Exactly 100 years ago this week, Cy Young pitched what is generally considered baseball's first perfect game, and it's just too bad nobody thought to ask Joe Paterno what he remembers about it when the carbon-dated Penn State football coach turned up at the Duquesne Club this week.
I guess technically, Joe's not that old. But then technically, at least two perfect games had been pitched years before Young went to the hill May 5, 1904, for the Boston Pilgrims and dismissed 27 consecutive hitters, the 27th being none other than Prospect, Pa.'s George "Rube" Waddell, then of the Philadelphia Athletics. It is written that Young was so pumped at being perfect that he screeched at Rube, "How d'ya like that, hayseed?"
Yeah, they didn't call him Rube for nothin'.
Anyway, Cy Young had the good sense to set down all 27 men he faced after the year 1900, which for some reason commences the "modern era" of baseball, before which all feats, accomplishments, statistics and even people are considered dubious by varying degrees, even though 267 of Young's unfathomable 511 career wins were of 19th century vintage. That Lee Richmond and John Ward each pitched a perfecto in 1880 apparently did nothing to dissuade historians from the notion that Young invented the thing, which is why the number of perfect games in "history" is alternatively given as 14 and 16.
(And, no, that doesn't include the Pirates' Harvey Haddix, who pitched 12 perfect innings May 26, 1959, at Milwaukee. Historians equate perfection with winning, and, since the Braves won in 13, The Kitten's singular achievement was unavoidably imperfect.)
What got me thinking about all this were two events in the early Pirates season, one being the plate appearance Wednesday night by backup catcher Humberto Cota against Roger Clemens, the second being Josh Fogg's April 21 outing against the Chicago Cubs.
In the first, Cota did not merely become strikeout victim 4,140 in Clemens' still somehow increasingly magnificent career, but showed in baseball terms the competitive imbalance at work when a moth flies smack into the grill of a Mack truck. Watching that matchup, I wondered if there really was any utility in having Cota carry a bat to the plate. It was just another thing he could hurt himself with.
If Clemens could pitch exclusively to Cota, he could pitch three, maybe four perfect games in a row.
Though it is not nearly so rare as a perfect game, Fogg's performance against the Cubs constituted the rare if ignominious perfectly imperfect game. He got nobody out. But as the thin history of perfect games and the Harvey Haddix nightmare have shown, sometimes you can get everybody out and still be lucky to win.
Los Angeles' Sandy Koufax, alternately baffling and blowing away various Cubbies Sept. 9, 1965, got his fourth no-hitter and first perfect game only because the Dodgers cobbled together a run in the fifth off Bob Hendley, who was throwing a no-hitter of his own. Lou Johnson walked in that fifth, moved up on a sacrifice, stole third and scored on a throwing error by Chris Krug. Johnson got the game's only hit two innings later. One hit and one batter left on by both teams in a completed nine-inning game is a record.
If a no-hitter can be purely a freak show, as much natural happenstance as skill, a perfect game can be not much more than the ultimate freak show. On Oct. 2, 1908, in baseball's "second" perfect game, Cleveland's Addie Joss beat the Chicago White Sox only because the Indians scored on a passed ball by Ossee Schreckengost. Otherwise, Indians hitters had been struck out 15 times by Joss' mound opponent, Ed Walsh.
History's most familiar perfect game, Don Lar-sen's 2-0 suffocation of the Brooklyn Dodgers for the New York Yankees in the 1956 World Series, almost didn't happen due to a violation of no-hitter protocol by Larsen himself. According to the late Mickey Mantle, who like many of Larsen's teammates called him "Gooney," Larsen would not stop talking about the possibility of a perfect game in the dugout.
"You think I'm gonna do this, Mick?" Larsen asked Mantle.
"Geez Gooney, I don't know," Mantle yipped. "Go over there and sit down and be quiet!"
I'm positive Paterno remembers that one. He'd only been at Penn State six years.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.