With most of the Penguins off until Tuesday for the NHL's all-star break, this would appear to be a worthy opportunity for upper management to take a hard look at any potential impact that hockey's so-called new analytics might have on coach Mike Johnston's first edition.
And yes, this is at least one person's idea of a good time.
"You can't just go on analytics, but I will say, I really like them," said general manager Jim Rutherford. "I really like them because it's just another checkpoint for me. I got scouting reports over here and they're talking about this guy, this way. I got a management group over here, they're talking about something else, and I got analytics over here showing me something else, and if there's a totally different viewpoint, then I gotta get everybody together and figure out what's going on."
Of course, what's going on with the Penguins for the moment is not anything that usually gets lost in some empirical dark alley of a quadratic formula; it's not so much related to algorithms as it is to biorhythms.
Translation: They stink.
With Wednesday night's shootout loss to the mostly listless Chicago Blackhawks, the Penguins have but four wins in their past 14 games.
Read More
The problem for Rutherford lies in a pretty obvious parallel. Just as the 21st century hockey metrics are probably most useful to an NHL team when they are used to measure the specific performance areas of NHL players, NHL games are still more easily won by, well yes, established NHL players -- and the Penguins don't have enough of those right now.
Or for most of this season, really.
As long as Johnston has to keep meeting the Wilkes-Barre Express and has little choice but running Scott Harrington and Brian Dumoulin and Taylor Chorney out on defense and penciling in forward lines held together with your Andrew Ebbetts and Bobby Farnhams and Jayson Megnas and Dominik Uhers and Bryan Rust Never Sleeps's, the chances that he'll get any kind of winning edge from the Penguins' new exposure to analytics aren't terribly great.
"There were a few people in this organization that embraced [analytics], but it didn't run throughout the whole organization," said Rutherford, who's probably as progressive a 65-year-old as you'll find in an NHL executive suite. "That's one of the things that I said [when he arrived last May] -- that we're going to use it throughout the organization.
"But understand, as I told these people, don't expect that the analytics are going to make our final decision for us. First of all, analytics start with people's information, and it's not always accurate. And different analytics, whether it's puck possession or red-zone shots, have to be viewed in that light, but everybody's bought into the analytics, even if at the end of the day, it still boils down to a personal decision and a gut feeling."
Just as it took most of a decade, and in some instances more, for the value of advanced metrics to take hold in baseball -- where you can now barely write a lineup card without approval from the Matt Damon character in Good Will Hunting -- hockey still has a dominant old guard that probably didn't have a lot of graduate-level exposure to calculus.
Plus, as Rutherford points out: "It's easier in baseball. It's more of an individual sport. It's kind of more cut and dried. You're hitting the ball on your own, you're catching the ball on your own. You're pitching the ball on your own. Hockey is more of a team sport."
Just as it is difficult (at least for me) to conceptualize how such a chaotic sport as Rutherford's can be usefully illuminated by such absolute numbers, it has been difficult for hockey teams to know how to act around the data.
Some refuse to say whether they use advanced analytics. Some are anxious for you to know that they do, but won't reveal their sources for the data or the manner in which they interpret it.
"Puck possession, we use [the metric for] that, but that's not the main point that drives us," Rutherford said. "But we don't talk about what metrics we use or how we analyze them."
If you're not numerophobic, you can visit the new frontier of hockey-player analysis on numerous websites, but the crash course is basically that teams are paying a lot of attention to an individual's Corsi numbers and Fenwick numbers (both uber-precise measurements of puck possession), and their WOWY numbers as well, which measure how a player performs with and without certain teammates, all of this even as certain old-guard execs are only convinced that Corsi Fenwick is a backup goalie somewhere in the Western Hockey League and WOWY is what the Saskatoonians exclaim when he flashes the toe save.
But while guys like that weren't looking, football's beloved red zone came to hockey.
"If you're watching a player and you're keeping the analytics," said Rutherford, "and he's giving up more red-zone shots than he's getting, that's an issue. You want to be a high plus in red-zone shots. It's how you play in the most critical areas."
It's how hockey will be played more and more, with one executive eye on the numbers and the other eye leaning that way.
Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.