One minute it was Buctober; the next it was Bucwinter.
You don't really need a Harvard climatologist to understand that climate change has altered both the duration and intensity of the seasons, but the constricted duration of this Pirates postseason was pretty alarming.
What kind of "season" was that?
The kind that lasts three hours and 12 minutes, apparently, and the kind that is effectively over well before that.
San Francisco shortstop Brandon Crawford swung some lumber at a generous portion of high slop that Pirates starter Edinson Volquez served up with the bases loaded in the fourth inning of the National League wild-card game. About 340 feet later, that dreadful 1-2 pitch was buried in the right field stands, puncturing the right flank of the Black Army of the Allegheny, and signaling the imminent extinction of Pittsburgh's grand baseball summer.
The largest crowd for a baseball game in PNC Park history did not seem terribly impressed that it was eyewitness to the only grand slam by a shortstop in the postseason, and showed even less enthusiasm, frankly, for the final pierorgi race until April two innings later.
Read More
Shocking.
Well it was a good thing Clint Hurdle's team had fought so hard to secure this home game as the setting for the dangerous contours of wild-card roulette. I mean, had the Pirates had to play this one in the Bay Area, they might have gotten hammered.
Safe at home, they got nipped, 8-0.
But this was not the kind of October surprise that bores into the marrow, nothing that will trigger the kind of enduring suffering the Oakland Athletics are registered for after a fabulous 12-inning American League wild-card round that saw them blow a 2-0 lead, a 7-3 lead and -- in the 12th and final inning -- an 8-7 lead on the way to dragging the Kansas City Royals to their first postseason victory since the Reagan Administration.
No this was a little easier to live with, if nothing else but for the brilliant pitching of San Francisco's Madison Bumgarner, who limited one of the best offenses in the league to just about one base runner per hour.
Bumgarner apparently had not won 18 times this season for nothing, hadn't gone 11-4 on the road because he is nervous in front of a hostile audience, not even one that prided itself on its ability to be exactly that and then some.
Bumgarner's surgical applications with his fastball, moving that four-seamer all around the perimeters of the strike zone and trapping the Pirates' best hitters with his offspeed stuff, somehow brought to the moment the immortal words of Hines Ward, the former Dancing With The Stars champion.
You remember him.
"Sometimes," Ward once said after a fairly decisive loss by your favorite football team, "you just have to take your hat off and hand it to them."
The Pirates were in trouble just as soon as it was evident that a lineup specifically designed to put strength-to-strength was essentially powerless against the experienced Giants left-hander.
Josh Harrison, 4 for 5 against Bumgarner lifetime with a home run, struck out and flied out in his first two trips.
Jordy Mercer, a .340 hitter career hitter against left-handers (and 3 for 7 against Bumgarner), went 0 for 4 and struck out twice. MVP candidate Andrew McCutchen didn't reach base in four trips against Bumgarner.
If there was anything even remotely galling about Wednesday night, it was only that a Pirates team that had played so well on the North Side all summer went so quietly into the night, not looking at all like a team that had won a record 51 games at PNC Park this summer, and worse, not making the place the least bit uncomfortable for a team with serious postseason gravitas.
The Giants won their eighth consecutive postseason game and their seventh consecutive elimination game, and that in itself should eliminate any extended coulda-woulda-shoulda regarding the Pirates' performance.
Now Hurdle can finally have his hip replacement surgery and the front office can get ready for a long offseason of Russell Martin-replacement surgery, which likely won't be as successful.
Martin tipped his helmet after flying out to center in the ninth, his final at-bat before a regularly scheduled cash windfall.
His two seasons here were the best in a long, long time, even if the final act was part of a brutally short postseason.
Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.