Thanks, but no thanks.
This is what Pete Coughlin told Football Championship Subdivision football coaches when they tried to recruit him out of Upper St. Clair to play cornerback.
"It wasn't what I wanted to do," he said. "I wanted to be a college quarterback."
But what about his perceived size limitations, at 5 feet 10, 190 pounds? And that unorthodox throwing style, in which he barely cocks back before delivering the football?
"I believed I could do it," Coughlin said.
As did Washington & Jefferson coach Mike Sirianni.
Good thing, too. Because Coughlin is, without debate, among the top Division III quarterbacks in the nation.
This junior play-maker went on a season-ending, four-game tear in which he averaged 364 yards, with 13 touchdowns and no interceptions. He completed 77 percent of his passes during that stretch.
"He does it all for us," Sirianni said. "He spins out of sacks, makes big throws – we've pretty much seen him do it all."
Coughlin threw for a minimum of 346 yards in each of those final four games, including 377 at Case Western, 363 against Thiel and 370 this past Saturday in the season finale against Waynesburg.
In the Thiel win, Coughlin accounted for 426 total yards, including 63 on three rushes. He was named the Presidents' Athletic Conference player of the week.
"I guess you could say I was in the zone," Coughlin said, humbly. "Everything was working."
Coughlin helped the Presidents to an 8-2 overall record, 6-2 in the PAC. They averaged 44.2 points per game. However, it wasn't enough to land them in the NCAA playoffs. It marked just the second time in Sirianni's 13 seasons that W&J did not qualify for the postseason.
Coughlin described it as bittersweet.
"There were some things that didn't go our way, things we have to accept and learn from," he said. "But it was still a successful year."
For the season, Coughlin completed 71 percent of his passes for 3,023 yards with 25 touchdowns and seven interceptions. He exceeded the 300-yard mark six times.
He now ranks eighth all time in the PAC with 60 touchdown passes and ninth with 6,869 yards. His three-year completion percentage of 66.2 is third among Division III passers and ninth among all NCAA quarterbacks.
What's more, he is 19-5 as a starter. That total includes back-to-back trips to the postseason, notably a 41-25 victory against Wittenberg as a sophomore. Two of his losses came in the Division III playoffs to national power Mt. Union.
"He's a special player, no question," said Sirianni, who has a 119-28 record at W&J. "He's a great athlete, and he can get you out of situations that are not favorable for the offense. We averaged (521) yards, and without his play-making ability, there is no way we'd be anywhere close to that. We give him the freedom to use his athleticism."
Therein lies the rub with Coughlin. He puts excessive pressure on defenses with his ability to extend plays and to find an open receiver. He'll tap into his 4.6-second speed in the 40 when needed — he ran for 182 yards with five touchdowns — but his first priority is utilizing his arm. He completed passes to 13 receivers, led by Avonworth grad Jesse Zubik's 55 receptions for 1,054 yards.
Coughlin credits Sirianni for doing, essentially, nothing with him when he arrived on campus.
More precisely, the veteran coach didn't try to alter Coughlin's passing style, which has been loosely compared to a shot-put toss. If it ain't broke ...
"Coach said, 'I know you do it differently than the norm, but I'm not going to change it because you've shown that you can be effective,'" said Coughlin, who went 22-4 as a starter at Upper St. Clair. "I appreciated that he trusted me."
Sirianni appreciates Coughlin's team-first approach. Wins trump individual statistics for the decorated signal-caller.
"We've had some great quarterbacks here, and Pete could go down as one of the best ever," Sirianni said of Coughlin, a financial economics major. "But he'd tell you that he'd rather win. He's just the kind of player that you love having in your program."
Asked if he had any regrets about passing on a chance to potentially play defensive back at a Football Championship Subdivision school, Coughlin answered quickly.
“I’m getting a great education and doing what I want to do,” he said. “I have another year to go and I want to help us get back to the playoffs. I know this is the right place for me.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.