Chris Dell is the founder of BettingPredators.com, as well as the lead fantasy football and sports betting analyst on ESPN 97.5’s “Late Hits.” He’s also our new sports editor at the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. In his new weekly “Post-Gazette Fantasy Football Favorites” column, Chris will break down his top fantasy players and strategies to win your leagues, in addition to some prop bets along the way. Please note: This article should be considered opinion, not gambling advice.
Welcome to the Week 9 edition of our “Post-Gazette Fantasy Fallout” series, which focuses on waiver wire targets, roster management and trade strategies to help win your leagues. Every week, we’ll take a deep dive into the waiver wire waters — and the often-murky trade market streets — to help you identify top players to add, drop, and consider for buying low and selling high.
Please note: League sizes, scoring formats, and waiver wire options vary wildly, so if you don’t see a player listed below that you’re considering adding or dropping (or including in a trade), feel free to send me an email (cdell@post-gazette.com) or send a comment or message on X/Twitter (@MaddJournalist). I’ve also included my complete list of FantasyPros waiver wire rankings at the bottom of this article, which includes players who cross our 25% ownership threshold.
DEEPER LEAGUE ADDS
(must be owned in 25% or less of ESPN leagues)
QB. Will Levis, Titans (1.1%)
What a debut from the rookie. Will Levis was the overall QB6 in Week 8 with 26.6 fantasy points, which included an impressive 238 passing yards, 4 TDs and 0 turnovers. He also ran 7 times for 11 yards, showing off an overlooked part of his game that he flashed in last year’s combine with an 88th percentile burst score, according to PlayerProfiler.
The Titans were treading water at QB with an aging, talent-declining Tannehill under center and would be foolish not to ride out the rest of 2023 to see what Levis has. Two more key factors to consider here in prioritizing Levis on waivers this week: Tennessee already had its bye, and the team has one of the most QB-friendly schedules remaining this season with pass-funnel matchups upcoming in Weeks 10-11 against Tampa Bay and Jacksonville. Levis, if given the chance to keep this job, wouldn’t face a top-10 secondary for the rest of the year, with the toughest test being a Week 16 matchup at home against Seattle. The QB position in fantasy this year has become dire at best, and those without one of the “Top 5” in Hurts, Jackson, Allen, Mahomes — and now a healthy Burrow — Levis could provide instant upside and a much-needed spark for the fantasy stretch.
Recommended FAAB bid: up to 25%
TE. Trey McBride, Cardinals (7.9%)
It wasn’t technically a debut, but man, Trey McBride stole the TE show in Week 8 in his first full game with teammate Zach Ertz on injured reserve. McBride led all tight ends last week in targets (14), was tied for first in receptions (10) and second in receiving yards (95) only to George Kittle en route to a TE2 finish only behind Taysom Hill (see more on him right here below, as he yet again makes our list). I mentioned last week that “McBride could flirt with being a weekly T10 option” because of his impressive combo of size (6-4, 245 pounds) and athleticism (89th percentile 40-yard dash). We actually saw an even higher ceiling against a stingy Baltimore defense on Sunday. With Kyler Murray’s return likely coming in Week 10, McBride could truly compete for top-five TE status as long as Ertz remains out.
Recommended FAAB bid: up to 25%
WR. Rashid Shaheed, Saints (18.4%)
Before we get to Taysom once again, let’s talk one more time about his teammate Rashid Shaheed. Yes, contrary to what his No. 22 jersey might indicate, Shaheed is not actually running back.
He’s a full-time wide receiver in a Saints offense that is desperate for explosive playmakers, and he’s done just that this season when seeing targets from Derek Carr. Shaheed was the WR4 overall in half-PPR scoring formats in Week 8 after racking up a ridiculous 153 receiving yards on just 3 catches/3 targets. It’s the second time in only three weeks that Shaheed has now posted a WR6 performance or better, and he’s now recorded a catch of at least 40 yards in 4 of 8 games this season. He’s not going to hit every single week, but in the weeks he does, he’s going to single-handedly help win you your fantasy matchup, and that’s simply not something we can say about hardly any of the WR waiver options in Week 9.
Recommended FAAB bid: up to 15%
WR. Demario Douglas, Patriots (0.2%)
Demario “Pop” Douglas finally breaks onto our top-five list of waiver adds who are also owned in 25% or less of ESPN leagues. The talented rookie has made big plays for the New England Patriots this season but hasn’t yet hit the fantasy radar because of dealing with various injuries and playing behind teammate and fellow wideout Kendrick Bourne in the team’s receiver rotation. Bourne suffered a season-ending knee injury, unfortunately, in Week 8, which leaves Douglas as the last halfway-decent wide receiver standing in Bill Belichick’s locker room. The rookie should see an increased, steady role, however, as evidenced by 13 targets over his past two games and a team-leading five catches this past Sunday vs. MIA.
Athletically, Douglas sported an impressive 96th percentile burst score and 81st percentile 40-yard dash at the 2023 combine and also registered an elite-level 91st percentile college target share, albeit at a small school program in Liberty. At this point of the fantasy calendar year, however, we’re betting on two things: upside and “the unknown,” both of which Douglas possesses. Yes, he could certainly return to fantasy irrelevancy in a few weeks. But he could also become NE’s defacto WR1 and earn 10+ targets every weekend. Because the upside case is there, it’s something we must prioritize on waivers over veteran WRs who possess lower floors and have shown us multiple years now of little-to-no week-winning upside.
Recommended FAAB bid: up to 10%
WR. Khalil Shakir, Bills (0.2%)
Another young wideout whose bull case is relatively unknown at this point. What we do know about Khalil Shakir, however, is that he’s a talented prospect who’s never really had a chance to shine in this potent Buffalo Bills offense. Shakir flashed in Week 8 with 6 catches for 92 yards en route to a WR24 overall fantasy performance. It was a career-high in catches, yards and targets (6) for Shakir, who directly benefitted from the Bills running more “11 personnel” three-receiver sets without tight end Dawson Knox in the lineup.
Shakir, a fifth-round pick out of Boise State in 2022, had an 85th percentile 40-yard dash and 81st percentile burst score in his draft class, as well as a very impressive 95th percentile college football target share of 32.2%. He manned the slot receiver role for Buffalo this past Sunday, and with his teams sporting the league’s fifth-highest pass rate over expectation (PROE), there could be many more opportunities in the near future for Shakir to benefit from his system/quarterback.
Recommended FAAB bid: up to 10%
TE. Taysom Hill, Saints (14.8%)
This marks at least the third time I’ve written up Taysom Hill on our Post-Gazette weekly fantasy fallout/waiver wire column, and as long his ownership remains below 25%, that trend will continue. Another trend that continued in Week 8 was Taysom’s run of now five straight games with at least five rushing attempts. He turned that into 9 carries for 63 and TWO touchdowns against the Colts on Sunday, as well as adding 44 passing yards on two attempts. Taysom is a legit threat to score TDs in three different ways every single week, and while he’s no lock to find the end zone every Sunday (newsflash: no player is), his upside alone — one that made him the TE1 overall in Week 8 despite just one target — is worth a weekly start in most fantasy leagues given the poor state/lack of reliable TE play around the NFL.
Recommended FAAB bid: up to 15%
THE BEST OF THE REST
QB. Gardner Minshew, IND (3.6%)
The Colts continue to run their offense at one of the fastest paces in the league with Shane Steichen calling the shots. Minshew might not run like Richardson, but his floor should be solid enough to get you through bye weeks and get you through the recent run of injuries to Cousins, others.
Recommended FAAB bid: up to 15%
WR. Michael Wilson, ARI (24.1%)
Kyler Murray’s return to the Arizona offense will serve as a boon for not only the aforementioned McBride and Marquise Brown but also for Wilson, a talented rookie WR who excels in making plays down the field and in the red zone with his size, speed and physicality. He’s at the very least worth a bench stash to see what surmises for ARI.
Recommended FAAB bid: up to 10%
WR. Jamison Crowder, WAS (18.4%)
If Curtis Samuel remains out, then Crowder can serve as a reliable PPR flex play in a Washington offense that ranks second overall (only behind KC) in PROE. His 7-7-95 stat line in Week 8 is nothing to scoff at, and all WAS pass-catchers will remain fantasy-relevant if the team keeps up this rate.
Recommended FAAB bid: up to 10%
RB. Royce Freeman, LAR (1.2%)
Kyren Williams could return in Week 12, but until then, this backfield should continue to operate as a 1-2 punch. Freeman has run the ball more efficiently in this RB committee and now has 21 carries for 110 yards with a TD in his last 2 games.
Recommended FAAB bid: up to 10%
WR. Jayden Reed, GB (17.1%)
Reed led the team by a wide margin in Week 8 with 83 receiving yards, more than double that of his next-closest teammate, and his “big slot” role could lead to easier targets in the short-to-intermediate areas of the field for Jordan Love. Reed’s explosiveness with the ball in his hands makes him a big-play threat each week as well.
Recommended FAAB bid: up to 10%
RB. Leonard Fournette, BUF (3.2%)
Fournette’s signing with the Bills likely means nothing for your fantasy teams. BUT — and that’s a big ‘but’ — he’s still a running back with a potential “role” for one of the top five offenses in the league. If something happens to James Cook down the road, someone will get the touches in this backfield. Maybe it’s Fournette. That alone is worth a dart-throw 5% FAAB bid for Week 9.
