UNIVERSITY PARK, Pa. — There was only so much time that could elapse, only so much small talk to be had during Rich and Kelly Burkitt’s first date before the inevitable emergence of the elephant in the closet — or, more aptly, the Nittany lion or the panther.

They came from different ends of one of the few things that has the power to transcend love — fandom. Rich was a Pitt graduate and Kelly was a native of State College, Pa., placing them on opposite sides of a longstanding rivalry that was once was among the most bitter in college athletics.

The topic was broached quickly and was just as promptly accepted. But when Christmas came and it was time for Rich to visit Kelly’s family — who include, among others, her Penn State professor of a father — the reality of the arrangement began to come into focus.

“It wasn’t until then that I realized the enormity of it all,” Rich said.

Advertise with us

In a region of the state where alumni and fans of Pitt and Penn State live in close proximity to one another, stories like the Burkitts’ aren’t exactly the norm, but they’re far from anomalous. Sports, and specifically rivalries, have the power to divide houses, friendships, workplaces and, for those like the Burkitts, marriages.

Their bond also illustrates a reality that occasionally gets lost in fits of rage and zeal, something that was seen with regularity Saturday around the parking lots and fields surrounding Beaver Stadium in advance of the Panthers and Nittany Lions meeting in football for just the second time since 2000. For all the vitriol and venom that seemingly exists between the two fan bases for much of the year, at least online, placing them together in a confined area – with bountiful supplies of alcohol, no less — reveals more commonalities and genuine relationships than animosity and anger.

Tailgates around the stadium were littered with fans of both programs, with blue and white intermingling with blue and gold.

Such pairings, in a way, are unavoidable for those from the western half of the state. There are families like the Nesticos, Pittsburgh-area natives whose bloodline is divided almost evenly between Pitt and Penn State. There are people like Tim Truitt and Zackery Erb -- a Pitt and Penn State fan, respectively – who developed a friendship while the latter worked for the former at a marina on Lake Erie in North East, Pa.

“It’s just a friendly rivalry,” Cory Nestico, a Pitt fan, said of his family and friends who cheer for Penn State. “It never gets mean.”

Advertise with us

Elsewhere outside the stadium, fans of the two programs could be found sharing food and drinks, buying scalped tickets from one another and, in one instance, even gathering in a circle in the parking lot to share a marijuana blunt.

Such examples of harmony, of course, didn’t come without moments of discord.

As a man in a white Penn State jersey walked by a row of six portable toilets, he loudly remarked, “Smells like Pittsburgh.” There were also the occasional shouts from Pitt fans of “Joe Knew.” That was an especially pointed slight on a day when CNN reported that former Nittany Lions coach Joe Paterno, according to a 2001 police report, told staff member Mike McQueary that he had received a previous complaint about former defensive coordinator Jerry Sandusky sexually abusing children, well before Mr. McQeary reported to Mr. Paterno about seeing Sandusky with a boy.

Those sort of verbal exchanges, though, rarely materialized into anything more severe. The Penn State police crime log listed one incident from 5:52 a.m., one in which the department’s bomb squad was called to provide support after a report of suspicious activity at the stadium. A call to a university police official was not immediately returned.

That relative lack of activity came one year after Pittsburgh police made only three arrests near Heinz Field when Pitt and Penn State met for the first time in 16 years.

Advertise with us

Saturday’s matchup was the first between the two schools at Beaver Stadium since 1999 and only the 23rd meeting in a 98-game series that took place in State College. The frustration that came from that prolonged wait was palpable in and around Heinz Field in 2016, as the game drew a crowd of 69,983, becoming the most-attended sporting event in Pittsburgh history. On Saturday, 106,572-seat Beaver Stadium hosted an announced 109,898 spectators, making it the seventh-biggest crowd in the stadium’s history and the biggest ever for a Pitt-Penn State game.

The attendance for both games signals a level of ecstasy and relief that the two schools play after an extended absence. That joy, however, invariably comes with dread as the programs are now halfway through a four-game agreement that ends in 2019. Beyond that, the next time the state’s major football teams will meet again remains unknown.

For those who made the trip from Western Pennsylvania, where Pitt is located and where Penn State has more than 50,000 living graduates, there’s anxiety about the rivalry’s fate. The past 12 months, if nothing else, have shown them what this game once meant and how it continues to bring them together.

“Back then, it was a true rivalry because the day after Thanksgiving was the Pitt-Penn State game,” Mr. Truitt said. “You missed that, but now it’s coming back.”

Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG