A new class-action lawsuit against the NCAA was filed by 10 current and former NCAA players, suing the college sports conglomerate for its eligibility rules, which currently allows athletes four years of eligibility in five years in school.
The lawsuit is challenging that if a player is expected and required to participate in team events, show up to team meetings, and otherwise be a part of the team for those five years, each player deserves five years of eligibility from the NCAA.
“We are not challenging the NCAA’s rule limiting players to five years of eligibility to play college sports or the concept of a defined eligibility period generally,” co-council Ryan Downton of the Texas Trial Group said to The Athletic. “But the NCAA has no basis to prohibit a player who is working just as hard as all of his teammates in practice, in the weight room, and in the classroom, from stepping on the field (or court) to compete against another school in one of those seasons. Five years to practice, five years to graduate, five years to play.”
The NCAA currently operates on a “five-year clock,” forcing athletes to complete their four years of eligibility in a five-year time span. This clock can change, however, depending on different circumstances a player faces in their career. For example, the NCAA ruled that 2020 would not count towards eligibility due to the shortened season from the COVID-19 pandemic.
Tyson Meiguez, a graduate transfer at Duquesne, spoke on his experience with his NCAA eligibility. Meiguez had a tumultuous start to his career, giving him an inside look at how the NCAA operates their eligibility conversations.
“Coming into college in 2020 was COVID, so the NCAA ruled that year wouldn’t count. My true freshman year, I tore my ACL, so I got a medical redshirt,” Meiguez said. “I didn’t start competing on the field until my junior year, which was my redshirt freshman year.”
Read More
The addition of NIL (name, image, and likeness) into NCAA sports has sparked heated debate over an athlete’s rights in collegiate sports. NIL now allows players to collect monetary gains and sign brand or sponsorship deals using their name, image or overall likeness.
Duquesne’s men’s track and field team, for example, lost three of its top seniors this year to the transfer portal, looking for new and better opportunities to play at the collegiate level. With the introduction of NIL, colleges across the nation are seeing higher transfer rates as athletes move to where they could be the most successful.
“I definitely feel like NIL has impacted the transfer portal,” Meiguez said. “College students want to be compensated for what they do, and I understand that. NIL is a huge portion of the transfer portal.”
With this new motivation to play, it has created more dialogue for the NCAA to expand its eligibility rules. The lawsuit’s proposed restructuring could also change the current redshirt rules, allowing players to suit up for a limited number of games without sacrificing a year of eligibility.
The designation is popular among underclassmen who might be lower on the depth chart, thus having less opportunity to play. But with five total years of eligibility as the lawsuit proposes, that worry could go away. While there’s no definitive change to the redshirt opportunities from the lawsuit, the NCAA could shake things up if it adopts a new eligibility method.
One of the biggest groups affected by this potential change would be graduate students. With redshirt designations, injury years, and extra eligibility from COVID-19, some students have the opportunity to play collegiate sports while pursuing a graduate degree.
If a player can play all five years while pursuing their undergraduate degree, the need and availability of graduate students would likely disappear. According to the National Football Foundation, there are 3,695 graduate students playing college football this season across 304 schools, marking all-time highs for each metric.
Big names in college football like Garrett Nussmeier, Carson Beck, Luke Altmyer and Diego Pavia are all playing as graduate students this year. If this proposed change was made, some of these players and many of the current 3,695 could no longer play as a graduate student, or would have limited time to play based on how they used their eligibility in years prior.
Duquesne currently has 14 redshirted players and 17 graduate students on its football roster. If the NCAA were to adopt this rule change, it could greatly impact Duquesne’s current rosters, apart from football. Many teams rely on fifth- or sixth-year seniors or graduate students for leadership, like sixth-year senior wide receiver Joey Isabella.
Meiguez is now in his fourth year playing collegiate football, on his third team. He started his career and graduated from Georgia Tech, played one year at Murray State, then came to Duquesne for his final year. Throughout all his trials and tribulations, he maintained a good relationship with the NCAA, and he’s happy with how his collegiate career shaped out.
“Through my experience, I completely understand the process and how many years I had,” Meringue said. “I had a good experience with my eligibility, and it worked out for me.”
It’ll be interesting to see how the NCAA responds to such an ambitious class-action lawsuit. If the suit goes through, the landscape of college athletics will once again be flipped on its head. For now, it’s only a matter of time.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.