Chris Dell is the founder of BettingPredators.com and the lead fantasy football and sports betting analyst on ESPN 97.5’s “Late Hits.” He’s also our new sports editor at the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. In his new weekly “Post-Gazette Fantasy Football Favorites” column, Chris will break down his top fantasy players and strategies to win your leagues, in addition to some prop bets along the way. Please note: This article should be considered opinion, not gambling advice.
Welcome to the Week 16 edition of our Post-Gazette ‘Fantasy Favorites Manifesto’ series. The players I write about below will be mainly those I’m significantly higher or lower on vs. the expert consensus rankings (ECR), which includes 200+ analysts across the fantasy football industry.
The semifinals are officially here, just in time for Christmas weekend.
And come New Year’s Day 2024, your fantasy football championships will have already been decided.
We’ve talked a lot about strategy over these past few months in this column, and just like the beautiful tradition of the 12 Days of Christmas, all of these principles still apply to Week 16 for your squads:
- Continue to grind your waiver wire: If Kenneth Walker or Josh Jacobs are somehow ruled out, Zamir White and Zach Charbonnet would be top-20 options in all scoring formats.
- Handcuff your heroes: Relying on McCaffrey and Swift to get you across the finish line? Make sure you’re rostering Kenneth Gainwell and Elijah Mitchell … and maybe even Jordan Mason.
- Start your studs: Yes, Brock Purdy and Lamar Jackson might have tough matchups on paper, but they’re ranked in the consensus top five for a reason. You’re not benching them in Week 16.
- Know your situation: Is your fantasy app projecting you as a massive underdog this weekend? You might be better off swinging for the fences on high-upside plays in high-totaled games like DET/MIN, IND/ATL, DAL/MIA and BAL/SF. The more points scored, the better chance your FLEX has to take part in that potential fantasy shootout, regardless of the “matchup on paper.”
- Know your opponent: Does your Week 16 or potential Week 17 opponent also have injury issues at RB/WR? Drop the bottom two players on your bench and “block” your foe by picking up the top options available they might need come game day. All’s fair in love and war, after all.
- Know the matchups, too: No, we’re not contradicting our high-total strategy above. But in coin-flip situations between FLEX/WR3 options, for example, go for wide receivers facing the Eagles, Lions and Titans, all secondaries graded in the bottom five of the league currently by PFF.
- Don’t be afraid to pull a “sabotage drop”: Terry McLaurin is still easily owned in more than 50% of ESPN/Yahoo leagues, but he’ll be lined up against Sauce Gardner-Johnson early and often this weekend, and if dropped to waivers, there’s a chance one of your desperate, WR-needy opponents could take a swing. There are similar scenarios at QB/RB/TE here too.
- Don’t be afraid to look ahead to Week 17, either: If you’ve made it this far, there’s a 50% chance you’re advancing to the fantasy finals, plain and simple. If that means stashing a low-owned, high-upside D/ST for Week 17 ahead of time, say Seahawks vs. Steelers at home, do it now. Those defenses might be highly prioritized by your opponent come Tuesday waivers.
- Trust the volume (and the process): Disappointed by D’Andre Swift and Jerome Ford over these past four weeks? The fact remains that these backs are still comfortably lead roles in their backfields, and the usage is there to bounce back in your favor. The matchups are there as well.
- Ignore the final box score: Wait, what? Ignore touchdowns and chase targets/touches. If you do this, long-term, sustained fantasy success awaits you. Just because Noah Brown and Curtis Samuel scored 20+ PPR points last week doesn’t mean their auto-starts in Week 16 against formidable defenses in the Browns and Jets, respectively. Keep your expectations in check, folks.
- Stash rookies with elite athleticism and high upside: This won’t be the first year we see a rookie fantasy RB or WR breakout in the final 2-3 weeks of the fantasy football playoffs. Lions’ wideout Jameson Williams is coming off a career-high seven targets, and while he hasn’t done much in the box score yet, stay patient. If the usage catches up with the talent, you could be truly looking at a top-20 or top-10 fantasy wide receiver come the fantasy football championships.
