Does this sound like it will end well for the Pirates and Burnett? Me neither.

The Pirates have acquired right-handed pitcher A.J. Burnett and are responsible for paying him $8.5 million this summer.

So wait, what year is this?

Has that Facebook IPO thing happened yet? That was in 2012 I thought. Both those things.

Advertise with us

But the Burnett news is actual news. It happened Friday, which is fine, but look, if he fouls a ball off his face on the first day of spring training, things will be officially weird.

The Pirates owed Burnett $8.5 million in 2012, with the New York Yankees paying the balance of his $16.5 million salary. Now they owe him $8.5 million for 2015, with no one to help them defray the cost of a 38-year-old pitcher who lost 18 games this past summer. Does this sound like it will end well? Me neither.

Let’s chart it for a second.

A.J. Burnett’s wins as a 35-year-old: 16.

A.J. Burnett’s wins as a 36-year-old: 10.

Advertise with us

A.J. Burnett’s wins as a 37-year-old: 8.

I didn’t do very well in that section of the SAT, but I don’t think the next number is 16 again, or 14, or, gulp, 11.

“We did feel the hernia hindered him,” Pirates general manager Neal Huntington said about Burnett’s miserable summer in Philadelphia this year. “And there were some other factors. Indicators are that he’s still a good pitcher. Can still win big games for us. Can still eat innings. Still put us in a position to win every time he takes the ball.”

Burnett took the ball 34 times, a National League high, for a doomed Phillies team that wound up paying $176 million for a sickly 73 wins, including almost $15 million to Burnett. He ate more than 200 innings, but many of them went down the wrong way. Now he’s back, perhaps because Clint Hurdle’s starting rotation experienced a debilitating decline in its ETI (evident tattoo index) when A.J. left, or perhaps because, well, let the big right-hander tell it:

“I want to win,” Burnett said. “Pittsburgh, I believe, puts a good team out there every year. Bottom line — it’s where I want to finish my career, for this team, for this city.”

Advertise with us

Much will be made of the way Burnett declined a 2015 salary of $12.75 million from Philadelphia to take $4.25 million less from the Pirates, but, frankly, that would be a lot more heart-warming if he hadn’t made $123.9 million over the past eight years.

Always with great representation, Allan James Burnett has long been a good-to-very good starting pitcher with great-to-staggering contracts. Even the $8.5 million he will cost the Pirates this summer, Huntington admitted, will make it tough for the general manager to sign Francisco Liriano and Edinson Volquez for 2015.

That probably means the Pirates have swapped out Liriano for Burnett, who led the league in walks last year (97) with a 4.59 ERA and a 1.409 WHIP. That doesn’t look like a promising trade on its face, but if Burnett fails this season it won’t be because he’s uncomfortable with Hurdle, even if the two separated on less-than-fabulous terms.

Apparently, that’s water under the Clemente Bridge.

Burnett said he and the manager had a great chat the other day, and that they understand each other better now than when Hurdle chose Gerritt Cole to start the deciding game of the 2013 National League Division Series against St. Louis even though Burnett was eager and available.

Advertise with us

Burnett walked out of the manager’s office after hearing that news a year ago in October, probably because he was right. Cole was pitching awfully well, but Burnett was a proven postseason performer who probably would not have made the kind of mistake Cole did to St. Louis clutch master David Freese in Game 5, a hanging something or other that Freese whacked for a two-run homer to spark a 6-1 romp.

That’s right; I just can’t resist a second-guess that’s 13 months in the making.

If there’s a positive for the Pirates, it’s Burnett’s sandpaper demeanor. In the middle of the diamond, he remains as tough as anybody, not pitching for money or the art of the game or metrics or anything other than to plainly and simply beat you. That has real value, even if it doesn’t extend to the other parts of his game. I mean he’s not going to run out a grounder. Let’s not get crazy.

“Pittsburgh’s just where I belong; it’s just certain feelings you get, certain gut feelings you’ve got to go with,” he said. “So let’s do it. Let’s get going and let’s win a ring.”

All things considered, that would have sounded a lot more implausible in 2012.