Chris Dell is the founder of BettingPredators.com, as well as the lead fantasy football and sports betting analyst on ESPN 97.5’s “Late Hits.” He’s also our new sports editor at the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. In his new weekly “Post-Gazette Fantasy Football Favorites” column, Chris will break down his top fantasy players and strategies to win your leagues, in addition to some prop bets along the way. Please note: This article should be considered opinion, not gambling advice.
Welcome to the Week 5 edition of our ‘Post-Gazette Fantasy Fallout’ series, which focuses on waiver wire targets, roster management and trade strategies to help win your leagues. Every week, we’ll take a deep dive into the waiver wire waters — and the often-murky trade market streets — to help you identify top players to add, drop, and consider for both buying low and selling high.
For the sake of brevity (and reality, for most of us), all waiver wire recommendation writeups below will be set to players who are owned in 25% or less of ESPN leagues as of every Tuesday (the day before most leagues run waivers). When it comes to players to cut, on the other hand, we’ll focus on players owned in 50% or more of leagues.
Please note: League sizes, scoring formats, and waiver wire options vary wildly, so if you don’t see a player listed below that you’re considering adding or dropping (or including in a trade), feel free to send me an email (cdell@post-gazette.com) or send a comment or message on X/Twitter (@MaddJournalist). I’ve also included my complete list of FantasyPros waiver wire rankings at the bottom of this article, which includes players who cross our 25% ownership threshold.
MUST-ADDS
(must be owned in 25% or less of ESPN leagues)
TE. Jake Ferguson, Cowboys (24.6% owned)
I told you to draft him back in August. In case you missed it — or drafted an earlier-round TE — then it’s time to fully buy into the man, the myth, the 2023 legend … Jake Ferguson. The “Ferg-Daddy” ranks seventh in the league in TE targets (25) through four weeks and tied for sixth in TE receptions (17). He had the fourth-most receiving yards for TEs in Week 4 on the heels of a career-best 7 targets, 7 catches, 77 receiving yards line (7-7-77). Before the season began, Dak Prescott called Ferguson a soon-to-be “big-time player in this league,” which comes from a QB who might love throwing to TEs more than any signal-caller in the NFL. The TE position in Dallas before 2023 had seen an average of 120+ targets over the past four seasons, with the “starter” receiving 90+ targets per year. Dak also went so far as to target TEs on a league-high 25%+ of his passes in 2022. The Ferg-Daddy is 6-foot-5, 250-pounds and has already emerged as a red zone go-to threat for Dak this season, ranking top 10 in the NFL in targets inside the 10-yard line. It’s not often you can pick up a top-10 TE option off waivers ahead of Week 5. I have Ferguson ranked firmly ahead rest-of-season over the likes of Kyle Pitts, Dallas Goedert, Darren Waller, etc. If TE is your biggest need, then prioritize Ferguson. He’s an every-week start.
Recommended FAAB bid: up to 25%
RB. Jaleel McLaughlin, Broncos (0.7%)
Oh, how Sean Payton loves his pet projects. The undrafted McLaughlin out of Youngstown St. is next in line for Payton’s house of fantasy fun, as we saw him rival Samaje Perine in total snaps, routes run and touches in Week 4 after starter Javonte Williams left early with a hip injury. This early in the week, it’s unclear how serious (or unserious) Williams’ injury is, which is why we’re not breaking the bank here to get McLaughlin. Still, he’s one of the top two RBs on this must-add waiver wire list for a reason. McLaughlin may be undersized at 5’8” and 187 pounds, but he’s showed explosiveness in the Broncos’ come-from-behind victory over the Chicago Bears on Sunday. McLaughlin rushed for a team-high 72 yards on just seven carries — including a long gain of 31 yards — and hauled in a 3-3-32 receiving line to go along with a score through the air. His yards per carry (7.1) is already nearly double that of both Williams and Perine. Case in point: the kid’s got juice. He might not be the starter in the short term or long term, but he could be, and we play fantasy football based on the potential ceiling outcomes of those potential unknowns. I’d be comfortable bidding up to 25-30% if desperate for RB help.
