Welcome to Paul Zeise’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life and everything in between. You can also chat about all sports with Paul at noon Thursdays. If you want to ask a question, tweet him @paulzeise or email him at pzeise@post-gazette.com.

Let’s get started:

Marty: I have a hypothetical question. If a team would have offered the Steelers the same package that the Broncos gave the Seahawks for Russell Wilson, would they have taken it? Also, do you think they should have done that?

Zeise: Two first-round picks, two second-round picks, three players and they swapped a fifth for a fourth? Absolutely. And, if they didn’t make that deal they should have all been fired. I said back then that the Steelers should not sign another extension for Roethlisberger but instead trade him while he still had a lot of value. I was crushed for saying the three-year deal they gave him was throwing money away that he would not justify that contract. And here we are five years later and the Steelers have as many playoff wins as they did five years ago. It is bad business to marry yourself to an aging quarterback, particularly when teams are willing to give a king’s ransom to you for one.

Advertise with us

Amy: Given the most recent developments with respect to Aaron Rodgers and Russell Wilson are the Steelers now in the situation that they might have to consider Deshaun Watson?

Zeise: They already should have been considering Watson. At some point the legal situation, which seems to be slowly clearing up, has to go away. Watson is a stat quarterback who is still young and because he has some legal issues, he probably will come at a reduced rate. They also have the ability to get Mitch Trubisky or Carson Wentz so there are still some good options.

Tom: Do you think the Steelers will go offensive line or defensive line in the first round?

Zeise: Yes. And if you are asking me to guess which side of the ball they draft, I will say defensive line in the first round, offensive line in the second. But, yes, I do believe they will go with a big guy first.

Jim J: I know what you have written and said about Jeff Capel but given how the season ended and looking at the roster what is real argument to bring him back? The money? I just think he has to hit lightning in a bottle in recruiting and have everything go right just to get to 20 wins. Aren’t we just pushing the ball down the road one more year by bringing him back?

Advertise with us

Zeise: The hope is he can do at Pitt what Steve Forbes has done at Wake Forest. And that is grab a bunch of transfers who all fit together and transform the team into one of the best on the ACC. Is it a long shot? Yes. Is it impossible? No. And at $15 million buyout, that’s a gamble worth taking. It is a faster route back to respectability than starting over and Capel has done a reasonably good job of rebuilding the foundation so I would give him another year to see what he can do.

Engstock: In last week's chat, someone thought that John Wooden, not Mike Krzyzewski, was the greatest ever college basketball coach. You said Wooden got so successful only after someone started paying top recruits to go to UCLA. My question is you think that hasn't happened at Duke, or really any other major basketball power?

Zeise: Well let’s see, we found out thanks to the FBI/adidas scandal the going rate for the top prospects was between $100,000 and $150,000 but we are supposed to believe the guys who go to Duke and Kentucky, the two programs who get the most blue chippers, are doing so because they want to wear blue. The thing is Coach K and everyone else has operated in that climate his entire time. John Wooden was a good coach until he started getting help from the bag man.

David N.: What is Coach K’s record against Pitt?

Zeise: He is 8-3 against Pitt. His three losses are the Levance Fields game at the Garden, during Jamie Dixon’s last year and to Capel a couple of year ago.

Advertise with us

Kelly: Do you admire Phil Kessel for wanting to keep his consecutive games streak alive and be at the birth of his child or do you think it cheapens his streak?

Zeise: I think it is a farce and makes the consecutive games streak a farce. He played one shift for 30 seconds and left to go to the hospital. What is the point of that? If I was his teammate or coach, I would be fuming. His streak now is meaningless.

Drew: Why does basketball allow instant replays for fouls? In no other sport does that happen.

Zeise: You could have put the period at the end of replays and the sentence would still be good with me. I hate replay in all sports. I especially hate it in basketball, and those reviews you are talking about are absurd. Basketball is a game that flows and is back and forth — until the last two minutes then it gets ruined by reviews and replays and fouls. Get rid of it now.

Chad: With technology advancing at a rapid rate, do you believe that someday in the future we will see instant replay at some/all high-school sporting events?

Advertise with us

Zeise: Let’s hope not. With all the things that are argued against a shot clock, which is something high school basketball desperately needs, I believe there is no chance of replay coming to high schools. And, I’m just fine with that because replay is ruining sports.

Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com or Twitter: @paulzeise