Pitt senior Tyler Wilps was surprised, if not shocked, by two decisions made by the referees in Saturday's NCAA Division I title match at 174 pounds against Penn State senior Matt Brown.
In a bout that had four coaches challenges, Wilps, a Chartiers Valley graduate, was called for two technical violations in the final three seconds, which turned a 4-3 lead into a 5-4 defeat.
To fully understand the final seconds of the bout, a recap of the final two periods is in order.
After a scoreless first period, Wilps won the flip and took the down position in the second period. He escaped with 1:26 remaining, but was cautioned for stalling, for backing away from Brown, with 58 seconds left. Both wrestlers had a scoring opportunity during the period, but neither could finish their shot.
Brown tied the score at 1-1 with an escape 25 seconds into the final period. Midway through the period, Brown scored a takedown at the edge of the mat, but Pitt coach Jason Peters felt the two landed out of bounds, so he used one of his two coaches challenges.
"It looked as if both were out of bounds when Brown was awarded the takedown, so I decided to use one of my challenges," Peters said. "But the refs felt the takedown call was correct after looking at the video replay."
Wilps escaped with 42 seconds remaining as the two went out of bounds, but the refs quickly huddled and reversed the call. Wilps promptly escaped four seconds later to cut the deficit to 3-2, but Penn State coach Cael Sanderson did not agree and challenged the decision. The video replay confirmed Wilps had escaped.
With 23 seconds left, Wilps scored a takedown to take a 4-3 lead. The two went out of bounds three seconds later. At that point, the bout was stopped briefly as a cut on Wilps' forehead was attended to. That left Wilps with the task of holding Brown down for the remaining 20 seconds to claim the title.
On the restart, Wilps was almost called for stalling when the two came to their feet, as Wilps held onto Brown's left leg, but they went out of bounds before the ref could complete his five-second count.
"The NCAA instituted a new rule this year to cut down on stalling," Peters said. "It's a bit controversial, since referees interpret the rule differently."
The rule states if a wrestler in control locks or holds an opponent’s leg(s) and does not breakdown the opponent, execute an offensive move, or work to the upper body for five seconds — stalling will be called on the wrestler in control.
The same scenario occurred when the bout was restarted with 10 seconds remaining and Wilps was called for stalling with three seconds left, thus tying the bout at 4-4.
"I was obviously disappointed, but wasn't worried about it," Wilps said. "I just had to forget about it, hold him down for three seconds, and get ready for overtime."
The final seconds ticked off with Wilps in control and the refs signaled the period was over. But before the overtime began, Sanderson challenged the call stating that Wilps had locked his hands.
"My hands did touch, but it was because Brown pushed my hands together," Wilps said. "That should be a technical violation on him. I never once intentionally locked my hands."
After looking at the video replay, the refs awarded Brown the winning point stating that Wilps had locked his hands.
"I've never been called for locked hands in my 20-year wrestling career," Wilps said. "At no point did I think I had lost. I thought we were going into overtime. I was very surprised with the decision."
At that point, Peters decided to use his last challenge.
"Tyler felt Brown had pushed his hands together, but I felt it occurred after time had run out," said Peters, who was left with the decision of which challenge to make. "I could only challenge one thing, so I decided to have them check the clock. Unfortunately, they didn't have a camera view that had the clock in the background."
The decision left both wrestlers with a bad taste in their mouth, as the sellout crowd at Scottrade Center in St. Louis chanted “let them wrestle.”
"Ugly," was the way Brown described the final 30 seconds. "It's bittersweet. I didn't want it to end like that."
Wilps and Peters were obviously disappointed with the final decision, but neither is bitter.
"I'm not bitter, just surprised and disappointed," Wilps said. "I just want to thank God for putting me in that situation and allowing me the chance to wrestle in an NCAA title match. I consider this another life test and I will come out the other end better for having to deal with it. I'm passionate about wrestling, but I don't define myself solely as a wrestler."
Wilps will graduate in April with a major in finance and minor in chemistry.
"I plan to take a year off and then attend med school," said Wilps. "I would like to go into either sports medicine or orthopedics. I'm keeping my options open."





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.