When it comes to wrestling, Bobby Siar is a proven winner. But there was one match in which the Shaler Area Hall of Famer had no chance of winning.

When his daughter Chelsea showed an interest as a young girl in taking up the family sport, the idea was taken down by her mother and Bob’s wife, Cheryl.

“She wasn’t too keen on that,” Bobby said.

Chelsea elaborated a bit more: “She was like, ‘Oh my God, this is not happening.’”

Advertise with us

Mother certainly knew best. That was the best move for Chelsea and one that helped extend an incredible streak for the Siar family.

Chelsea eventually found her way into softball and became one of the best players in Shaler Area history. The four-time letterwinner, three-time all-WPIAL selection and two-time team captain was one of a kind. The Titans advanced to the WPIAL Class AAAA title game three times and the PIAA championship once during her reign. In those four seasons, Shaler went 67-20.

After a senior season in 2011 in which she batted .387 with nine extra-base hits and scored 15 runs, Siar signed on at Robert Morris and experienced similar success. Her 18 career homers are the fourth-highest tally in Colonials’ history and she is one of just four Robert Morris players to be named Northeastern Conference Player of the Year multiple times.

When she was inducted into the Titans’ Hall of Fame Oct. 24, Siar became the third generation of her family to be enshrined. Her grandfather, Bob, is in the Hall as well for his efforts in setting the foundation for a stellar wrestling program and accumulating a 315-108-6 career from 1965 to 1987.

Bobby Siar racked up a 98-3-1 record and a PIAA title in 1979 while wrestling for his father. He now coaches at Fox Chapel.

Advertise with us

Wrestling was a way of life in the Siar household. The elder Siar would bring home mats and set them up in the backyard so the wrestlers could get work in over the summer.

“We would wrestle until it got so hot you couldn't stand to be on the mat anymore,” Bobby Siar said. “We waited until there were shadows and then we went out and wrestled some more.”

The wrestling lessons didn’t stop with Bobby. Chelsea was the beneficiary of impromptu sessions every time she visited her grandfather, which was often because he lives in the same neighborhood.

“He was always showing me wrestling moves,” Chelsea said.

Chelsea took up slow pitch softball and eventually got onto a fast pitch team as a project.

Advertise with us

But in her first game of fast pitch, Chelsea, 11, was sent up to pinch-hit with the bases loaded and slugged a grand slam.

All of a sudden, wrestling had some competition in the Siar household. And Cheryl, whose brother Ed Bodnar is in the Hall as well for his role on the 1980 PIAA championship baseball team, was much happier to see her girl in stirrups rather than a singlet.