All eyes will be on Pittsburgh in the final week of April as the Steel City is set to play host for the 2026 NFL Draft. While most locals are focused on the monetary value the event can bring to the area, the Steelers will have a different objective. Similar to every other draft, their mission is to find a crop of young, hungry players who can help the franchise capture its next championship.

History shows that a productive draft often produces favorable results on the field. In the spirit of the upcoming event on the North Shore, the Post-Gazette reviewed every Steelers’ draft throughout the Super Bowl era and ranked the 10 best classes.

Ranking system

Before we dive in, allow me to share how these rankings were decided. The first step was choosing the 10 best classes in no specific order. That selection process focused on the value provided by the overall class, meaning a class that produced five starters on a Super Bowl team could potentially be selected ahead of one that featured a legendary Steeler but nothing else.

Those 10 classes were then ranked through a scoring system that aimed to determine their collective value, based on accolades, championship contribution and career longevity.

Advertise with us

Scoring system

  • 50 points for every Pro Football Hall of Famer
  • 25 points for for every MVP, Super Bowl MVP and Defensive Player of the Year (DPOTY) honor
  • 20 points for every All-Pro selection
  • 10 points for every Pro Bowl selection
  • 5 points for every start made in a Steelers Super Bowl
  • 5 points for every player that played 10 or more years in the NFL

A few concessions were granted due to circumstance, such as T.J. Watt being graded as a Hall of Famer, despite still being an active Steeler. And since this is the Steelers we’re talking about, all tie-breaker criteria centered around one thing: Which group won more in the postseason?

The list is sure to spark debate, which is absolutely welcomed.

Below are the 10 best draft classes in franchise history:

10. 2002 (85 points)

Notables: Kendall Simmons, Antwaan Randle El, Chris Hope, Larry Foote, Brett Keisel

Advertise with us

Summary: This group made the list due to its bulk value. It boasts no true star but still produced five significant contributors to a pair of Super Bowl-winning teams. Simmons, the first-round pick, served as an anchor to the Super Bowl XL-winning offensive line. Randle El, Hope and Foote were also starters on the Super Bowl XL team, the former most being responsible for the game’s defining play.

Foote and Keisel — a pair of Day 3 picks — both started on the Super Bowl XLIII team. Keisel, who also started in Super Bowl XLV, was probably the best value pick among the class, carving out a 12 year career which included a Pro Bowl selection in 2010, as a seventh-round selection. In all, five of the Steelers’ eight draft picks this year made a notable impact.

9. 2007 (110)

Notables: Lawrence Timmons, LaMarr Woodley, William Gay, Daniel Sepulveda

Summary: This class is similar to the one above but boasted a bit more upside in overall talent. Timmons and Woodley, the first two picks of the class, both earned one All-Pro nod and made a Pro Bowl. All four names listed above were starters on both the Super Bowl XLIII and XLV teams. Timmons and Gay both played 10 seasons with the Steelers, the latter doing so as a fifth-round selection. Sepulveda’s career was brief but productive, as he was a reliable weapon on special teams during an era that featured consistent playoff runs.

8. 2017 (325)

Notables: T.J. Watt, JuJu Smith-Schuster, James Conner, Joshua Dobbs

Advertise with us

Summary: This group is sure to raise some eyebrows for a handful of reasons. First off, only one of them (Watt) is still a Steeler. He has, of course, never won a playoff game, nor did the other three during their time in Pittsburgh. That being said, it’s still hard to deny the value this draft class produced. Assuming all return to the NFL in 2026, all four will have played 10 seasons at the game’s highest level.

Watt is the group’s obvious headliner with six All-Pro selections, eight Pro Bowls and the 2021 DPOTY award. As noted above, he’s a lock for the Hall of Fame, which was factored into this rating. Conner has made two Pro Bowls, while Smith-Schuster made one in 2018. Dobbs, meanwhile, has been one of the league’s most productive backup quarterbacks throughout the last decade, although the majority of his best work was done outside of Pittsburgh.

7. 1998 (470)

Notables: Alan Faneca, Hines Ward, Deshea Townsend, Chris Fuamatu-ma'afala

Summary: Far and away the best draft class delivered by Tom Donahoe, who served as Steelers general manager from 1991 through 1999. He nailed the first pick, selecting Hall of Fame guard Alan Faneca 26th overall. Faneca was an eight-time All-Pro, made nine Pro Bowls and produced perhaps the best block in franchise history, one that sprung Willie Parker free for a 75-yard touchdown run in Super Bowl XL.

Faneca is the lone Hall of Famer among this class for now, but there’s still a chance Hines Ward can join him. Ward, a three-time All-Pro and four-time Pro Bowler, was the MVP of Super Bowl XL and is viewed by many to be the greatest blocking receiver of all time. Townsend was a solid role player, starting Super Bowl XL and XLIII at cornerback. Fuamatu-ma'afala, meanwhile, never won a Super Bowl but scored an iconic postseason touchdown in addition to boasting a great last name.

Advertise with us

6. 2010 (450)

Notables: Maurkice Pouncey, Emmanuel Sanders, Antonio Brown

Summary: Let’s start here: Pouncey and Brown could both end up in the Hall of Fame one day. Neither is a sure thing — one due to being a center and the other due to being Antonio Brown. While this writer finds both to be deserving of the honor, he played it safe and operated under the assumption that just one of those two will be enshrined in Canton. Similar to the 2017 class, this one never won a Super Bowl in Pittsburgh, although they played in Super Bowl XLV as rookies. Still, this trio — really just the duo of Pouncey and Brown — generated enough production and accolades to be Kevin Colbert’s best draft class.