- Relax, take a deep breath, and have fun: Tilting is no fun. If you find yourself not enjoying watching every single play with so much on the line in your leagues, then simply … don’t. There’s nothing wrong with spending time with loved ones and focusing on your mental health while luck plays a role in seemingly 50% or more of your fantasy outcomes. You will often make the playoffs based on skill, but sometimes dumb luck happens to the worst of us, too. Just because you lose or are losing doesn’t mean you should let it affect you in more of a negative way than it should.
And with that said, may you all have a very safe and Merry Christmas, and hopefully snatch some W’s from the jaws of defeat in the process.
See you in the fantasy finals, folks.
Please note: you can view my full Week 16 fantasy football rankings and top 150 players, sortable by position and by scoring format, by scrolling to the bottom of this article
PLAYERS I LOVE (START ‘EM)
QB. Baker Mayfield, Buccaneers
(Dell’s rank QB7)
It turns out the number-one pick from the 2018 NFL Draft isn’t a bust after all, right? Maybe I’m confusing fantasy with reality here. Nonetheless, Mayfield’s ascension to borderline elite fantasy QB must be recognized here. “Baker” finished as the QB2 overall in Week 15 on the heels of 381 passing yards and four scores, against a run-funneling Packers defense, no less. The matchup gets even better in Week 16 against an actual pass-funneling Jaguars secondary, which gives up gobs of production through the air to even the most mediocre of signal-callers. I would’ve never believed it if you told me this before the 2023 season began, but Mayfield is as close to a top-five overall option as you can get in the fantasy semis.
Honorable mention: Brock Purdy QB5, Jared Goff QB6, Dak Prescott QB8, Patrick Mahomes QB9, Tua Tagovailoa QB10, Nick Mullens QB12, Geno Smith QB13, Joe Flacco QB14, Gardner Minshew QB17
RB. Ty Chandler, Vikings
(Dell’s rank RB5)
Alexander who? Chandler’s emergence in Week 15 should be absolutely nothing to scoff at. Chandler racked up a massive 158 yards on 26 touches and a touchdown against the Bengals last weekend, and now Vikings coaches are singing his praises as the franchise’s next “feature back” in line. Even if Mattison returns from the injury that sidelined him last week, I expect Chandler will continue being this team’s workhorse for the foreseeable future. His 90th percentile 40-yard dash time and 92nd percentile burst score as a 2022 prospect give this team something they’ve severely lacked all season: “the juice.”
Honorable mention: Raheem Mostert RB6, Josh Jacobs RB11, De’Von Achane RB14, D’Andre Swift RB16, Joe Mixon RB17, Derrick Henry RB18, Jerome Ford RB19, Aaron Jones RB20, Chuba Hubbard RB23
WR. Michael Pittman, Colts
(Dell’s rank WR8)
Pittman has cleared concussion protocol after suffering a nasty hit in Week 15, and he should be 110% trusted in Week 16 in a matchup with this pass-funneling Falcons secondary. Pittman amassed 78 receiving yards in nearly one half of action last weekend before leaving early. Before that contest, he had racked up a ridiculously elite 52 targets over his previous four starts, good for the fourth-most in the league during that span. Atlanta might have a solid DB in A.J. Terrell, sure, but Pittman runs nearly one-third of his routes out of the slot and should feast on a pass defense ranked a lowly 23rd out of 32 teams by PFF.
Honorable mention: Mike Evans WR6, DJ Moore WR9, Jaylen Waddle WR10, Deebo Samuel WR11, Tee Higgins WR12, Rashee Rice WR14, DK Metcalf WR15, Stefon Diggs WR16, DeVonta Smith WR17, Amari Cooper WR18, Brandon Aiyuk WR19, Jordan Addison WR22, Calvin Ridley WR23, Chris Godwin WR25, Joshua Palmer WR26, Drake London WR27, Jaxon Smith-Njigba WR28, DeAndre Hopkins WR29, Tyler Lockett WR30
TE. David Njoku, Browns
(Dell’s rank TE9)
Guess who has two thumbs, lives in Cleveland and has led all NFL tight ends in targets by a very, very large margin since Week 7? It’s wild to think that Njoku has somehow morphed into one of the most consistent players in the league at his position over the past two months, but the numbers don’t lie here. Njoku’s 84 targets rank first overall since Week 7, and the next closest isn't even … well, close. T.J. Hockenson has 76, and Trey McBride has 70—the next closest (Evan Engram) clocks in at a commendable 65. Njoku is no athletic slouch, either, once boasting 96th percentile burst score, 94th percentile catch radius and 98th percentile arm length (35 inches) during the 2017 NFL Draft process.
Honorable mention: Isaiah Likely TE6, Dallas Goedert TE7, Jake Ferguson TE8, Cole Kmet TE10, Darren Waller TE11, Evan Engram TE12, Tucker Kraft TE13, Cade Otton TE17, Tyler Conklin TE18
PLAYERS I HATE (SIT ‘EM)
QB. Sam Howell, Commanders
(Dell’s rank QB29)
It didn’t work out for us last week in our weekly fade of fantasy QBs facing the New York Jets, as Tua Tagovailoa tore Gangreen a new one. Sam Howell, however, isn’t Tua by even the shortest of Miami miles, and he’s in for a tough spot against a Jets team with simply nothing to lose at this point in the season. You might’ve lost Trevor Lawrence or C.J. Stroud and need a spot start, and the fantasy apps you’re using might tell you Howell is a top-10 option, but buyer beware: don’t buy that noise come this Sunday. Howell could indeed be benched for the second straight week in real life by Washington, and he should certainly be benched in fantasy life in Week 16 as well, or dropped to waivers accordingly.
Dishonorable mention: Kyler Murray QB15, Jordan Love QB18, Russell Wilson QB21, Taylor Heinicke QB24
RB. Saquon Barkley, Giants
(Dell’s rank RB28)
Barkley played barely 50% of the Giants’ snaps last weekend, and at this point of the year, what incentive or excuse does this team have for trotting out its franchise star in seemingly meaningless games? The matchup doesn’t get much tougher than Barkley faces in Week 16 either, with the Eagles ranking 5th overall in PFF run defense and the Giants arriving as massive +13.5 underdogs in Philadelphia.
Dishonorable mention: James Conner RB21, Austin Ekeler RB24, Travis Etienne RB26, Breece Hall RB27, Bijan Robinson RB28, Devin Singletary RB30, Javonte Williams RB31, Gus Edwards RB39, Antonio Gibson RB41
WR. Terry McLaurin, Commanders
(Dell’s rank WR46)
Just as we continue to fade our fantasy QBs against the Jets, we do the same for our boundary/outside wide receivers who will see at least half of their snaps lined up against the vaunted Sauce Gardner-Johnson. McLaurin has talent for days, don’t get me wrong, but I’m here to tell you that you need to 125% ignore last week’s box score that shows 12 targets for 141 yards. Most of that production came after Howell was benched in favor of Jacoby Brissett, and before Week 15, McLaurin was 120% sinking your lineups with miserable finishes of WR119, WR46, WR42 and WR50, respectively.
Dishonorable mention: Nico Collins WR32,Courtland Sutton WR33, Noah Brown WR34, Adam Thielen WR37
TE. Dalton Schultz, Texans
(Dell’s rank TE28)
The Cleveland Browns continue to be a defense we fade our fantasy tight ends against, and Dalton Schultz is no exception in Week 16. Even before his most recent injury, Schultz had mustered just five targets in two games combined from Weeks 11-12, and now he has Case Keenum under center throwing the ball. Schultz might be worth a start with Stroud back in Week 17 against the Titans, so if you can stash him on your bench, that investment could pay off. In the fantasy semifinals, however, he’s a hard pass.
