CHICAGO — The National Labor Relations Board blocked an historic bid by Northwestern University football players to form the nation’s first college athletes union Monday, dealing a blow to a labor movement that could have transformed amateur sports.
In a unanimous decision, the board said the prospect of union and nonunion teams in college could lead to different standards at different schools — from how much money players receive to how much time they practice — and create competitive imbalances on the field.
The ruling annuls a 2014 decision by a regional NLRB director in Chicago who said scholarship football players are employees under U.S. law and thus entitled to organize. But the decision Monday did not directly address the question of whether the players are employees.
Some observers said the ruling effectively ends any chance to establish labor unions in college athletics.
“This puts the nail in the coffin of organizing college players,” said Ronald Meisburg, a former attorney for the NLRB and onetime board member.
Tim Waters, of the United Steelworkers union, which helped bankroll the union drive, disagreed. “It is a bump in the road,” he said.
The face of the union-building effort, former Northwestern quarterback Kain Colter, also expressed disappointment. But he said the push for unionization already had pressured the NCAA to take athletes’ grievances more seriously.
“It turned out to be the right thing to do, and I don’t regret it,” Colter said.
The labor dispute goes to the heart of American college sports, where universities and conferences reap billions of dollars by relying on amateurs who are not paid.
Pitt’s athletic department issued the following statement in response to the ruling: “The University of Pittsburgh has always believed in and been committed to the concept of amateurism for student-athletes. That has been the foundation of our athletic endeavors. We have never believed treating student-athletes as employees would be beneficial for the students.”
The biggest factor in how it ruled, the board said, was the NLRB’s jurisdiction, which extends only to private schools like Northwestern, the sole private institution in the Big Ten. The board repeatedly cited the need for standardization of rules and policies in sports and said giving the green light to just one team to collectively bargain would disrupt that uniformity. NLRB rules do not offer the losing side the option to appeal.
The board seemed to leave open the possibly of taking up the unionization issue again if it involved other schools or if conditions change for Northwestern football. But Meisburg said the way the ruling highlights the challenges of organizing sports at private and state schools means the board is unlikely to consider another union petition from a college team.
Sam Werner of the Post-Gazette contributed to this report.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.