The NFL pre-draft process can be a bit like speed dating for teams and players, but the Steelers are taking Cole Payton home. They’re also getting to know the most decorated defensive player in college football this past season, a sturdy offensive lineman and a mountainous cornerback.
Payton was one of four draft prospects to visit the Steelers facility Friday, along with cornerback Tacario Davis, Texas Tech inside linebacker Jacob Rodriguez and Georgia Tech guard Keylan Rutledge.
Rodriguez is a 6-foot-1, 231-pound unanimous All-American who won the Bronko Nagurski Trophy for college football’s defensive MVP, as well as the Butkus, Lombardi and Chuck Bednarik Awards. Hailing from Hastings, Minn., Rodriguez transferred to Texas Tech after one season at Virginia, where he was a quarterback and gadget player on offense.
Now he’s a mainstay in the middle, racking up 244 tackles over the past two years and forcing a whopping seven fumbles just last season. Rodriguez, who turns 24 in September, also had four interceptions in 2025 for the Red Raiders, and only helped his cause with a 4.57 40-yard dash at the combine.
Payton, a 6-3, 232-pound left-handed quarterback out of North Dakota State, is intriguing. Steelers quarterbacks coach Tom Arth was in attendance Thursday at North Dakota State’s pro day in Fargo, N.D., after which Payton told reporters he’d be flying to Pittsburgh.
An Omaha, Neb., native, Payton was a backup for his first four seasons of college football but didn’t want to transfer out of the winningest program in FCS history. He became the starter last season as a redshirt senior and led the Bison to an unbeaten regular season but second-round loss to Illinois State in the playoffs.
Read More
Payton threw for 2,719 yards, 16 touchdowns and four interceptions on 162-of-225 passing (72%). He also rushed for 777 yards and 13 scores.
With his dual-threat skill set, Payton was used in certain offensive sub-packages the previous three seasons. He rushed for 13 touchdowns in 2023.
Payton proved his athleticism at the combine, running a 4.56-second 40-yard dash, with a 40-inch vertical leap and 10-foot-10 broad jump. His 40 time was third best among quarterbacks in Indianapolis and his jumps each ranked second.
There’s buzz around Payton as a result, but he does have a bit of a hitch in his throwing motion and just the one season as a starter. Some believe with his muscled-up frame and speed, he could at least be used like Taysom Hill in the NFL if he’s not a full-time passer.
Payton turns 24 in October and is mostly projected anywhere from the third round to late rounds. He could even be the third quarterback off the board behind Fernando Mendoza and Ty Simpson if a team falls in love with him. The Indianapolis Colts are also on his visit schedule.
The Steelers now have brought in two quarterbacks, Payton and Miami’s Carson Beck. This is starting to feel a bit like last year, when the Steelers hosted Jaxson Dart, Tyler Shough and Shedeur Sanders, or the 2022 draft, when they checked all the boxes to do extensive prep work on the top-five prospects in that quarterback class.
Rutledge (6-4, 316) played the past two years at Georgia Tech after transferring up from Middle Tennessee State. He’ll be 23 before the NFL season begins and is a four-year starter.
A first-team All-American this past season, Rutledge is from Georgia and played right guard for the Yellow Jackets. His nickname is “Big Red” because of his hair and beard.
Davis is one of the tallest defensive backs in this draft and would be one of the tallest in the NFL at 6-4, 194 pounds. He was a two-year starter at Arizona before transferring to Washington for his senior season.
After picking off just one pass in his first three years, Davis had two interceptions last season while missing two games due to injury. Davis, 21, is from Long Beach, Calif., and ran a 4.41 at the combine with a 37-inch vertical. Some draft analysts believe he could move to safety in the NFL with his size and range.
Here are the other prospects who have taken visits to the Steelers thus far:
March 18: Pitt LB Kyle Louis (local) and Illinois DL James Thompson
March 17: Miami QB Carson Beck and San Diego State CB Chris Johnson
March 16: Cincinnati WR Jeff Caldwell and Kentucky WR Kendrick Law
March 6: Miami OT Markel Bell
Early March: Washington CB Ephesians Prysock






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.