Recommended FAAB bid: up to 25%
WR. Michael Wilson, Cardinals (1.5%)
The rookie Wilson exploded onto the fantasy football scene in Week 4, hauling in 7-7-76 with two touchdowns to boot. This Cardinals offense has impressed so far in 2023, as has QB Joshua Dobbs, and it’s Wilson who has benefitted as one of the top three targets in the passing game this season. Wilson, a third-round draft pick out of Stanford, trails Marquise Brown by just yards for the team lead in receiving yards (239 to 237) and is third on the team in both targets (16) and receptions (14), catching a ridiculously elite 87.5% of his targets overall, albeit on a small sample size. Wilson’s athleticism, in addition to his imposing 6’1”, 216-pound frame, makes him a go-to target for Dobbs in the red zone, and if the Cardinals continue moving the ball and putting up points, don’t be surprised if you see his name as a regular in the top 20 fantasy WRs week to week. Don’t go wild with your bids, but I’d be comfortable going up to the 25% FAAB range if you’re hurting for WR depth and flex starters come bye weeks.
Recommended FAAB bid: up to 20%
QB. Joshua Dobbs, Cardinals (2.2%)
Sir “Robert” Joshua Dobbs (h/t Wikipedia) is the feel-good football story of 2023, without question. The man went viral on social media last week when he visited an Arizona Cardinals team shop and couldn’t buy his own jersey (or even customize one with his own name on it, for that matter). He also popped up on “X” last month when he visited a Cardinals cheerleader who shares the same hair-loss disease — alopecia — that Dobbs has dealt with since he was 10. However, if you scratch beneath the surface, you’ll notice that Dobbs didn’t just come out of nowhere. He had impressive athletic metrics as a QB entering the 2019 NFL Draft, including an 88th percentile 40-yard-dash time, 88th percentile agility score, 83rd percentile burst score and 80th percentile “breakout age,” according to PlayerProfiler. He currently ranks as the QB16 in total fantasy points this season. Since Week 1, he has ranked even better as the overall QB6, which includes games against upper-echelon defenses such as the Cowboys and 49ers. A big reason for that is his rushing. He ran for a league-high 12 times at his position in Week 4 and added 48 yards on the ground. On the year, he now ranks fifth in QB rush attempts (24) and fourth in QB rushing yards (141). Dobbs’ name is the only thing currently holding him back from being a sure-fire weekly fantasy starter. Pick him up now before the rest of your league mates realize the truth and try to put some respect on his name too late.
Recommended FAAB bid: up to 15%
WR. Jameson Williams, Lions (16.3%)
Williams has been one of the biggest busts of the 2022 NFL draft so far, catching just one pass in his rookie season and not playing single game yet in 2023 due to his suspension for violating the league’s gambling policy. The floor for Williams is 0. We know it, we’ve seen it. But the ceiling is the unknown, and that’s what we want to bet on when it comes to most of our waiver-wire additions throughout the fantasy football season. Williams’ draft capital (first round, 12th overall pick) screams elite talent, as does his 94th percentile 40-yard-dash time of 4.39 seconds at last year’s combine. He now steps into a Lions passing offense rated third overall by PFF, as well as third for overall offense and fifth for pass blocking grade. In his first game last season, his first (and only) reception went for a 42-yard touchdown. The speed, the situation and the talent are there. If he doesn’t put it all together, you can simply cut him in a few weeks. But IF he does, the ceiling case could be a top-25 fantasy WR with league-winning upside. I would still prefer the likes of Michael Wilson if you need an immediate spot-start for now, but if you’re starting lineup is strong enough to take shots on lottery tickets, then Jameson is your guy. Truly boom or bust.
Recommended FAAB bid: up to 20%
RB. Chuba Hubbard, Panthers (17.8%)
I’m throwing in a sixth contender for our must-adds of the week in Panthers RB Chuba Hubbard, who saw a season-high 16 touches in Week 4 while mixing in with the now-hobbled Miles Sanders. As long as Sanders is active, he’ll likely remain the starter, but Hubbard could quickly force a committee here and has taken over this Carolina backfield when called upon in the past. Nonetheless, unlike the other “handcuffs” around the league, Hubbard takes this sixth spot because he has standalone value right now, with the upside and potential for more. The Panthers have targeted their RBs at one of the highest rates in the league, and Hubbard himself has seen multiple targets in every game this season. It won’t often be pretty, but volume alone can make him a serviceable spot-start when heavy bye weeks come. And if Sanders continues to struggle with his health — as we’ve seen recently — then Hubbard could soon find himself in a borderline 20-touch per-game role. That alone is worth a 20% bid for the young “Chooba” Hubbard.
