On an unseasonably pleasant December evening, tranquility permeates Chatham University. The tree-lined, narrow roadway that snakes through the 39-acre campus – located off of Fifth Avenue in Shadyside – showcases both intimate and picturesque buildings.

At the upper level of the school, serenity is awoken by the shrieks of athletic shoes, the echo of bouncing balls and the directness of a 31-year-old coach attempting to lead 19 pioneering young basketball players.

During a frenetically paced practice at Chatham's Athletic and Fitness Center – an $18 million, multi-purpose facility built in 2004 – coach Drew Garcia intervenes when a 5-on-5 drill goes awry.

"Why do we keep screwing this up?," the Elliot/West End native and Central Catholic graduate says. "Let's start over."

Advertise with us

At Division III Chatham (1-7, 1-2 Presidents' Athletic Conference), they are starting from the beginning. The very beginning.

This is not only the first year of men's basketball, it is the first year male students joined the undergraduate population. Chatham had been an all-female institution since its inception in 1869.

Of the 1,034 undergraduates, 295 are male.

"These young men are leaders, they've come in and been a part of this transition," said Amy Becher, vice president for enrollment management at Chatham. "We've been really pleased with the basketball players. They are scholars. They identify with the academic mission of the university."

The first basketball commitment came a year ago. Guard Jack Ridenour, a Potomac, Md., native who attended an all-boys catholic school, took the leap of faith. Culture shock ensued – at first.

Advertise with us

"Talk about going from one extreme to the other," Ridenour said. "I used to see guys all day. Now it's predominantly girls. It was a 180-degree turn. I think, early on, there were some female upperclassmen who might not have been keen on us being here because they weren't used to it. But in time, people have come to accept it. I'm glad to be a part of history."

For Garcia, hired in August 2014, his challenge was selling recruits on a program that previously did not exist. Potential players could not go online to analyze statistics or evaluate recent win-loss records. No game video was available.

It was sight unseen.

"Kind of like selling a dream," Garcia said, laughing.

Garcia had great resources in the coaching industry like Ohio State assistant Dave Dickerson (his coach at Tulane) and Tony Wingen (his most recent boss at Carnegie Mellon), but neither faced this type of undertaking.

Advertise with us

He was determined, though. He tapped into the inner-drive that made him a two-sport star at Central Catholic; a walk-on wide receiver for two seasons at Pitt; and a team captain and two-time assists leader for the Tulane basketball team.

He and his three-man staff – Brian Urso (Fox Chapel graduate), Mike Sherry (Chartiers Valley) and Sean Devinney (Central Catholic) – sent out an estimated 5,000 emails to recruits around the country. Twenty-seven of those players took them up on the invitation. Nineteen remain on what is a geographically diverse roster.

Eight states are represented, including California, Texas, Florida, South Carolina, Arkansas, Maryland, New York and Pennsylvania. Six Cougars players hail from the WPIAL.

"We told them that we can offer something that no one else can guarantee: A chance to play," Garcia said. "It was an opportunity to come in and be a leader in the locker room. We said, 'You can end up as a four-year captain. That's something you can put on your resume.'

"We also emphasized the fact that they can be at the very beginning of something and build it into a success. If you can make this work, we told them, you can go out into the world and do anything. The parents liked hearing that more than the kids, but it was all part of it."

Advertise with us

As with most start-ups, finding sustained success is a work in progress at Chatham. The university's debut game – played at home – ended in a 70-64 loss to Penn State New Kensington. Five more losses would follow. All on the road.

Garcia refused to let morale sink.

"I told them they were 4-2, based on effort," he said. "Regardless of the score, I felt they played hard enough to win four of them. That's what we want from our players."

He got much more on Dec. 5 in a PAC contest at Washington & Jefferson. Chatham won its first game in program history, 71-64. Four players scored in double figures, including guard Logan Hunter of Latrobe High and Alex Schoppen of Central Catholic.

As the final seconds ticked away, guard Anthony Bomar of Bethel Park basked in the moment. After all, once in a lifetime happens only once.

Advertise with us

"We were jumping around in the locker room, water was flying everywhere, it was crazy," Bomar said. "It reminded us why we came here, for opportunities like this. I'll remember that day for the rest of my life."

Ridenour said that victory reaffirmed his belief that Chatham was the right choice.

"I'll tell my kids, my grandkids about it," he said. "I have a lot of friends back home who play college basketball. They couldn't even pronounce 'Chatham' when I told them I was coming here. But now, none of them get to say that they were a part of something like this. It's what sets me, my teammates, apart. It's unique only to us."

Four days after the milestone, Garcia had moved on – even if some of his players had not. He pushed them hard during a battery of drills, barely letting up. Some failed to meet the prescribed time during wind sprints.

Garcia let them have it.

Advertise with us

"Are you satisfied because you won a game?," he said, his voice echoing through the 74,000 square-foot facility.

A chorus of "no's" quickly followed.

Three days later, the Cougars lost at three-time defending PAC champion Saint Vincent, 82-63. It was a reminder that, while much has been accomplished, more must be done.

"You have to keep pushing yourself," Garcia said, gathering his team around him. "This is just the beginning for us."