Pouncey continued the Steelers tradition of having an elite center, earning five All-Pro selections, nine Pro Bowl nods and a spot on the NFL’s All-Decade team for the 2010s. Brown also earned five All-Pro selections and seven Pro Bowl nods. His off-field behavior was an issue, ultimately cutting his time in Pittsburgh shorter than what it could’ve been, but during his time as a Steeler, no wide receiver dominated the game more than him. Sanders isn’t in the Hall of Fame discussion, but he had a very productive career, making a pair of Pro Bowls and winning a Super Bowl with the Denver Broncos. Add their three careers together, and you have a very impressive trio.

5. 1970 (485)

Notables: Terry Bradshaw, Mel Blount, Ron Shanklin

Summary: Few players have had a greater impact at their respective positions than Bradshaw and Blount. The former was the first quarterback to win four Super Bowls and earn multiple Super Bowl MVP honors. The latter was the NFL Defensive Player of the Year in 1975 and inspired rule changes due to his physically dominant style of play.

Advertise with us

Bradshaw was named NFL MVP in 1978, the same year as his only All-Pro selection. He was also named to three Pro Bowls. Blount was a six-time All-Pro and five-time Pro Bowler. Both are in the Pro Football Hall of Fame. Shanklin, meanwhile, played just six seasons in the NFL but made a Pro Bowl in 1973 and started at receiver in the franchise’s first Super Bowl win.

4. 1971 (510)

Notables: Jack Ham, Frank Lewis, Dwight White, Larry Brown, Ernie Holmes, Mike Wagner

Summary: It’s hard to imagine there being three classes ranked ahead of this one. Ham is the group’s lone Hall of Famer, accounting for eight All-Pro and Pro Bowl selections. White, Holmes and Wagner played alongside him on one of the best defenses in NFL history. White and Holmes made up half of the “Steel Curtain,” and both earned All-Pro recognition. Wagner, meanwhile, was a difference maker in the secondary, earning two All-Pro and Pro Bowl selections.

On the offense, meanwhile, was Brown and Lewis. Brown, who is in the Steelers Hall of Honor, started his career as a tight end. He was the first Steeler to ever catch a touchdown in a Super Bowl, snagging a 4-yard pass from Bradshaw in Super Bowl IX. He then moved to tackle later in his career, where he became a starter on a championship-winning offensive line. Lewis was the other starting receiver in Super Bowl IX. He played 12 years in the NFL and made a Pro Bowl while with the Buffalo Bills in 1981.

3. 1969 (555)

Notables: Joe Greene, LC Greenwood, Jon Kolb

Advertise with us

Summary: Greene is the most important draft pick in franchise history. Selected fourth overall in 1969, he arrived in Pittsburgh alongside rookie head coach Chuck Noll. He developed not only into one of the best defensive players in NFL history, but the unquestioned leader of the Super Bowl era’s first true dynasty. He was a two-time DPOY, eight-time All-Pro and 10-time Pro Bowler. He was known for his “mean” personality on the field, but his softer side would emerge when presented a postgame soda.

Greene was the star of the “Steel Curtain,” but not far behind him was Greenwood, a two-time All-Pro, six-time Pro Bowler and fellow member of the NFL’s all-decade team in the 1970s. Greenwood has yet to make the Pro Football Hall of Fame, a reality some believe is due to his legacy being overshadowed by his many standout teammates. Kolb played on the other side of the football, starting multiple Super Bowls at left tackle. He played 13 NFL seasons, all with the Steelers, and was an All-Pro in 1979.

2. 1987 (640)

Notables: Rod Woodson, Thomas Everett, Greg Lloyd, Merrill Hoge, Hardy Nickerson

Summary: Some of you might be shocked to see this group at the No. 2 spot because none of these names won a championship in Pittsburgh. This grade, however, is a reflection of their careers as a whole, both during and after their time with the Steelers.

Woodson is the second-best defensive back in franchise history behind Blount, although he boasts a better resume. Throughout his 17-year Hall of Fame career, Woodson was a nine-time All-Pro, 11-time Pro Bowler returned an NFL-record 12 interceptions for touchdowns, and tied Charles Woodson and Darren Sharper for the most defensive touchdowns in league history (13). He won DPOY in 1993 and suited up to play in Super Bowl XXX in 1995 despite tearing his ACL earlier in the season.

Advertise with us

Lloyd is the second-most notable Steeler among the group and the most-feared pass rusher throughout the 1990s, making three All-Pro teams and five Pro Bowls. Everett and Nickerson both had successful NFL careers, mostly away from Pittsburgh. Everett won a pair of Super Bowls with the Cowboys and was a Pro Bowler in 1993. Nickerson was a four-time All-Pro and five-time Pro Bowler, all while a member of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers.

Hoge was another name worth mentioning from this class, although he never played in a Steelers Super Bowl or earned any significant accolades. In all, this group might not have given the most to the Steelers, but it accounted for 16 All-Pro selections and 22 Pro Bowls, a pair of figures that would only be topped by the class below.

1. 1974 (990)

Notables: Lynn Swann, Jack Lambert, John Stallworth, Mike Webster

Summary: We all knew how this list was ending. The Steelers had 17 picks that year. They drafted four Hall of Famers with their first five selections.

Swann and Stallworth are among the best receivers in league history, with the former taking home MVP honors in Super Bowl X. Lambert was an eight-time All-Pro, nine-time Pro Bowler and the DPOY in 1976. If any player were to rival Greene for the most iconic Steeler in franchise history, it would be him.

Advertise with us

Webster, meanwhile, might be the greatest to ever play his position, earning eight All-Pro selections, nine Pro Bowl nods and a spot on the NFL’s all-decade team for both the 1970s and 1980s. Few of the Steelers’ other 13 selections from this class made much of an impact, but it didn’t matter.

Not only is the 1974 draft class the best in franchise history, it’s the best draft in the history of professional sports.