Pitt and Penn State had different reactions Thursday regarding the NCAA Division I Board of Directors' decision to rescind a proposed ban on college football satellite camps.
Pitt athletic director Scott Barnes took issue with the move, not only for the substance of the rule but for how the process played out.
The Division I Council, composed primarily of athletic directors, voted in favor of the ban earlier this month, while the Division I Board of Directors, mostly university presidents, overturned it Thursday. Barnes called the intervention of the presidents a “step back” in the long reform process the NCAA has undertaken over the last few years.
“We’ve spent 24-plus months restructuring governance of the NCAA to put the practitioners back in the decision-making process, and that’s the ADs,” Barnes said Thursday afternoon. “And here we are, the ADs making a decision that is then rescinded by the presidents.”
“This really flies in the face of why we restructured the governance system.”
Penn State Athletics, however, said in a statement it was “pleased” with the board’s decision.
Read More
“Penn State staunchly believes that intercollegiate athletics should be providing opportunities for coaches to instruct more potential student-athletes, which helps familiarize themselves with their college choices,” the statement said.
As for the rule itself, Barnes confirmed that Pitt’s coaching staff will participate in satellite camps -- where coaches and staff work at clinics away from their respective schools -- as long as they are allowed. The ACC previously did not allow them but changed its rule today to match the NCAA ruling.
Barnes conceded that he did not like the idea of football coaches being on the road at far-away camps when incoming freshmen arrive this summer but said “we’re going to have to be in the mix.”
“Now what you have is 25 new kids coming on campus in the summertime and a lot of your staff will be deployed to these camps instead of taking care of the needs of the student-athletes on campus,” Barnes said.
“Now it’s time to put a plan together and decide. We’ve got to look at this and decide how much we’re going to bite off.”
Barnes wasn’t sure what the process would be moving forward to try and re-institute a ban or refine the rules on satellite camps. He said he expects the topic to be a focus of conversation at the ACC’s spring meetings in Amelia Island, Fla., in two weeks.
The SEC and ACC sponsored the proposal that had created the initial ban. There was an immediate outcry from coaches across the country who contended satellite camps provide opportunities for previously un-recruited athletes to be noticed by high-profile coaches and possibly receive scholarships.
The bickering over satellite camps started in 2014, when Penn State coach James Franklin and his staff worked at camps held in Florida and Georgia. Ohio State jumped on board, sending coaches to Florida Atlantic. They had drawn a high profile since Jim Harbaugh and his Michigan staff held camps in the South last summer.
Opponents of the camps say they are simply recruiting events held outside the recruiting calendar.
The Big Ten turned out to be the only Power Five conference in the D-I Council to oppose the ban. The Big 12 and Pac-12 joined the SEC and ACC in voting for the ban, even though a significant number of coaches within those conferences favored satellite camps. Pac-12 Commissioner Larry Scott later said the conference’s representative on the council did not vote the league’s position in backing the ban.
At the Associated Press Sports Editors Mid-Atlantic Region meeting earlier this month, Penn State athletic director Sandy Barbour lamented the initial proposal to ban the camps but guessed that the Division I Board of Directors would likely uphold the council’s decision.
“I do think it’s a shame on a number of different levels,” Barbour said April 18. “One is that there’s no doubt that the ACC and the [Southeastern Conference] ... their opposition is around trying to protect an inherent advantage that they have.”
Council Chairman Jim Phillips, a board member and athletic director at Northwestern, said the board’s decision will give the council an opportunity to review the recruiting environment in a more thorough way.
“It’s clear that the membership has differing views on this subject, and the council appreciates the board’s insights into this important issue,” Phillips said. “This review will provide an opportunity to identify the most effective ways prospective student-athletes can have their academic and athletic credentials evaluated by schools across the country.”
Staff writer Megan Ryan and the Associated Press contributed. Sam Werner: swerner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SWernerPG






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.