-time leader in squawking, at least as expressed by this exact complaint: “How could he be playin’ me there?!”
Didn’t matter if he had just smashed a one-hopper to the pitcher.
“How could he be playin’ me there?”
Rose felt the proper place to play him was anywhere the defense could not possibly take a hit away, and in his era, before sophisticated spray charts, metrics, analytics, dWAR-corrected defensive models, Charley Hustle mostly got his wish.
All of which would be neither here nor there, except that watching Pete Rose hit from 1963 until 1986 was a lot more compelling than watching the National League hit .249 in 2014, as more and more would-be menaces at the plate rapped easy grounders into over-shifted infields.
Read More
And that is really all Rob Manfred was saying a month ago when, as the fresh prince of the commissioner’s office, he mentioned that he had be open to eliminating such shifts, a comment he modified significantly because it sparked a massive industry-wide conniption felt most acutely in the offices of the highly paid algorhythmics. Those brilliant Ivy Leaguers no doubt had to be paddled back to life with defibrillators before being told they could resume informing baseball managers on the mathematically correct way to set up their defense.
What a relief.
All Manfred was saying was that “it’s smart to pay attention,” to the forces changing the delicate political balance between pitchers and hitters, and that defensive shifts are one of those forces.
Not the only one.
Not the main one.
One.
As the game strains to maintain the generation of fans who spend a good seven or eight of the nine innings staring at their phones, it’s not going to be helped by three hours of pitch and catch interrupted by the occasional grounder to the short right fielder (formerly the second baseman).
For the record, I wouldn’t want to see the shift outlawed by forcing defenses to put two infielders on each side of second base when the ball is pitched. That’s too severe. I would prefer to see hitters adjust to the shift and beat it by hitting the ball the other way, which is a lot to ask of players whose status among society’s 1 percent could be compromised by a dip in their power numbers traceable to shift aversion.
"You never know whether people are going to adjust,“ Manfred said in his semi-retraction to Fox Sports’ Ken Rosenthal. ”Maybe a lot of hitters went home this winter and they figured out how to go the other way against the shift and it's going to self-correct and we're not going to need to make a change. But we look at these things. We think it's important to think about possible solutions, even if it turns out we don't have a problem."
Throughout the evolution of all four so-called major sports, fundamental adjustments have been made when the front office feared defense was smothering the entertainment along with the offense, and there is hot empirical evidence that we’ve reached that point in baseball again. Runs were down to a 33-year-low in 2014, 8.14 per game. Runs for last year and the year before were at the lowest point for consecutive seasons since 1975-76.
To his credit, Pirates owner Bob Nutting told media Wednesday in Bradenton, Fla., that Manfred’s shift comments were perfectly in line with the commissioner’s mission.
“Commissioner Manfred, just as commissioner Selig [was], will be respectful of the entire game,“ Nutting said. ”He represents 30 clubs, not the New York Yankees, not the Pittsburgh Pirates, and it’s his role to find the right balance to grow the game overall. Part of that game is competitive balance, access to talent, the things that are critically important to the Pittsburgh Pirates. At the same time he needs to find every opportunity to grow the game both domestically and internationally.“
Toward those ends, presumably, Manfred also let slip this week that he would not be averse to shortening the season, perhaps to the mid-20th century standard of 154 games instead of 162. Unlike with the shift comment, where I liked the fact that Manfred was thinking more than the particular thought, I could be down with the shorter season. In fact, you could lop off April entirely.
This idea, however, will be what the business people call a non-starter.
Owners are not going to give away eight gates. Not even over Ernie (Let’s Play Two!) Banks’ dead body will they give you a doubleheader for one admission price. But the owners won’t be solely culpable on that one. The players aren’t going to surrender days of service against their pensions, so that’s likely going nowhere.
In any event, I like the way Manfred’s thinking so far, and I know Pete Rose is anxious to talk with him to find out where he’s positioned on the Pete Rose matter. I suspect it will produce one more, ”How could he be playin’ me there?“
Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com and Twitter @genecollier.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.