There they were, the Tampa native and the Tampa transplant, exchanging pleasantries on the blacktop basketball courts beneath the canopy at Sadie Park in Tampa, Fla.
It was early April, and Tarence Guinyard was back home, back at the park where he’d spent countless hours growing up. Life moved fast for him. He was a father less than a month after graduating high school in 2021. He has two sons now, Tarence Jr. and True, with another child on the way.
In March, Guinyard had entered the transfer portal after a stellar season at the University of Tennessee-Martin.
So, on a nondescript day back home, Sadie Park it was. There was another college hooper there, a few inches taller than Guinyard at 6 feet 5 and wearing a University of South Florida shirt. Jimmie Williams had to find somewhere to play. He threw his name in the transfer ring after a modest year with the Bulls, and his keycard to enter the team’s facility was quickly deactivated.
When Williams was in seventh grade, he told himself he was as good as LeBron James. No matter that he wouldn’t see much playing time until his senior year of high school. No matter that he’d eventually have to pay his way onto a now-defunct Division II team in Ohio.
He was here, and Sadie Park — or officially the Brandon Park & Recreation Center on Sadie Street — it was.
Williams and a friend on the team started making the short drive from USF to the outdoor courts a few weeks earlier. This time, when they ran into Guinyard, Williams struck up a conversation. Surface-level stuff.
Then they decided to join forces.
“We played on a team a couple of times,” Guinyard said. “We didn’t lose.”
Neither knew the two would be teammates at Duquesne a few months later.
And neither knew then — although they both would certainly learn — the extent of grief and struggle they shared along their ongoing basketball odysseys.
‘I can’t see myself without basketball’
Jimmie Williams spent evenings inside the USF gym, sometimes until midnight, alone.
The ink he bears on his left arm — the initials AAR bolded and pronounced — tells the story. Amir Abdur-Rahim died from complications relating to a medical procedure on Oct. 24, 2024. He was 43 years old. The late South Florida coach was a star in college basketball, the engineer of a remarkable turnaround at Kennesaw State and the 2023-24 American Conference Coach of the Year after his first season in Tampa.

He recruited Williams during his final spring.
“It’s hard to — I don’t know,” Williams said contemplatively. “It’s hard to lose somebody everyone loves.”
This was Williams’ first Division I opportunity. He’d been chasing that for years, nearly quitting the sport altogether when the goal started to feel inconceivable. After graduating from Solon High School in the Cleveland suburbs, he spent a year at Covenant College Prep in Neptune, N.J., a basketball academy for players trying to make it to the collegiate level.
Williams, in the words of Covenant coach and director Ian Turnbull, is a “relationship guy.” The place didn’t matter so much as the people. And more specifically, the coach.
Williams rode the bench during the bulk of his adolescence. At tryouts for the seventh- and eighth-grade team, the coach read off the names, in order, of the 15 kids who made the squad.
The 15th? Williams.
But Turnbull knew he was talented, certainly a player capable of contributing at the mid-major level. Williams was set to attend Division II Goldey-Beacom College in Wilmington, Del., after his year at Covenant. But the coach revoked the offer.
“Jimmie was stuck,” Turnbull said.
He landed at Notre Dame College in South Euclid, Ohio, only 20-some minutes north of his hometown. Williams was unexpectedly redshirted. He was already paying to attend school and play basketball.
“It was a very disingenuous way of doing things,” Turnbull said.
Notre Dame College has since shuttered after conflicts with enrollment and debt grew unsustainable.
One game that season in 2023, Williams saw a jersey lying around and thought the coach was looking for someone to throw it on and check in. “I’m delusional,” Williams said. He did, and was subsequently called out and berated by the “pissed” coach.
He can laugh about it now, sitting courtside inside Duquesne’s UPMC Cooper Fieldhouse. But he was consumed with doubt. It gnawed at him and made Williams, who was uber-confident as a middle schooler, question whether this was really the end.
But Williams is still going.
“I can’t see myself without basketball,” he said.
‘It was Tarence’s show’
Tarence Guinyard was fresh out of high school, committed to play basketball at Division II Angelo State in San Angelo, Texas.
He was a standout in high school, where he set Lennard records for assists and was named District Player of the Year as a junior. The following year, he transferred to Lee High School and averaged 16.1 points per game as a senior.
Guinyard was a skinny kid with a penchant for scoring from anywhere, on anyone. On June 24, 2021, he became a father. He bounced around academies and post-graduate programs for some time, and at one point he was working at an Amazon warehouse.
“It was just so much,” Guinyard said.
He dreamed of playing Division I basketball. He’d watch the NCAA tournament on television and visualize himself on those courts.
Nearly a year after graduating high school, he received an offer from Florida State College at Jacksonville, a junior college that competes in the National Junior College Athletic Association. The team went 8-20, but Guinyard averaged 20 points per game and was named to the All-Central Conference first team.
There was just one problem — although Guinyard started receiving some offers, he was academically ineligible ahead of the following season. He was one of just three returning players. There was a new coach, John Putyrski, who moved down on Aug. 25, three days before the start of school.
“[Guinyard] was actually thinking about quitting basketball,” said Putyrski, now the coach of professional side BKM Lučenec in Slovakia. “Not coming back.”
Putyrski helped sort out the academics. It was his first head coaching job, and he was hungry. He ran the place like a Division I program. He knew he couldn’t afford to lose Guinyard.
Before the 2023-24 season began, Putyrski barked at the team to get on the baseline.
“I remember I was nervous to do this,” he prefaced.
He asked them if they knew the best junior college basketball player in Florida.
Silence.
He singled out a couple players and repeated the question.
Crickets.
Then he pointed at Guinyard, who started to blush.
“I go, ‘It’s this mother-[blank] right here,’” Putyrski said. “From that point on, he had the confidence. It was Tarence’s show.”
Guinyard again starred, averaging just over 21 points that season, and the team (26-10) tied a school record for wins. He was named the NJCAA Region 8 Player of the Year. It was, indeed, his show.

