Can’t say I was surprised the Penn State community celebrated heartily over the weekend on news of a settlement that would restore all 111 of Joe Paterno’s NCAA-hijacked victories.
Yet I hope that was mostly because they’ll celebrate almost anything in State College, where, if long-term memory serves, pitchers of Genesee Cream Ale were routinely reduced to half price just to celebrate the arrival of … Monday.
In February.
Of course, we celebrated heartily.
As it happens, the restoration of Paterno’s coaching record to its full dimensions is the correct thing to do for a couple of reasons.
Whether you think Paterno’s culpability in the Sandusky child sexual abuse scandal is damningly substantial or virtually nonexistent (as there seem to be precious few reasoned calibrations in between), Penn State gained no competitive advantage from the soon-to-be-malignant inconvenience of having a serial pedophile roam the countryside.
Read More
Sandusky’s pathology would come to mean many, many terrible things, things that won’t be mitigated anytime soon — but it never impacted the competition and it never meant, for example, that Northwestern would have avoided getting trimmed, 49-0, in Beaver Stadium in October 2002 if only Penn State’s administration not made the key to the Lasch Building available to the former defensive coordinator.
Furthermore, I would venture that a significant portion of Paterno’s 409 victories, now again the most in college football history, came against institutions this same NCAA had failed to prevent from cheating like hell.
All that said, the symbolism of 409, as displayed on the helmets of Penn State’s hockey team and anywhere else it might have turned up, is at best insensitive to the victims and at worst emblematic of a culture so imbued by the force-fed notion of Penn State exceptionalism that it remains, even after all this, impenetrable to humility.
Athletic director Sandy Barbour first agreed to the insensitivity charge on Twitter over the weekend, was promptly shouted down by the orthodox exceptionalists, then wound up apologizing.
That’s leadership?
Unfortunately, the terms of the settlement include some language the plaintiffs would have choked on only two weeks ago, mainly that Penn State agrees that the NCAA had “legitimate and good faith interest and concern regarding the Jerry Sandusky matter.”
I don’t think that’s even close to being true. If it were, State Sen. Jake Corman, R-Centre, and state Treasurer Rob McCord would not have sued, right?
I doubt that any legal or administrative protocols regarding serial child rape has a presence anywhere in the NCAA Manual. It’s a criminal matter. The NCAA’s primary mission in this caper was to administer a theatrical public flogging of one of its hallmark institutions in the vain hope that it would re-establish for itself something approximating relevance.
Even before the NCAA became an agency that allows the five most powerful athletic conferences to set their own rules that train had departed.
If the NCAA thought it had jurisdiction, its internal emails demonstrated something short of full conviction, with one administrator last summer saying she was “not sure we have a good answer to that.”
No kiddin’.
By agreeing that the NCAA had standing and acted in good faith, Penn State and the plaintiffs suing on its behalf show themselves willing to perpetuate a lie in exchange for getting the correct answer to college football trivia — who’s the winningest coach? That’s hardly worth it, even if keeping the $60 million fine in state happens to have been a worthy pursuit.
Sixty million, by the way, is another figure the NCAA pulled out of thin air (why not $600 million?) along with the disingenuous bluster choreographed by president Mark Emmert that the college presidents “want blood on this.” An investigation by USA Today appears to indicate there was no stomach for the so-called death penalty among the 21 persons on a presidential committee considering Penn State’s punishment, with one telling the paper he didn’t remember the exact vote, “but if you told me it was 19-2 against I’d believe it.”
In the meantime, no one in authority at Penn State is ready to talk about, much less plan, the full public refurbishing of the Paterno legacy, and no one should be.
Trials for then president Graham Spanier, then vice president Gary Schultz, and then athletic director Tim Curley, aren’t even on anyone’s docket yet, inexplicably enough. After any or all of them testify under oath on charges of perjury, obstruction, conspiracy, child endangerment and failure to report suspected abuse, after all relevant witnesses do the same, we might see some substantial portion of what has been so elusively contentious the past three years, namely the absolute truth.
The trials could be years in the making, as might their fallout, as might the fallout from the fallout. The absolute truth might well convulse the university community still again.
So, for now, if pitchers are half off, by all means, have at it. But I wouldn’t be dusting off any statues.
Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.