Laina Connor wants her players to be free to express the intricacies of their personalities.
When it comes to her junior pitcher and designated player, Bethany Rodman, the Muskingum softball coach said she is enjoying the show — however that may be manifested on a daily basis.
“She is so much fun,” Connor said. “She does not take herself too seriously. She brings a lot of energy to our team and truly is part of the heartbeat of our team because of her personality. One minute she can be dancing and singing, and then the next minute she’s out and dominating in the pitching [circle] or hitting a grand slam.
“She’s really kind of hitting her stride in being able to bring her personality to the field every day.”
The Rodman show has been sweet so far this season.
The former Shaler standout is doing it all for the NCAA Division III Ohio Athletic Conference Fighting Muskies (18-4, 3-0), who are currently ranked No. 25 in the nation. She has an 8-0 mound record with a 2.13 ERA, 0.96 WHIP, 31 strikeouts and just 12 walks.
Read More
Rodman is also hitting .455 with a .659 slugging percentage, 14 RBIs, three doubles and two home runs.
“We knew what she was capable of,” Connor said. “I think we have put a lot of great pieces together as a full team to help her as well. Our offense has really done a great job this year, too, but she’s just really focused on executing, hitting her spots, and I think that has been the biggest difference for her this year in seeing the jump in those numbers and in the winning and all of those things.”
Coming into this week, Rodman was tied with Mount Union pitcher Kendyll Cahill for the OAC’s lowest ERA, while leading the conference with a .208 opponent batting average and 16 strikeouts with the batter looking. She ranks third in the OAC with 65⅔ innings and her eight mound wins are second in the conference behind Cahill’s 10.
Rodman said she is equally as proud to also contribute at the plate, as her batting average and slugging percentage both rank third on her team. She remains in Connor’s batting order on days she pitches and also serves as Muskingum’s designated player for games she isn’t in the circle.
“I feel like I can just be myself with my team,” said Rodman, who helped lead Shaler to the WPIAL Class 5A semifinals and PIAA final as a senior in 2023. “They always have my back, and they’re always pushing me to do better. I mean, without my team, I am nothing. I just feel like that just makes us go a long way.”
Rodman was named the Post-Gazette’s Class 5A Player of the Year as a senior in 2023 after accumulating a 14-0 record on the mound with a 2.79 ERA and 51 strikeouts in 49⅔ innings. She was also one of the WPIAL’s most productive hitters that season with a .591 batting average, nine doubles, 12 home runs and 45 RBIs.
Shaler coach Tom Sorce said Rodman was one of the players most crucial to the success the Titans have accrued during his tenure with the team.
“She battled,” he said. “She resurrected our program down here from when I took over. She resurrected it, she started it, to get it back to where we are competing every year for some kind of road to the championship.”
Rodman transitioned to Muskingum, where she was 5-3 with a 3.52 ERA as a freshman before beginning to show signs of breaking out as a sophomore a year ago, when she was 8-9 with a 3.78 ERA and 44 strikeouts.
“I’ve been putting the extra work in,” Rodman said. “I go to the field when we’re not practicing. I’m always hitting off the tee on the field. I realized I’ve had good years before this, but I feel like everything is clicking. I’m a junior now, an upperclassman, and I feel that for my teammates to put in the extra work, too, I have to show it and that we all want it.
Aside from locating her fastball, Rodman said she has worked to develop her curveball, a rise ball and her changeup this season.
“My big thing in the offseason was working on my changeup,” she said. “It’s been a working thing since I've got here. We switched changeups a lot. I knew going into this season that was going to be my biggest thing to get batters off balance because I’ve seen them for two years.”
Connor said she is proud of the work Rodman has put in to develop her game.
“I think she can be a contender for (OAC) Pitcher of the Year if we keep doing the things that we have been doing so far, which would be really exciting,” she said. “I want us to get on another postseason run, and the way she has been executing has put us in position for that.”
Rodman, too, said she is looking to lead Muskingum back to the NCAA tournament for the first time since 2024 – all while having a little fun along the way.
“I feel that I always have to be the laughter,” she said. “ I’m always falling, I’m always doing the stupid stuff, and I feel like that just keeps us loose and we play our best.”
As much fun as she likes to have, though, make no mistake, Rodman is serious about the potential surrounding her team.
“We just want to keep things rolling,” she said. “We aren’t at our full potential yet. I think if we just keep working at getting better, we are going to make it. We made it to the [NCAA] Super Regionals my freshman year. I think we just want to get there and get further.
“We are all about family and doing things for each other,” she added. “Getting that far, we can just lean on each other.”
Notables
• Mars graduate Jackson Krock and Pine-Richland product Liam Varmecky helped the Hamilton College men’s hockey team upset three-time defending NCAA Division III national champion Hobart to capture the 2026 title Sunday night. Krock scored eight goals with 14 assists this season, while Varmecky tallied two goals and three assists on the year.
• American University senior midfielder Reagan Murdoch, a Mt. Lebanon product, is among her team’s leading scorers. The 2021 Post-Gazette girls lacrosse Player of the Year has scored a team-high 30 goals with one assist so far this season.
• Grove City junior middle blocker Andrew Kessler, a Penn-Trafford graduate, was named the Presidents’ Athletic Conference men’s volleyball Defensive Player of the Week. He averaged 1.11 blocks per set last week while also recording seven total blocks, two digs and two twin kills against Chatham last Wednesday.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.