Pitt faced something of a no-win situation when guard Cam Johnson sought a graduate transfer to conference foe North Carolina over the summer.
Allow Johnson to leave without restriction and Pitt would have to compete directly against a guy it recruited and developed now wearing the colors of the stacked and defending national champion Tar Heels. Try to block the transfer and Pitt would face an onslaught of scathing criticism from grandstanding media types like ESPN’s Jay Bilas, who has made a cottage industry of performative outrage when universities attempt to protect their own interests in some very narrow circumstances like Pitt’s in the Johnson case.
Pitt ended up getting the worst of both worlds when it attempted to force Johnson to sit out a year for transferring to an ACC institution before the NCAA said Pitt must either block the transfer entirely or allow Johnson the immediate eligibility customary for graduate transfers. Johnson ended up getting a full release, though he’s been injured for most of the season.
Now it looks like the NCAA is looking to avoid ugly episodes like that one by moving to open up its transfer rules further, even for undergraduates.
I spoke w/ an NCAA official this week who was “95% certain” transfers will soon be allowed to play immediately in basketball & football. Could be a one-time freebie, plus grad transfer option. So in theory, a student-athlete could play for three different schools w/o sitting out.
— Matt Schick (@ESPN_Schick) January 17, 2018
Sounds great, right? Unpaid amateurs should have the right to move freely if they want to. Just as the coaches they commit to in recruiting can skip town with little more than a text message. (Then get canned and replaced by Herm Edwards.)
Like most NCAA decisions, though, this one is likely to be a half-baked half-measure that plays well in a press release but only reinforces the systemic exploitation of athletes while damaging competitive balance.
Let’s start with the players. They should be paid. They should be able to control and profit from their likenesses. This was true before the Cam Johnson incident. It will be true until they are.
Rule changes like this are bread crumbs by comparison, intended to mollify rather than address the root of the problem.
Yes, lifting transfer restrictions would help players find their way into better opportunities more easily. The transfer destinations, however, still get to keep everything that those opportunities are worth until the player graduates. They get to claim they’re taking care of the athletes by giving them more freedom, but bottom line doesn’t change.
Well, unless you’re a mid-major or struggling power conference program. And that’s the other problem with this rumored change.
Competitive balance will surely suffer as the talent is more rapidly funneled upward to the programs that already have big advantages. When a player has a nice freshman year? Goodbye Duquesne, hello Pitt. When that same player has a true breakout for the Panthers as a junior? Time for a graduate transfer from Oakland to Chapel Hill.
This is how minor leagues work. Not competitions where 300-plus Division-I teams are ostensibly on the same level, competing for the same championship.
We don’t have all the details yet. Perhaps there will be some provisions we’re not aware of that change some of the calculus here.
The basics, though, seem to portend a world where the only real winners are the NCAA and the top programs in football and basketball. The NCAA avoids bad press for controversies like the one that ensnared Johnson and Pitt while the big programs get easier access to the best players in the country — even if they didn’t recruit or develop them — while giving up absolutely nothing.
The better solution for everyone would be for players to get control of their likenesses and paid employment. Allow transfers, but leave the requirement for undergraduates to sit out for to discourage the rapid funneling of talent out of the lower ranks of the sports. This would protect the players and competitive balance simultaneously.
Don’t hold your breath for the right thing to happen, though. Instead, it seems we’re likely to see the NCAA and university officials use the rule change to fortify their exploitative definition of amateurism. To tout it as a sweeping freedom for athletes that’s really pretty illusionary in reality.
Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.