Recommended FAAB bid: up to 5%
Honorable mention:
- Derek Carr 21.3% *Not a good QB, but weapons around him are good
- Kenneth Gainwell 21.2% *One ‘Swift’ injury away from 20+ touches per week
- Joshua Kelley 20.2% *Splitting early down work in above-average offense
- Chig Okonkwo 17.3% *Athleticism is there; could see resurgence with Levis
- Joshua Dobbs 16.8% *Upside remains after being traded to MIN this afternoon
- Robert Woods 15.9% *Texans will need to pass more often than not; has Stroud’s trust
- Bryce Young 10.1% *Young has only scratched the surface of his potential
- Julio Jones 8.0% *Could see significant role if Smith or Brown were to miss time
- Jonathan Mingo 7.9% *Just a stash for now, but has explosiveness to matter later
- Marvin Mims Jr. 7.0% *Stash only, but future is bleak with no Sutton/Jeudy trades
- Desmond Ridder 6.9% *Coach says he’s still starter; week to week can be streamed
- Pierre Strong Jr. 4.1% *Looked good with 80+ yards in Week 8, but needs an injury to Hunt/Ford to truly matter
- Jalin Hyatt 3.1% *Daniel Jones’ return could provide spark for rookie breakout
- Rico Dowdle 2.8% *Dowdle is an elite handcuff whether you own Pollard or not
- Irv Smith Jr. 2.7% *Burrow is healthy, which means Smith has life for stretch run
- Cade Otton 2.3% *Young, talented player playing in pass-happy Tampa Bay offense
- Noah Fant 2.1% *Fant only runs about 50% of the routes, but he makes splash plays
- Alec Pierce 1.8% *Slowly developing as a steady deep threat for uptempo Colts
- Donald Parham Jr. 1.7% *Not much value when Everett returns to Chargers
- Jelani Woods 1.2% *Add him before he returns from I.R.; most talented TE in Indy
- Noah Gray 1.0% *If there were ever such a thing as a TE handcuff, it’s Gray for Kelce
- Jake Bobo 0.9% *Underrated rookie already seeing prominent role for SEA
- Zamir White 0.8% *Elite stash who could see 20+ touches per game if Jacobs gets hurt
- P.J. Walker 0.5% *Watson’s future remains cloudy; Walker has weapons
- Raheem Blackshear 0.5% *Seems to have usurped Miles Sanders for CAR
- Aidan O’Connell 0.2% *At some point, LV has to abandon the Jimmy G experiment
- Taylor Heinicke 0.1% *Much better passer than Ridder if he were to get a shot
- Nick Mullens/Jaren Hall 0.0% *MIN traded for Josh Dobbs, but Mullens and Hall can still be stashed in superflex leagues
SHALLOW/SMALLER LEAGUES
(players owned between 25%-50%)
- Chuba Hubbard, RB (42.8%)
- Emari Demercado, RB (39.2%)
- Daniel Jones, QB (33.9%)
- Jake Ferguson, TE (49.6%)
- Zach Charbonnet, RB (30.1%)
- Sam Howell, QB (30.4%)
- Roschon Johhnson, RB (46.4%)
- Kyler Murray, QB (33.1%)
- Quentin Johnston, WR (31.3%)
- Logan Thomas, TE (38.7%)
- Jameson Williams, WR (28.1%)
- Tyjae Spears, RB (36.0%)
- Brandin Cooks, WR (49.8%)
- Devin Singletary, RB (33.9%)
- Tyler Boyd, WR (46.4%)
- Justice Hill, RB (28.1%)
- Treylon Burks, WR (34.6%)
- Jeff Wilson Jr., RB (43.0%
- Curtis Samuel, WR (45.0%)
- Jaleel McLaughlin, RB (36.0%)
- Michael Gallup, WR (36.0%)
- Gerald Everett, TE (26.7%)
- Zay Jones, WR (25.9%)
- Elijah Mitchell, RB (25.1%)
- Romeo Doubs, WR (48.2%)
Honorable mention:
- Elijah Moore, WR (44.6%)
INJURED RESERVE: IR STASHES
(must be listed “O” or IR” and owned 50% or less)
- Kyler Murray, QB (31.8%)
- Zay Jones, WR (25.9%)
- Jelani Woods, TE (1.2%)
- Pat Freiermuth, TE (43.5%)
- Greg Dulcich, TE (6.2%)