By then, he was the father of two sons. He’d sometimes bring Tarence Jr. and True to practice, where Guinyard’s teammates spent time getting to know them.
These days — although the six-hour time difference can create some hurdles — Putyrski and Guinyard still keep up constantly. Putyrski won’t text him about scoring. They’ve never talked much about that, despite it being Guinyard’s strength.
The two recently made a bet that Guinyard could snatch eight rebounds in a game. He fell shy.
“He owes me like $200,” Putyrski said. “I’m still trying to motivate him how I can.”
JUCO life
After a recent Duquesne practice, there were prepared lunch options awaiting the team inside the media room.
On the main court, boxes of fresh red sneakers were lined up for the players.
There were some frustrations at that practice. Duquesne was two days removed from losing 83-79 to William & Mary. At one point, coach Dru Joyce III hurled a ball up near the light fixtures hanging above the practice court.
That doesn’t faze Williams or Guinyard one bit. The catered lunch and new shoes are likely bigger surprises.
Although both spent last season at the Division I level — Williams at South Florida and Guinyard at UT-Martin — they remember their gritty junior college experiences. After the debacle with Notre Dame College, Williams was offered a spot to play at Wallace State in tiny Hanceville, Ala. It’s between Birmingham and Huntsville, about 50 minutes either way, population 3,255.
“You’re just kind of out in the country,” said Allen Sharpe, Williams’ coach at Wallace State who now leads the women’s basketball team at the University of Alabama-Huntsville.
Teams travel to games in vans, and postgame food spreads aren’t quite luxurious. Putyrski remembered how his squad would stop at Papa John’s after games because, well, “it’s $5 pizzas.”
And yet, neither Williams nor Guinyard grew disillusioned. At FSCJ, Guinyard said, if a player left a water bottle in the van, Putyrski would set it out in front of the team the next morning and make them run.
“It could be the smallest thing,” Guinyard said. “You could write your name with a lower-case letter and you’re running. It wasn’t like punishment — he just wanted you to focus on the details.”
The details. Williams knows that game. Before Wallace State played Marion Military Institute on Dec. 2, 2023, Sharpe walked into the locker room to address the team.
He glanced down and noticed Williams’ shoelaces were untied. Sharpe ripped him. The entire pregame speech. Williams sat quietly and didn’t interrupt.
“It’s really rare that you have your best player and you can coach him the hardest,” Sharpe said.
Williams averaged 22.5 points a game that year and led Wallace State to an appearance in the NJCAA tournament. On March 7, 2024, in a win against Lawson State Community College, he scored 48 points on 73.9% shooting.

At one point, Wallace State was 20-3. Williams still didn’t have any further college interest at that point. He spent four hours cutting up highlight tapes to post on social media to just catch one pair of eyes.
A week later, his first Division I offer came in from Florida A&M.
“I ain’t gonna lie,” Williams said, “I sprinted so far. I was so, so happy.”
‘That’s all fire’
Williams met Joyce for the first time in the spring of 2022 in northeast Ohio on the set of “Shooting Stars,” a movie chronicling the upbringing of LeBron James.
Joyce, of course, was teammates with James at St. Vincent-St. Mary High School. He was portrayed in the film by “Stranger Things” actor Caleb McLaughlin.
Williams was signed up by his mother to go on set and train the actors on handling and shooting the ball. He estimated he raked in $200-400 for just a few hours on set during the months he helped out.
“It was my first time getting paid for basketball,” Williams said.
Joyce was fuzzy on the memory of when he recruited Williams to Duquesne two years later. The South Florida transfer was one of the first players Joyce targeted on the recruiting trail. Guinyard, who was named to the All-Ohio Valley Conference first team after averaging 16.3 points per game last year at UT-Martin, entered the fold a bit later.
The Duquesne coaching staff assembled an initial list of 30-40 point guards to sift through.
Guinyard wasn’t on it.
But Joyce didn’t have a “gut” feeling about the other guards. He started watching tape of Guinyard, who reminded the coach of Jimmy Clark III — a strong scorer and stout defender who arrived from a junior college in Florida and helped lead Duquesne to its magical NCAA tournament run in 2023-24.
“I want him to be one of the best point guards in all of basketball,” Joyce said of Guinyard.
Both Guinyard and Williams have been effective scorers this year. Guinyard is leading the team at 17 points per game, and Williams is third at 14 a night.
But the teammates who met by chance 1,028 miles south at Sadie Park are out for much more, both aspiring to play professionally.
Asked to reflect on this young season — his second at the Division I level after sacrificing and enduring so much to get here — Guinyard lamented the team’s 6-3 record entering Wednesday’s late game at Boise State.
Williams nodded in agreement.
“That’s all fire,” Turnbull said. “It’s the steam that’s going to power his dreams.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.