The narrative, especially in these parts, identifies Penn State: A large university faces national scrutiny and outrage after a longtime assistant coach is accused of committing sexual abuse within the walls of a storied athletic program.
The 24-hour demand for information would be fed by an army of satellite trucks converging on a formerly isolated campus surrounded by idyllic rural scenery.
But Penn Staters, who have been numbed by the Jerry Sandusky scandal and the havoc it has wreaked, are not alone. Syracuse University is a brother in this season of discontent that will now always be connected to Penn State in a way both institutions would rather soon forget.
Today at 12:15 p.m., the Syracuse men's basketball team will face Kansas State in a NCAA tournament East Region third-round game at Consol Energy Center.
Victories have continued to pile up for coach Jim Boeheim's Orange, who bring a 32-2 record and a No. 1 seed into their game against the Wildcats. But because of the cloud of controversy that has followed the program in the months since former Syracuse assistant Bernie Fine was accused of sexually abusing two former ball boys, it has seemed as if the Orange can't do anything right in the court of public opinion.
Mr. Boeheim, 67, in his 36th season as head coach and 44th total at Syracuse, was asked this week if his team carries an "us-against-the-world" mentality as it attempts to advance to the tournament's second weekend.
"I don't think it's the whole world," Mr. Boeheim said. "Three-quarters maybe. I think there's some people in China that aren't upset with us."
Syracuse has tried to separate itself from Penn State -- helped by the fact that Mr. Fine won't face charges because of the statute of limitations -- but the timing of the scandals has made that difficult. On Nov. 4, Mr. Sandusky, a former defensive coordinator under football coach Joe Paterno, was arrested on numerous counts of child sexual abuse. A day later, in a grand jury report, it was alleged that many of those incidents occurred at Penn State's Lasch Football Building.
On Nov. 17, ESPN reported that former Syracuse ball boy Bobby Davis, now 39, said Mr. Fine began molesting him in 1984 and that the conduct continued until he was 27. The abuse happened at Mr. Fine's home, at Syracuse's basketball facilities and on team trips, Mr. Davis said.
Mr. Davis' stepbrother, Mike Lang, 45, also served as a ball boy and said Mr. Fine molested him when he was in the fifth or sixth grade.
When the report surfaced, Mr. Fine was still a member of Mr. Boeheim's staff, as he had been the 34 previous years. Syracuse immediately put Mr. Fine on a leave of absence and later fired him. Mr. Fine denied the accusations, and Mr. Boeheim publicly supported him.
"I have known Bernie Fine for more than 40 years," Mr. Boeheim said then. "I have never seen or witnessed anything to suggest that he would have been involved in any of the activities alleged. Had I seen or suspected anything, I would have taken action."
The culpability of a legendary head coach was the key question, as it was at Penn State. The grand jury report on Mr. Sandusky said Mr. Paterno had been notified of a 2002 incident at the football facility in which Mr. Sandusky sexually abused a boy in the shower. In a statement, Mr. Paterno, who died Jan. 22 of complications from lung cancer, said, "With the benefit of hindsight, I wish I had done more."p>
Mr. Paterno, who began coaching at Penn State in 1950, was fired by the university's board of trustees Nov. 9.
Mr. Boeheim was thrust into the Syracuse scandal by Mr. Davis, who alleged that Mr. Boeheim had seen him in Mr. Fine's bed in a hotel room during a team trip. Mr. Boeheim was not bashful about standing up for himself.
"Some people have said that if these allegations are true, I should be fired," Mr. Boeheim told the Syracuse Post-Standard. "Why? Because Bernie Fine is my friend and I support him? I don't have any reason not to.
"I'm not Joe Paterno. Somebody didn't come and tell me Bernie Fine did something and I'm hiding it. I know nothing."
Mr. Boeheim's stated belief that Mr. Davis and Mr. Lang were lying resulted in the former ball boys suing him for slander.
In the midst of all of this, the Orange, who have a roster stacked full of talent good enough to play in the NBA, still had to play games. Syracuse forward C.J. Fair said that Mr. Boeheim informed the team of the allegations against Mr. Fine before the report went public.
"So we wouldn't be surprised about anything we hear," Mr. Fair said. "He just brought us together, saying this is going to make us stronger and a better team."
Syracuse assistant coach Mike Hopkins, who played for Mr. Boeheim and has been on his staff since 1996, said the team has used the negative publicity from the scandal as a rallying cry. When times have been tough, the players used basketball as an escape.
"Obviously, it was a very tough situation we had to deal with," Mr. Hopkins said. "But basketball is a fun game, and it's been their release, being able to go out there and play the game."
On Dec. 7, a New York state prosecutor said that while he found the two former ball boys, Mr. Lang and Mr. Davis, believable, Mr. Fine would not face charges because time had run out to file them. Two other men also accused Mr. Fine of abuse, but one, a New York state prison inmate, has since said he lied, and the other admitted to the Syracuse Post-Standard that he lied and doctored emails to try to prove Mr. Fine molested him in a Pittsburgh hotel room in 2002.
Amid the turmoil, the Orange jumped out to the best start in school history, going 20-0. And, unlike at Penn State, the scandal slowly evaporated. All that is left to sort out is the slander suit against Mr. Boeheim.
"Back in those dark days of November, one got the sense that this was going to be something that was going to be around not only for the rest of the season but for a long time to come," said Bob Thompson, a Syracuse professor of communications. "But, for whatever reason, within a couple of weeks of the students coming back from Thanksgiving, the only thing people were talking about was the fact that they were winning. The whole story seems so long ago now, which is really strange."
Mr. Thompson said there are many similarities between the scandals at Penn State and Syracuse -- but one big difference.
"Boeheim didn't get wrapped up in the Syracuse version of that story," Mr. Thompson said. "The story never developed to the point of a culpability in the complex ways in which it did at Penn State."
The media circus may have left Syracuse, but this has still been a trying time for the school's fans and alums. It didn't help that Yahoo Sports reported last week that Syracuse has a history of playing athletes who have failed drug tests, or that the NCAA is now investigating the academic performance of Syracuse center Fab Melo, who is suspended for the tournament.
"It's extremely painful," said Cindy Letzt Rogen, a Syracuse alumna who lives in Cleveland. "Syracuse fans, we take it very personally. It's sad. We're embarrassed. It is a very personal experience. We're just proud of the way the team has risen above it."
And maybe that's the ultimate lesson about college sports scandals: Wins and championships can make just about anything easier to handle.
"That's the main thing," Mr. Fair said. "Keep winning, they have nothing to say about you. When you lose, that's when you give them ammunition to bash the team."
Correction/Clarification: (Published March 18, 2012) A partial quote in Saturday's editions attributed to late Penn State football coach Joe Paterno was incorrect. The quote in full reads, "With the benefit of hindsight, I wish I had done more."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.