Honorable Mention:
- Justin Shorter, WR (0.1%)
TOP CUTS: PLAYERS TO DROP
(must be owned in 50% or more of leagues)
- Kirk Cousins, QB (88.9%)
- Deshaun Watson, QB (64.6%)
- Cam Akers, RB (55.6%)
- Dolphins, D/ST (71.7%)
- Miles Sanders, RB (84.0%)
Honorable Mention:
- Eagles, D/ST (92.9%)
WEEK 9 D/ST STREAMERS
(must be 50% owned or less)
- Chargers at Jets
- Packers vs. Rams
- Falcons vs. Vikings
- Rams at Packers
- Giants at Raiders
- Raiders vs. Giants
- Vikings at Falcons
- Titans at Steelers
- Commanders at Patriots
- Patriots vs. Commanders
Honorable mention:
- Colts at Panthers
WEEK 10 D/ST STASHES
(must be 50% owned or less)
- Panthers at Bears
- Raiders vs. Jets
- Falcons at Cardinals
- Packers at Steelers
- Titans at Bucs
- Patriots vs. Colts
- Colts at Patriots
- Bengals vs. Texans
- Vikings vs. Saints
- Bears vs. Panthers
Honorable mention:
- Bucs vs. Titans
WEEK 9 KICKER STREAMERS
(must be owned in 50% or less of ESPN leagues)
- Brandon Aubrey, DAL at PHI (42.9%)
- Dustin Hopkins, CLE vs. ARI (32.1%)
- Cameron Dicker, LAC at NYJ (36.6%)
- Kai’imi Fairbairn, HOU vs. TB (36.4%)
- Blake Grupe, N.O. vs. CHI (5.1%)
Honorable mention:
- Eddy Pineiro, CAR vs. IND (11.0%)
TOP BUYS (TRADE FOR)
To qualify for this “buy-low” list:
- WRs must be ranked outside the top 20
- RBs must be ranked outside the top 15
- QBs/TEs must be ranked outside the top 10
QB/TE “BUY” TRADE TARGETS
- Trevor Lawrence QB14
- Dak Prescott QB16
- C.J. Stroud QB17
- Geno Smith QB22
- Joe Burrow QB23
- Gardner Minshew QB25
- Bryce Young QB27
- Daniel Jones QB31
- Will Levis QB36
- Logan Thomas TE11
- Kyle Pitts TE12
- Jake Ferguson TE15
- David Njoku TE17
- Dalton Kincaid TE18
- Trey McBride TE19
Honorable Mention:
- Justin Fields QB19
RB “BUY” TRADE TARGETS
- Tony Pollard RB18
- David Montgomery RB20
- Jerome Ford RB21
- Joe Mixon RB22
- Saquon Barkley QB23
- Javonte Williams RB28
- Austin Ekeler RB29
- Chuba Hubbard RB36
- Kareem Hunt RB37
- Tyjae Spears RB40
- Jonathan Taylor RB44
- Aaron Jones RB45
- Emari Demercado RB49
- Roschon Johnson RB54
- Zach Charbonnet RB61
Honorable Mention:
- James Conner RB31
WR “BUY” TRADE TARGETS
- Gabriel Davis WR21
- DeVonta Smith WR24
- Jaylen Waddle WR26
- DeAndre Hopkins WR27
- Terry McLaurin WR28
- Chris Olave WR30
- Josh Downs WR31
- Calvin Ridley WR35
- Tyler Lockett WR36
- Rashee Rice WR43
- DK Metcalf WR45
- Deebo Samuel WR48
- Jahan Dotson WR51
- Cooper Kupp WR55
- Tee Higgins WR58
Honorable Mention:
- Tank Dell WR50
TOP SELLS (TRADE AWAY)
To qualify for this “sell-high” list:
- WRs must be ranked inside the top 20
- RBs must be ranked inside the top 15
- QBs/TEs must be ranked inside the top 10
QB/TE “SELL” IN TRADES
- Cole Kmet TE6
- Darren Waller TE9
- Sam Howell QB8
- Jared Goff QB9
- Brock Purdy QB10
Honorable Mention:
- Justin Herbert QB7
RB/WR “SELL” IN TRADES
- Bijan Robinson RB11
- Josh Jacobs RB10
- Kenneth Walker RB6
- Zack Moss RB4
- Raheem Mostert RB3
- Marquise Brown WR20
- Jakobi Meyers WR19
- Christian Kirk WR18
- Justin Jefferson WR17
- Nico Collins WR15
- Davante Adams WR14
- Mike Evans WR13
- Jordan Addison WR10
- DJ Moore WR6
- Puka Nacua WR4
Honorable Mention:
- Adam Thielen WR8
Waiver Wire Rankings powered by FantasyProsECR ™ - Expert Consensus Rankings
Chris Dell: cdell@post-gazette.com and Twitter @MaddJournalist





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.