Recommended FAAB bid: up to 20%
THE BEST OF THE REST
WR. Rashee Rice, Chiefs (10.9%)
Recommended FAAB bid: up to 15%
WR. Sam Howell, Commanders (8.9%)
Recommended FAAB bid: up to 10%
WR. Curtis Samuel, Commanders (12.6%)
Recommended FAAB bid: up to 10%
WR. Wan’Dale Robinson, Giants (1.5%)
Recommended FAAB bid: up to 10%
WR. Calvin Austin III, Steelers (4.7%)
Recommended FAAB bid: up to 5-10%
WR. Braxton Berrios, Dolphins (1.9%)
Recommended FAAB bid: up to 5-10%
Honorable mention: Chig Okonkwo, TE 25.3%, K.J. Osborn 24.6%, Jayden Reed 22.2%, Rashid Shaheed 21.0%, Robert Woods 20.8%, Tyjae Spears 20.2%, Marvin Mims. Jr. 17.2%, Tank Bigsby 15.0%, Kendre Miller 13.%, Damien Harris 13.0%, Josh Downs 12.7%, Jonathan Mingo 9.9%, Tyler Conklin 9.8%, Chase Claypool 9.6%, Taysom Hill 8.4%, Logan Thomas 7.7%, Rashod Bateman 7.3%, DeVante Parker 7.1%, Rico Dowdle 5.7%, Latavius Murray 3.7%, Zach Wilson 2.0%, Cade Otton 1.7%, Durham Smythe 1.1%, Kylen Granson 0.8%, Nick Westbrook-Ikhine 0.6%, Isaiah Spiller 0.5%, Jonnu Smith 0.4%, Terrace Marshall Jr. 0.4%, Darnell Washington 0.4%, Trey Palmer 0.4%, Ronnie Rivers 0.3%, Jalen Tolbert 0.2%, Jordan Mason 0.2%, Deven Thompkins 0.2%, Malik Davis 0.2%, Trenton Irwin 0.1%, Derius Davis 0.1%, Drew Ogletree 0.0%
SHALLOW/SMALLER LEAGUES
(players owned between 25%-50%)
- C.J. Stroud, QB (32.1%) *Stroud should now be owned at 100% in all league sizes
- Romeo Doubs, WR (34.0%) *Won’t maintain his Week 4 target rate, but still a young asset with talent for Green Bay
- Luke Musgrave, TE (34.3%) *Might’ve been the Romeo Doubs of Week 4 had he not got hurt early; TE1 rest of season
- Zach Charbonnet, RB (40.6%) *one injury to Kenneth Walker, and Charbonnet could be a league-winner/week-winner
- Gus Edwards, RB (45.5%) *Edwards ran as the starter last week; if role continues, he could be a weekly fantasy RB3/flex
- Kenneth Gainwell, RB (44.8%)
- Joshua Palmer, WR (46.7%)
- Michael Gallup, WR (41.9%)
- Tyler Boyd, WR (43.0%)
- Zay Jones, WR (38.3%)
- Matthew Stafford, QB (33.5%)
- Elijah Mitchell, RB (35.5%)
- Roschon Johnson, RB (45.2%)
- Matt Breida, RB (35.8%) *moves down this list if/when Saquon Barkley returns
- Josh Reynolds, WR (27.7%) *would be higher if not for return of Jameson Williams
- Justice Hill, RB (29.1%)
- Kareem Hunt, RB (49.5%)
- Ezekiel Elliott, RB (47.8%)
- Gerald Everett, TE (34.1%)
- Kadarius Toney, WR (28.8%)
- D.J. Chark Jr., WR (46.5%)
- Allen Lazard, WR (25.6%)
- Darnell Mooney, WR (43.8%)
- Rondale Moore, WR (45.1%)
- Devin Singletary, RB (32.8%)
INJURED RESERVE: “IR” STASHES
(must be listed “O” or IR” and owned 50% or less)
- Jeff Wilson Jr. RB (30.8%)
- Keaton Mitchell, RB (2.2%)
- Greg Dulcich, TE (9.8%)
- Jelani Woods, TE (1.7%)
- Tyquan Thornton, WR (1.3%)
- Kene Nwangwu, RB (0.2%)
- Chase Edmonds, RB (1.2%)
- Justin Shorter, WR (0.1%)
- Aaron Rodgers, QB (17.3%)
- Kyler Murray, QB (15.5%)
MUST-CUTS: PLAYERS TO DROP
(must be owned in 50% or more of ESPN leagues)
- JuJu Smith-Schuster, WR (52.5%) *stop it already and let it go; let your opponent add JuJu and suffer the consequences
- Dalvin Cook, RB (77.9%) *even if he were the only NYJ back left, he’d still be unusable
- A.J. Dillon, RB (74.4%) *we’ve seen Dillon already w/o A. Jones and it wasn’t pretty