Dishonorable mention: Dalton Kincaid TE14, Chig Okonkwo TE19, Logan Thomas TE23, Michael Mayer TE21
SLEEPER WR OF THE WEEK
(must be ranked outside the consensus top 100)
WR. Jameson Williams, Lions
(Dell’s rank WR43)
Honorable mention: Dontayvion Wicks WR36, Parker Washington WR50, Darius Slayton WR55, Wan’Dale Robinson WR57, Michael Wilson WR62, Jalin Hyatt WR63, Alec Pierce WR66, Xavier Gipson WR73, Tre Tucker WR75
SHALLOW-LEAGUE STASH OF THE WEEK
(must be owned between 25-50% of leagues)
RB. Tyjae Spears, Titans (41.1%)
Honorable mention: Kareem Hunt 43.6%, Josh Downs 43.5%, Noah Brown 42.3%, Tyler Allgeier 37.2%, D’Onta Foreman 34.4%, Clyde Edwards-Helaire 29.2%, Demario Douglas 28.9%, Gerald Everett 25.9%, Joshua Palmer 25.3%
DEEP-LEAGUE STASH OF THE WEEK
(must be owned in less than 25% of leagues)
RB. Chase Brown, Bengals
Honorable mention: Elijah Mitchell 14.1%, Jameson Williams 12.1%, Zamir White 9.7%, Rico Dowdle 8.2%, Tucker Kraft 6.5%, Michael Mayer 5.3%, Dontayvion Wicks 4.1%, Michael Wilson 3.9%, Jalin Hyatt 3.4%, D’Ernest Johnson 2.9%, Jordan Mason 1.2%, Noah Gray 0.9%, Cedric Tillman 0.4%, Josh Oliver 0.1%
WEEK 16 D/ST STREAMERS
(must be 50% owned or less)
Week 16 streamer ranks:
- Packers at Panthers
- Broncos vs. Patriots
- Bears vs. Cardinals
- Colts at Falcons
- Steelers at Titans
- Bengals at Steelers
- Bucs vs. Jaguars
- Commanders vs. Jets
- Patriots at Broncos
- Lions at Vikings
WEEK 17 D/ST STASHES
(must be 50% owned or less)
- Jaguars vs. Panthers
- Broncos vs. Chargers
- Seahawks vs. Steelers
- Rams at Giants
- Colts vs. Raiders
- Bucs vs. Saints
- Packers at Vikings
- Texans vs. Titans
- Vikings vs. Packers
- Raiders/Chargers/Titans
WEEK 16 QB STREAMERS
(must be 50% owned or less)
Week 16 streamer ranks:
- Nick Mullens vs. DET
- Joe Flacco vs. HOU
- Gardner Minshew at ATL
- Jake Browning at PIT
- Tommy DeVito at PHI
- Aidan O’Connell at KC
- Taylor Heinicke vs. IND
- Easton Stick vs. BUF
- Ryan Tannehill vs. SEA
- C.J. Beathard/Mason Rudolph/Trevor Siemian
WEEK 17 QB STASHES
(must be 50% owned or less)
- Jake Browning at KC
- Nick Mullens vs. GB
- Gardner Minshew vs. LV
- Derek Carr at TB
- Aidan O’Connell at IND
- Tommy DeVito vs. LAR
- Taylor Heinicke at CHI
- Easton Stick at DEN
- Bryce Young at JAX
- Kenny Pickett at SEA
WEEK 16 TE STREAMERS
(must be 50% owned or less)
Week 16 streamer ranks:
- Gerald Everett vs. BUF
- Tucker Kraft vs. CAR
- Cade Otton vs JAX
- Tyler Conklin vs. WAS
- Michael Mayer at KC
- Chig Okonkwo vs. SEA
- Logan Thomas at NYJ
- Tanner Hudson vs. PIT
- Jonnu Smith vs. IND
- Noah Fant/Mike Gesicki
WEEK 17 TE STASHES
(must be 50% owned or less)
- Tucker Kraft at MIN
- Gerald Everett at DEN
- Hunter Henry at BUF
- Michael Mayer at IND
- Tanner Hudson at KC
- Logan Thomas vs. SF
- Cade Otton vs. NO
- Tyler Higbee at NYG
- Chig Okonkwo/Jonnu Smith
- Juwan Johnson/Noah Fant
WEEK 16 KICKER STREAMERS
(must be 50% owned or less)
Week 16 streamer ranks:
- Cairo Santos vs. ARI
- Dustin Hopkins at HOU
- Chase McLaughlin vs. JAX
- Michael Badgley at MIN
- Jason Sanders vs. DAL
- Anders Carlson at CAR
- Greg Joseph vs. DET
- Matt Prater at CHI
- Younghoe Koo vs. IND
- Brandon McManus at TB
2023 Fantasy Football Rankings powered by FantasyProsECR ™ - Expert Consensus Rankings
This column is dedicated to the late, great, legendary Robert William Barker ...
Chris Dell: cdell@post-gazette.com and Twitter @MaddJournalist





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.