Inside Carlow University’s St. Joseph Hall, a cramped gym that’s equal parts chapel and high school auditorium, is a 9-by-3-foot plywood folding table stationed against a brick wall.

Moments after Tim Keefer walks into the building on a mid-February afternoon, he sets a messenger bag, hooded sweatshirt and iPad down on top of it.

“What do you think of the office?” he asks, wearing a wide grin and pointing at the table.

The modest workspace is a reminder that most beginnings are humble. And it’s a lesson that Keefer, the man tasked with building a men’s basketball team out of nothing, is reminded of every day.

Advertise with us

His players account for nearly 10 percent of all male students at Carlow, where women compose more than 90 percent of the undergraduate population.

The season, which finished late last month, was a challenging and unforgiving grind, with only two wins to show for it. Even for someone like Keefer, whose coaching career at the local high school and small-college level has spanned decades, leading an undermanned, inexperienced squad has been tough.

“A lot of people say things like ‘We want to change the culture,’ ” Keefer said. “Well, there was no culture. There were no guys.”

Persistence pays off

Coaching basketball, even at a place such as Carlow, is easy for Keefer. Life over the past several years has been far more difficult.

Advertise with us

First, there was kidney cancer, for which he had surgery in 2012. Five months later, Keefer collapsed 400 yards from the finish line of the Brookline Breeze, a local 5K. Two fellow runners — one of whom signed up for the race on a whim 10 minutes before it started — tended to him before paramedics arrived.

“I was dead for about four minutes,” Keefer said.

After the heart attack, life developed a nice rhythm for Keefer, who will turn 58 March 10. He devoted much of his time to his granddaughter, Addilyn, born a week after the race, while also coaching football and basketball at Hempfield High School.

Then, one day in the summer of 2013, he received a call from a former student of his when he worked at Oliver High School.

Jehosha Wright was a sophomore at Carlow, a transfer from CCAC, who, unprompted, surveyed his classmates to see what sports they hoped Carlow would add. His work coincided with a five-year plan the university’s athletic department launched in 2012.

Advertise with us

Basketball was the overwhelming choice, and he pitched his idea to the school. Eventually, the program was approved, with play slated to begin in 2014 in the NAIA rather than the NCAA.

But a coach was needed, and Wright almost immediately thought of his former gym teacher who bonded with Wright and helped set him on a path to college.

“He taught me a lesson that everything you get in this life is going to be earned,” said Wright, a senior forward. “That was a big part of my epiphany and why I turned around, because he was one of the people that taught me that I had to earn these things.”

Keefer initially balked at the proposal.

“I’m not going to drive an hour down to coach girls basketball,” he said.

Advertise with us

Wright corrected him by saying it was for a men’s team, to which Keefer remembered thinking, “Even worse, I’m going to be coaching intramurals.”

Though Wright insisted this would be a real team, the whole idea seemed flimsy to Keefer. A few months later, he got a call from Carlow athletic director George Sliman about coming in for an interview.

After talking with Sliman and other university leaders, Keefer was convinced. What had once seemed like a far-off thought had become the start of a building process that was all too real.

Laying the foundation

When the season began, each member of Carlow’s team was given a long-sleeve gray warmup shirt with a message reading “History Happens Here” in yellow letters on the back.

Advertise with us

But history doesn’t just happen. Often it’s the result of a grueling process, and as their debut season dragged on, that much became clear to the Celtics.

They finished the season 2-22 and winless in the Kentucky Intercollegiate Athletic Conference, a mark that prevented them from qualifying for the conference tournament.

For a program in its first season, Carlow’s record wasn’t particularly surprising, especially considering 10 of its 16 players were freshmen and 10 were 6 feet 3 or shorter. The team had some talent and miles of heart, but simply didn’t have the length, athleticism or depth to compete with many of its opponents.

“They’re not the best basketball players,” Keefer said, “but they’re really nice kids.”

Being so routinely overmatched understandably led to frustration at times.

Advertise with us

“Everybody hates losing,” senior guard Brandon Lioi said. “During the season, it’s super tough. I’m sure at the end of the year we will be able to take a step back and realize the history that’s being made.”

But there is hope moving forward. For one, the team was widely accepted on campus after some feared a men’s team in such a visible sport wouldn’t sit well at a school with so few male students.

Based on conversations between athletic department officials and other leaders at the school, however, that proved to be far from the case.

“In some instances, there was almost an expression of ‘It’s about time,’ ” Sliman said.

Keefer anticipates his team will be more talented next season, both because of the development of his young players and the addition of some new ones.

Advertise with us

He is also known as a tireless recruiter, something a nascent program like Carlow will need. His pitch to prospective players, aside from academics, has revolved around the allure of laying a foundation. “Who can ever say they’re the first?” Keefer tells recruits.

The school’s female-to-male ratio doesn’t hurt, either.

While a look at the future can distract from the not-so-appealing present, Keefer is a man who prides himself on his patience.

It’s a trait he learned through the rehabilitation process after cancer and a heart attack. He has learned it from babysitting Addilyn — “the angel that brought me back” — for eight hours every weekday. And from his team, he continues to learn it with each passing day.

Constructing a winning program from scratch, even at the NAIA level, takes time. But after being on the verge of death three years ago, the coach is happy to have that much.

Advertise with us

“It makes you appreciate every day,” he said.

“I’m not the best coach for this job, but I’m probably the best guy for this job.”

Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG.