CINCINNATI — At their absolute aggravating best on the final day of their pointless season, the Cincinnati Reds bounced the Pirates from the divisional title chase for the greater glory of Pittsburgh arch nemesis Johnny Cueto.

Yes, the Pirates flipped the page on it rather dismissively, anxious for a couple off days and the ramp up to the wild-card playoff game Wednesday night against the San Francisco Giants at PNC Park, but only hours before a 4-1 loss Sunday, they were pep-talking themselves into catching the Cardinals, heading to St. Louis to win the division, reshuffling the postseason deck in their favor and perhaps spending most of October realigning the planets.

“We’ll shower it off,” said Gerrit Cole, who punched out a career-high 12 batters with the 101 pitches he was allowed to throw before Clint Hurdle pinch-hit for him at the start of the eighth inning.

“Yeah,” Cole sighed when asked if he had hoped to stay in the game, “but leading off right there, I guess we’d probably better take our chances with somebody who professionally swings the bat.”

Advertise with us

Funny he should mention that, because it brings the discussion back to Cueto, who was for some reason standing in the batter’s box with one out and the go-ahead run at third base a half-inning later.

A dugout filled with pinch-hitters including Ryan Ludwick and Ramon Grand Slammin’ Santiago, and Reds manager Bryan Price sent Cueto to the plate with one out against Tony Watson and his 1.40 eighth-inning specialist’s ERA.

“I know what’s on the line,” Price said in the first few minutes of Cincinnati’s offseason, “the Cardinals are watching the game going, ‘What’s this idiot doing?’ Because we knew [Aroldis] Chapman was going to pitch the ninth with the lead, the situation was like, ‘Hey, you know what? The most important guy for me today is Johnny Cueto, getting a chance at 20 [wins].’ And we could have had a pinch-hitter go up there and hit an absolute missile at any infielder and have [the next guy] do the same thing and not score that run and forfeit the opportunity for Johnny to survive and pitch the ninth and maybe still win 20.

“So that made the decision for me, pretty much.”

Well, that changes everything.

Advertise with us

Had they heard all that, I’ll bet the Cardinals were saying, “What’s this idiot doing?”

Had Price sent up a professional hitter, to use Cole’s term, and that hitter drove in the go-ahead run, Cueto would have gotten his 20th win anyway. The fact that Price didn’t want to remove him from a tied game puts the player ahead of the competition, but what else is new?

Hurdle yanked the nearly untouchable Cole after seven innings in a game that might have forced a tie for the division title. Milwaukee manager Ron Roenicke pulled Yovani Gallardo from the most important start of his season at PNC Park 10 days ago, giving Gallardo a perfect dugout view of Russell Martin’s three-run, eighth-inning home run. The Washington Nationals pulled Stephen Strasburg from the season a couple of summers ago, effectively filching a pennant from a city that hadn’t seen one in 87 years.

Oddly enough, the Nationals got a no-hitter Sunday from Jordan Zimmermann, which generally connotes a complete game, so apparently they are still legal.

Anywhoo, it’s no surprise that Cueto beat the Pirates Sunday; he is 5-0 against them this season and 18-4 lifetime, but this time he beat them with a bat.

Advertise with us

I mean he literally beat them with his bat.

Not all of them, just catcher Chris Stewart.

As Cueto reached out and swatted a 3-2 pitch from Watson through the drawn-in infield for a 2-1 lead, he let the bat loose on his follow through and it nailed Stewart on the left wrist.

“I didn’t get to see where he hit it,” said Stewart, who crumpled to the dirt and had to leave the game. “I was a little bit surprised to see him hit there. His pitch count was up. I don’t really know why he was in there, but obviously it worked out well.”

Kristopher Negron hit the next pitch, this one from Justin Wilson, into the seats in left, his second of the year against the Pirates and his eighth hit of the three-game series. The Pirates don’t have to wonder why his name is pronounced Ne-Groan.

Advertise with us

But here’s the line on Cueto — he got his 20th win, the first Reds pitcher to do that since Danny Jackson in 1988; he pitched eight innings, walked no one and struck out seven; he drilled Andrew McCutchen square in the back with first base open in the eighth, he came close to breaking Stewart’s wrist (X-rays were negative, in fact, X-rays are negatives), and he drove in the winning run.

I’ll bet you feel great for him.

Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com.