- Jamaal Williams, RB (52.9%) *only worth holding if you have an IR spot
- Pat Freiermuth, TE (81.6%) *The Muth is expected to miss several weeks … IR or drop
- Jerick McKinnon, RB (51.6%) *he’ll only be usable when KC trails, which will be rare
- David Njoku, TE (72.3%) *not worth rostering during bye if you have other needs
- Odell Beckham Jr., WR (61.9%) *BAL has clear 1-2 pecking order; OBJ isn’t on it
- Skyy Moore, WR (59.4%) *Rashee Rice is the only WR worth rostering for Chiefs
- Kyle Pitts, TE (91.8%) *Jonnu Smith is worth rostering over Pitts right now, sadly
D/ST MUST-STREAMS, WEEK 5:
(must be 50% owned or less)
- Commanders vs. Bears (18.9%)
- Packers at Raiders (38.6%)
- Lions vs. Panthers (4.9%)
- Broncos vs. Jets (6.6%)
- Cardinals vs. Bengals (1.4%)
Honorable mention
- Texans at Falcons (5.2%)
- Colts vs. Titans (7.0%)
- Titans at Colts (3.9%)
D/ST STASHES, WEEK 6:
(must be 50% owned or less)
- Vikings at Bears
- Seahawks at Bengals
- Lions at Bucs
- Commanders at Falcons
- Rams vs. Cardinals
Honorable mention:
- Jaguars vs. Colts
- Texans vs. Saints
- Falcons vs. Commanders
MUST-STREAMS: Kickers
(must be 50% owned or less)
- Jason Sanders, MIA vs. NYG (12.0%)
- Joey Slye, WAS vs. CHI (0.5%)
- Matt Gay, IND vs. TEN (49.6%)
- Nick Folk, TEN at IND (10.0%)
- Riley Patterson, DET vs. CAR (9.9%)
- Anders Carlson, GB at LV (1.8%)
- Kai’imi Fairbairn, HOU at ATL (0.8%)
- Greg Zuerlein, NYJ at DEN (8.4%)
- Brandon Aubrey, DAL at SF (33.9%)
- Brett Maher, LAR vs. PHI (19.1%)
TOP BUYS (TRADE FOR)
To qualify for this “buy-low” list:
- WRs must be ranked outside the top 20
- RBs must be ranked outside the top 15
- QBs/TEs must be ranked outside the top 10
QB “BUY LOW” TRADE TARGETS
- Justin Fields QB12
- Anthony Richardson QB15
- Trevor Lawrence QB19
- Dak Prescott QB22
- Deshaun Watson QB23
RB “BUY LOW” TRADE TARGETS
- Travis Etienne RB18
- Dameon Pierce RB25
- Josh Jacobs RB17
- Jerome Ford RB15
- Breece Hall RB31
- Zack Moss RB16
- Jahmyr Gibbs RB28
- Saquon Barkley RB27
- Aaron Jones RB34
- Austin Ekeler RB39
WR “BUY LOW” TRADE TARGETS
- Ja’Marr Chase WR27
- Calvin Ridley WR34
- Garrett Wilson WR25
- Jaylen Waddle WR57
- Chris Olave WR31
- Christian Watson WR110
- Amari Cooper WR31
- Cooper Kupp WR304
- Marquise Brown WR18
- Zay Flowers WR41
- Chris Godwin WR39
- Michael Pittman WR24
- Terry McLaurin WR40
- Tyler Lockett WR38
- Christian Kirk WR26
- Jerry Jeudy WR69
- Jakobi Meyers WR32
- DeAndre Hopkins WR50
- Jordan Addison WR43
- Tee Higgins WR49
TE “BUY LOW” TRADE TARGETS
- Luke Musgrave TE25
- Darren Waller TE13
- George Kittle TE14
- Dallas Goedert TE32
- Dalton Kincaid TE28
TOP SELLS (TRADE AWAY)
To qualify for this “sell-high” list:
- WRs must be ranked inside the top 20
- RBs must be ranked inside the top 15
- QBs/TEs must be ranked inside the top 10
QB/TE “SELL HIGH” FOR TRADES
- Cole Kmet TE4
- Hunter Henry TE5
- Jordan Love QB3
- Kirk Cousins QB7
- Russell Wilson QB9
RB/WR “SELL HIGH” FOR TRADES
- Brian Robinson RB7
- Raheem Mostert RB2
- Romeo Doubs WR17
- DJ Moore WR13
- Adam Thielen WR10
Waiver Wire Rankings powered by FantasyProsECR ™ - Expert Consensus Rankings
Chris Dell: cdell@post-gazette.com and Twitter @MaddJournalist





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.